Social Flashcards
Define ‘Social Psychology’.
The scientific field that seeks to understand the nature and causes of individual behavior in social situations.
What is obedience?
A type of social influence where a person follows an order from another person who is usually an authority figure.
What is agency theory?
A theory that suggests people have 2 states of behavior in social situations.
Define the ‘autonomous state’.
When people direct their own actions and take responsibility for the results of those actions.
Define the ‘agentic state’.
When people allow others to direct their actions, and then pass of the responsibility for the consequences to the person giving the orders.
What is moral strain?
Experiencing anxiety, usually because you are asked to do something that goes against your moral judgement
Which study supports Agency Theory?
Milgram’s study of obedience in 1963
What were the 2 aims of Milgram’s study?
- Investigate levels of obedience in the face of legitimate authority even when the command requires destructive behaviour
- Understand the German holocaust
What was the procedure of Milgram’s study?
- 40 men aged 20-50 years old from New Haven
- Drop out at any point
- Learner strapped to chair and electrodes attached to wrist (supposedly)
- Test shock 45V
- every time a ‘learner’ gets a general knowledge question wrong they have to ‘shock’ them, increasing th voltage each time up to 450v
- Given prods by a confederate in a white lab coat, connoting authority, such as ‘please continue’ ‘you must continue’ ‘the study requires you continue’
What were the findings of Milgram’s study?
-65% gave full 450V shock -100% went to 300V -35% = nervous laughter -3 ppts had full seizures
What was the conclusion of Milgram’s study?
People are obediant to legitimate authority even when it is destructive to another person
What were some strengths of Milgram’s study?
-Standardized (same experience for everyone) -Confederates always the same -Learner’s ‘mistakes’ same for all -Tightly scripted responses -Repeatable
What were some weaknesses of Milgram’s study?
-Gina Perry argued that they deviated from the script -Orne+Holland argued that the experimenter wasn’t concerned so ppts may not believe it -Questions the validity of the results
extrememly unethical: participants so anxious they has seizures is putting them massively in harms way
What was variation experiment 7 and what results did it give?
Telephonic Instructions, levels fell to 23%
What was variation experiment 10 and what results did it give?
Rundown office block, levels fell slightly to 48%
What was variation experiment 13 and what results did it give?
ordinary man giving orders, levels fell to 20%
What is Social Impact Theory?
Latene developed the theory in 1981 to describe the effect that certain social situations can have on our behavior.
What is the ‘source’ in social impact theory?
person doing influencing
what is the ‘target’ in social impact theory?
people who are influenced
what is the equation for impact on the target? (SIT)
f(SIN)
what does the S stand for? (SIT)
strength
what does the I stand for? (SIT)
Immediacy
What does the N stand for? (SIT)
number of sources
What is the light bulb analogy of Social Impact Theory?
brightness is affected by strength of the bulb, distance from the light source and number of bulbs
what is the divisional effect in Social Impact Theory?
social impact is reduced if there are more targets than sources
what is the impact on target equation Social Impact Theory?
impact on target = f(1/SIN)
what is the law of diminishing returns in Social Impact Theory?
once source group > , each added person has less of an influencing effect
What is supporting evidence for Social Impact Theory?
OBEDIENCE AT THE ZOO -Sedikides + Jackson (1990) -visitors asked not to lean on railing -confederate either as zoo keeper (58% obedience) or regular person (35% obedience) -61% when in same room, 7% when in adjacent room -obedience greater in groups of 1/2 that 5/6
What is a differing theory for Social Impact Theory?
-Immediacy less important than strength -Hofling (1966) - unknown doctor called 22 nurses to administer overdose -95% went to obey despite doctor not present
What is an application for Social Impact Theory?
political influence: -adopting strong + persuasive style of communication -reach voters face-to-face -address smaller groups rather than crowds
Define ‘dissent’ in obedience.
Having opinions that differ from those held by others. (disobedience)
Define resistance in obedience.
Ability to withstand social pressure to obey authority , influenced by both situational and dispositional (personality) factors.
What is the ‘authoritarian personality’? adorno et al 1950
hostile to inferior and obedient to superior -likely to have grown up with strict parents -scores high on the Fascism scale
What is Locus of control (LOC)? (rotter 1966)
persons perception of personal control over their behavior -internal = self responsibility -external = governed by others and chance factors -internal = more likely to disobey authority
Evaluate personality factors in influencing obedience.
strength: research support (Milgram tested his ppts, obedient ppts scored higher on F scale) -ca: may just be correlational (other factors may impact) - Miller 1975 found that when told to hold live wires people with an external locus of control were more obedient to high and low status experimenters and people with internal locus of control unaffected by the status
weakness: Schurz: asked to blast painful ultrasound on female students, fully obedient and resistive ppts had similar LOC on questionnaire
-APPLICATION: field of human resources: some jobs require higher obedience levels, using LOC scale to recruit
What impact does gender have on obedience?
-Women are more obedient than men (Sheridon + King = electric shock puppies, 100% females 54% males obeyed, (women did appear more distressed)
-Men more obedient than women (Kilham + Mann, replicated Milgram’s study = 40% males, 16% females fully obedient, even less when asked to shock another woman)
How does culture impact obedience?
Individualism vs collectivism -individualists = self resilience + personal autonomy -collectivists = loyalty to groups + interdependence -Power Distance Index (PDI) = how accepting people are of order and inequality in society -low PDI = more resistant
Evaluate culture as an influence of obedience.
+ close relationships between obedience and PDI (Kilham + Mann), both low in Australia, both high in Poland
- very similar levels of obedience between US & rest of world, universal social behavior
How do situational factors influence obedience?
-Legitimacy: perceived status (Milgrams variation) -Proximity: (Latene) Social Impact Theory -Behavior of others: role models who disobey, Milgram variation 17 (2 peers rebel, obedience = 10%)