Situation Ethics Flashcards
Legalism
Strict moral laws that govern our actions
Antinomianism
There are no rules (anarchy)
Situation ethics is the midpoint between…
Legalism and Antinomianism
Personalism
People are prioritised over rules
One of the 4 Working Principles
Pragmatism
It must work in practice as well as in theory
One of the 4 Working Principles
Theological Positivism
It all comes down to love
One of the 4 Working Principles
Relativism
There is only one absolute and that is agape. all other absolutes become relative to love
One of the 4 Working Principles
6 Fundamental Principles
1) Actions are not intrinsically good or evil
2) Love is the only absolute
3) Love and justice are the same
4) Love considers the needs of other people as well as ourselves
5) We must consider the consequences of our actions
6) Love’s decisions are not absolute, they are made not in the legalistic way of the pharisees but situationally
Whose teachings is Situation Ethics modelled off of?
Jesus
CRITICISM: The notion of a love that is selfless is…
Impractical and unrealistic
CRITICISM: The society that would follow this perfectly is too…
Utopian.
Utopia is often followed by dystopia
CRITICISM: It can be used to justify intrinsic evils such as…
Special Bombing Mission 13 where just under 150,000 people were killed. It has been justified that this is in the interests of the greater community as it brought an end to WW2
CRITICISM: Undermines God because…
What about his OT commandments and the explicit absolutist rules that we get from Him?
CRITICISM: Protestantism argues…
We cannot trust human reason. It is innately flames from the Fall
Ulrich Luz argues that…
A SE approach should be taken when interpreting the Sermon on the Mount