Sexual Ethics (2) Flashcards
What is the broad view of traditional Christian teaching on homosexuality?
- Conservative Protestants, The Roman Catholic Church all teach the bible condemns all forms of homosexual relationships
- It breaks the covenant relationship between God and his people
What does the traditional view of Sodom and Gommorah (Genesis) propose about homosexuality?
- The town of Sodom and Gomorrah was destroyed due to homosexual rape about to happen
- This teaching is used to show the evil of homosexual sex in Christianity
“don’t do this wicked act”
What does the traditional view of Leviticus 18 propose about homosexuality? (Quote)
- “You shall not lie with a male as with a woman; it is an abomination”
- A clear condemnation of homosexuality
What is the traditional view of St Pauls Quote in 1 Corinthians 6 on homosexuality?
“nor men who have sex with men”
- St Paul creates a list of those wrongdoers who will never enter the Kingdom of God
- Amongst this are male prostitutes and supposed homosexuals
What is the traditional view of St Paul in Romans on homosexuality?
“men committed shameful acts with other men”
- Paul illustrates Gentile depravity in Rome and reason for Gods judgement
- He argues these practices go against natural order and conscience
Quote Pope Paul VI in the ‘Human Vitae’ and how this links to homosexuality?
“every marriage act must remain open to the transmission of life”
- If marriages divine purpose is to have children, then homosexuality fails
- Sex can be unitive, for loving purposes, but also must be open to the transmission of life
-
Quote the Catechism on homosexuality?
- “intrinsically disordered”
- They call homosexuals to chastity
- The same way a nun works to ‘Christian perfection’ through celibacy, a homosexual should too
What are the two central ideas Liberal Christians use to argue against homosexuality?
- Bible must be read in historical context and not focus solely on physical aspects of sex, more about what it means to be in a relationship
- Justice is the root of Christianity, the marginalised are supported in the bible so we must not be prejudiced against homosexuals
What do Liberal Christians argue Sodom and Gomorrah (Genesis) is saying about Homosexuality?
- Argue that the city was condemned due to all sorts of wickedness, both homosexual and heterosexual rape
- Sodom was an abomination as it failed to help the needy (Ezekiel) and the NT Jesus exemplifies Sodom’s lack of hospitality as something that will be judged
- They condemn wicked acts, such as rape, not homosexual relationships
What do Liberal Christians argue Leviticus 18 is saying about Homosexuality?
- It is condemning all things which upset all natural order
- The law used is extreme, e.g a garment one kind of fibre
- Used to prevent the Israelites from doing what the Canaanites do, such as homosexual prostitution
- Homosexual relationships are not being condemned in themselves
What do Liberal Christians argue 1 Corinthians is saying about Homosexuality?
- Argue that Paul is condemning masturbation (malakoi) and male prostitution (arsenkoitai)
- It does not condemn homosexual relationships
- Furthermore he condemns drunkenness and robbery
What do Liberal Christians argue that Romans 1 is saying about Homosexuality?
- Paul chooses homosexuality as a way of persuading Jews to convert, and that the Gentile practice of homosexuality is unclean and not accepted
- He goes onto say that Jewish cleanliness laws have been superseded by Jesus’ death
- This included Jewish food laws, and by extension, homosexuality
What do Liberal Christians argue that Romans 1 is saying about Homosexuality?
- Paul chooses homosexuality as a way of persuading Jews to convert, and that the Gentile practice of homosexuality is unclean and not accepted
- He goes onto say that Jewish cleanliness laws have been superseded by Jesus’ death
- This included Jewish food laws, and by extension, homosexuality
How do Liberal Christians use Jesus as a liberator to justify homosexuality? (Quote)
“to set the oppressed free” - Luke
- Jesus tried to be inclusive to all, the Church should follow suit and seek justice
- Ephesians included slavery, they wouldn’t use this as justification, the same way they should not condemn homosexuality
- Church of England Bishop, Alan Wilson supports same-sex marriage as enrichment and healthy development of marriage
What ambiguity does the Church of England’s ‘issues in human sexuality’ cause?
“homosexual practice… dishonourable”
“God loves us all alike”
- They seem to have ambiguous conclusions which bishops are unhappy with
- The bishops asked for a review of ‘issues in human sexuality’