secularisim Flashcards
4 points to argue that Britain isn’t secular
- power of Catholic Church over abortion
- marriages still religious
- Dawkin’s cultural / Christianity even atheists sing carols and celebrate Christmas etc
- 26 bishops in House of Lords
- queen = head of church and state
- 10 commandments still influence war
6 points to argue that Britain is secular
- fewer people getting married
- church attendance has halved since 1960s
- people seem to be going against teachings. e.g. abortion and homosexuality. Laws have changed
- people may identify as ‘Muslim’ or ‘Christian’ in census but not really religious
- young people are increasingly less religious
- laws aren’t influence by bible, just common sense
what do secularists argue ?
- that the church and state should be seller age
- faith is a private matter and shouldn’t interfere with public matters of state which are decided by law and reason
why might Bentham be considered a secularist ?
because he argued that the law shouldn’t be based on tradition or the bible
to what extent is America a secular nation ?
they got rid of the idea that the King was chosen by God. democracy instead
what is a theocracy ?
- the belief that religion should play a role on government
- God comes up with the laws
what vestiges of theocracy still exist in Britain today
- queen is head of state and church
- citizens are entitled to use their local parish church for baptism, marriage etc
- we should get rid of bishops in the house of laws
what is programmatic secularism ?
- where all religious views / practices should be excluded from public institutions
- e.g. no church schools
what is procedural secularism ?
- where religion isn’t given priority or preference, but it is treated as equal with all other institutions
- there would be bishops in house of laws but not many
according to Hume, what kind of societies practice religion?
- those that are uneducated
- tribes/ cavemen were very very religious but very unintelligent also
explain Freud’s argument in favour of programmatic secularism
- people believe I’m religion during the early stage of infantile human development because they haven’t developed the power of reason
- when we are children our fathers discipline us and are morals and we want this comfort to continue in our adult lives so we take up a belief in God
- neuroses were the result of instincts being repressed by conformity to religion. We are unable to express sexual users because we see God as father figure and have mixed feelings towards him as we do with own fathers who have repressed our sexuality. Guilt
- we must rid ourselves of religion as it will lead to a happier society where people are content with themselves
explain Dawkin’s argument in favour of programmatic secularism
- a reductionist is someone who will only believe in something if there is scientific evidence for it
- an belief in God is unnecessary for experiencing beauty or morality as it is explained by evolution
- NOMA is non overlapping magisterium. Science and religion have to be separate
- belief in NOMA is naive because if there is two truths, religion and science then you might as well belief in a celestial teapot
- thinks religion is child abuse because ‘hell houses’ in America teach children what Hell is like so they will be good, parents baptise and Christen children before they even know what these words mean, schools reject teachings of evolution in favour of creatisim
explain Terry Eagleton’s argument against secularism
-religion has has an important contribution to human culture through art, literature etc. Only religion can capture the highest spiritual aspects of human experiences
Explain McGrath’s argument against secularism
- the fact that the universe is intelligible and can be describe scientifically may point to a greater intelligence, God. Science and religion aren’t in conflict. Complementarity
- there are some things we can’t believe it categorically e.g. justice, beauty. This is the same with religion
- wrote ‘the Dawkin’s delusion’ against Dawkin’s ideas.
explain Taylor’s argument against secularism
- questions why we find it easy in modern western society not to believe in God when it has been the norm throughout history
- a failure of secular humanism is that it gives too much importance to the individual and their private experiences but this is undersubscribed as it breaks down the communal aspects of society
- secular humanism is just a phrase
- come to accept ‘subtraction stories’ These are dominant narratives that tell us that the removal of religion is the obvious thing to do ; we have overcome religion and will lead happier lives without the need of God. Rejects this.