gender and theology Flashcards
what are Phyllis Trible’s 3 examples of approaches to the study of women in scripture
- textual evidence for the abuse of women
- re emphasis on significant women
- re telling the biblical stories and finding relevance for today
example of the first approach to study women in scripture
‘Amnon raped his half sister Tamar’ (2 Samuel 18)
3 laws in the Old Testament to suggest the bible is sexist
- men could marry more than 1 wife
- the women couldn’t divorce their husband
- if a women is found to have not been a virgin when she married then she could be put to death
explain the role of Eve in women in the Bible
- eve is portrayed as weak and she gives in to temptation
- this has been used as evidence to show women’s vulnerability and has been used to justify patriarchy
4 points to suggest that Jesus wasn’t sexist
- Jesus healed women as well as men
- he forgave the women who committed adultery even though she should have been stoned to death. John 8:1-11
- Jesus had a strong friendship with Mary and Martha (Lazarus’ sisters). Mary chose to listen to his teachings instead of doing domestic tasks. Jesus supported women who went against the expectations of women’s roles during that time
- women followed Jesus. Suggestion that some of his disciples were female
quote from the bible to suggest equality between the sexes
‘nor is their make or female’ Galatians.
2 ideas from Corinthians to suggest sexism
- in 1 Corinthians 11 Paul told women to cover their heads when worshipping God as an example of their subordinate status
- In Corinthians 14 Paul says women should remain silent in church
what do many traditionalists believe ?
that God created men and women equal but different
what would liberals argue
that the bible reflects patriarchal teachings and should be rejected
5 arguments for why Christianity is sexist
- in the Catholic Church women are excluded from roles within the church. e.g. women cannot become the pope
- laws that apply to women but not to men. e.g. women cannot divorce their husband is said in the bible
- God is often referred to as ‘father’ which suggests male
- Eve was made as Adams helper. Women are the lesser sex
- the gender roles expected from Christian beliefs are sexist. E.g. women should stay at home and have children as this is what God wanted
4 arguments for why Christianity isn’t sexist
- Jesus wasn’t sexist. Helped women. Forgave the women who committed adultery. Had female followers. Close friendship with Mary and Martha
- sting females in the Bible. E.g. Mary mother of Christ and Esther who was willing to risk her life to save her people
- the women described in the bible are not always homemakers and mothers. Deborah was both judge and leader of Israel
What is the quote from catechism of the Catholic Church 370
‘In no way is God in mans image. He is neither man nor women. God is pure spirit in which there is no place for the difference between the sexes’
Suggests that god is genderless
What does Luke 24:9-12 suggests
- ’ it was Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and the other women with them who told this to the apostles’
- ‘but peter got up and ran to the tomb’
- shows that women witnessed the resurrection first but didn’t believe it. Peter takes the lead and the women would have probably believed him. Sexist
- or peter is obeying the women as he gets up and sees what the women have said
What does Acts 16:13-15 suggest
- ‘the women who had gathered there’
- ‘a certain women named lydia’
- ‘the lord opened her heart to listen eagerly’
- ‘if you have judged me to be faithful to the lord, come and stay at my home’
- suggest women followers
- god relates to women
- Lydia had proved herself to be worthy
What is Hildegard’s interpretation of the second genesis creation account
- ’ woman is this the work of man’
- ’ God therefore gave him such a helper in the form of his mirror image ‘
- ‘the man and the woman were thus complementary ‘
- equality between the sexes.
the Hewbrew scripture views the Messiah as what?
- Gods chosen one
- the Messiah is a warrior who liberates people from their enemies
- Represents Gods people
what does Ruether ague about the male warrior expectation
- that Jesus wasn’t the traditional warrior Messiah that was expected
- Jesus helped his people instead of ruling over them
- She argues that the idea of a Messiah should represent a self sacrificing servant who has wisdom.
- Christianity shouldn’t mix the maleness of Jesus with the military messiah into the Christian concept of messiah as this displaced the female concept of God
explain ‘Sophia’ and Reuthers interpretation of it
- ‘Sophia’ is Greek for ‘Wisom’ and it was also associated with the female form of goodness.
- Reuther argues the early Christians refer to ‘sophia’ as divine wisdom and in scripture it was referred to in female terms
- however, Christianity has merged the notion of divine wisdom into the idea of a messiah King. In doing so, the idea of remake wisdoms has become replaced with the patriarchal view of Jesus
- Reuther is trying to recover the concept of God
explain ‘logos’
- used to define the presence of God which has become incarnate in Jesus
- the image of God in humanity and the logos of God were interrelated in androcentric definition.
- these definitions re enforced the assumption that God was male and that Christ must therefore be male in order to reveal the male God
what is a justification for re interpreting and re imaging God
-the biblical images of God are culturally dependent
explain the hermeneutic of suspicion
- used to challenge previous interpretations of a text by considering who interpreted it and why they might of interpreted it that way
- this enabled feminist theologians to reject traditional patriarchal understandings of the text without rejecting the Bible itself
explain Mary Daly idea on re imaging language about God
- if we think of God in male terms then that affects how we view the relationship between man and women
- we think of men as more God like, as being normative for what it means to be human. Women then become other and different
For Ruether, Jesus’s maleness was…
accidental
give an example of female imagery used to describe God
-gods love has been compared to that of a mother
two reasons why Daly would say that Christianity is sexist ?
- in Christian spiritual moments men are always involved. e.g. a make priest at a female baptism
- Christianity was anti-women due to its misogynistic teachings
three ways to argue why Daly thinks Christianity should be abandoned
- we should abandon the maleness of God and replace it with quintessence
- she thinks Christianity is one of the ways men use to control women
- Daly believes that Christian theology and ethics are enriched with patriarchy so it should be rejected or completely transformed
- it patriarchy is part of the unholy trinity