Schizophrenia Flashcards
What is S and who is most commonly diagnosed?
A serious mental disorder found in 1% of the population, diagnosed more in men than women, in people who live in cities and people categorised as the working class
What are the 2 main classification systems for S?
ICD-10 believes 2 or more negative systems must be present for diagnosis
DSM-5 blives 1 positive symptoms is sufficient for diagnosis
What is impaired with patients with S?
Reality and insight, an example of psychosis
What does S not have?
A single defining characteristic, rather a cluster of unrelated symptoms
What are the 2 positive symptoms of S?
ADDITIONAL EXPERIENCES
Hallucinations - unusual sensory experiences, some relating to events in environment, can be experienced in relation to any sense (e.g hearing voices, see things that aren’t there)
Delusions - Paranoid, irrational beliefs, delusions of grandeur and persecution. may believe body is under external control, can lead to aggression, seems normal to them but bizarre to others
What are the 2 negative symptoms of S?
LOSS OF USUAL ABILITIES/EXPERIENCES
Avolition - ‘apathy’, finding it difficult to begin or keep up with any goal related activity, reduced motivation. ANDREASON 1982 - 3 signs of avolition; poor hygiene, lack of persistence, lack of energy
Speech poverty - changes in patterns of speech,ICD-10 says negative symptom as reduction in amount and quality of speech, delays too. DSM-5 says positive symptom is SPEECH DISORGANISATION as it adds things does not take away anything
What is reliability and inter-rater reliability?
Reliability is about consistency - if diagnosis is reliable then it is consistent over time by different Psychiatrists
Inter-rater reliability - when 2 or more psychiatrists agree on diagnosis of S
What is validity and criterion validity?
Validity is the extent to which we are measuring what we intend to measure
Criterion validity - 2 or more different measures to diagnose S arrive at the same diagnosis
What research indicates issues with the reliability of the diagnosis of S?
Cheniaux at al 2009 - poor inter-rater reliability
2 separate psychologists who both used DSM-5 and ICD-10 to diagnose 100 patients.
1 diagnosed 26 with DSM compared to the other with 13
1 diagnosed 44 with ICD compared to the other with 24
WEAKNESS AS ILLUSTRATES THAT S DIAGNOSIS CAN LACK RELIABILITY - obviously an issue
What research indicates issues with the validity of the diagnosis of S?
Study above (Cheniaux et al) shows poor criterion validity too as it shows more likely to be diagnosed with ICD than DSM. So ICD either overdiagnosis S or DSM underdiagnoses S
What are the 4 factors which cause problems with the diagnosis of S?
Co-morbidity
Symptom overlap
Gender
Cultural bias
Why is comorbidity a problem when diagnosing S?
Refers to how common a medical condition is. It is the idea that 2 or more conditions can occur together, which questions the validity of their diagnosis as could be a single condition
Buckley at al 2009 concluded that around 1/2 of S patients have been diagnosed also with depression, 47% wth substance abuse, 29% PTSD and 23% OCD
WEAKNESS AS SAYING DOCTORS ARE BAD AT TELLING THE DIFFERENCE OR THE CLASSIFICATION IS WEAK AS COULD BE 1 CONDITION
Why is symptom overlap a problem when diagnosing S?
Considerable symptom overlap, e.g. bipolar symptoms include delusions, hallucinations and avolition. Questions validity of diagnosis and classification, patient may be diagnosed under ICD with S and under DSM with bipolar, could suggest S and B are the same condition given the amount of symptom overlaps
Why is gender a problem when diagnosing S?
Longenecker at al 2010 reviewed studies and concluded since 198’s men are more commonly diagnosed than women when prior to this there was no difference, could be men have more vulnerability or could be gener bias.
Cotton et al 2009 said women typically function better than men so symptoms could be masked or the idea that they are functioning so well means the idea of them having S is too wild
Why is cultural bias a problem when diagnosing S?
African Americans and Afro-Caribbean English people are more likely to be diagnosed in the UK. Rates in Africa are not very high so cannot be genetic vulnerability but in fact cultural bias.
One issue is that positive symptoms are acceptable in some countries as is seen as communication with ancestors, when they report it in this country it is seen as bizarre.
Escobar 2012 said that predominantly white psychiatrists tend to over-interpret symptoms and distrust honestly of black people during diagnosis
What is one weakness straight away of the genetic basis of schizophrenia in the biological explanation?
It says it runs in families but families also share the same environment
Who can be used as support for the genetic basis of schizophrenia?
Gottesman 1991 - supports association between greater genetic similarity and likelihood of developing S
Large scale family study, pooled data from 40 EU studies between 1920-1987, meta analysis and found likelihood of getting S if identical twin has it is 48%, siblings 9%, parents 6% and general public 1%
What are candidate genes in the genetic basis of S?
The idea that not 1 single gene is responsible for S, there are a number of genes associated with S, it is polygenic
AETIOLOGICALLY HETEROGENEOUS - different combo’s of factors leading to same condition
What is some research to support S being polygenic? (Biological explanation for S…)
Ripke 2014 - large study combining previous data from genome-wide studies (not focusing on 1 particular gene). Genetic makeup of 37000 patients compared to 113000 controls, found 108 separate variations for risk of S
What is the dopamine hypothesis in the biological explanation of S?
Dopamine is a neurotransmitter associated with increased risk of S - it is important in the functioning of several brain systems that may be implicated in the symptoms of S
Where are the 2 explanations for the dopamine hypothesis found?
Cortex - hypodopaminergia
Goldman-Rakic et al 2004 found low levels of dopamine in pre-frontal cortex responsible for thinking and decision making - negative symptoms of S
Sub-cortex - Hyperdopaminergia
Original version of D.H focused on high levels of dopamine in sub-cortex, excess of D in Broca’s area associated with poverty of speech and auditory hallucinations
What may it be about the hyper and hypodopaminergia explanations?
That they are both correct and both high and low levels of dopamine in different brain regions are involved in the development of S
What are neural correlates?
Measurements of structure/function of the brain that correlate with an experience, in this case S. Both positive and negative symptoms have neural correlates
What are the negative symptoms neural correlates?
Avolition involves loss of motivation, motivation involves anticipation of a reward, certain brain areas such as VENTRAL STRIATUM are believed to be associated with this anticipation
Juckel at al 2006 - measured activity levels in VS in S patients and found lower levels of activity than control group, this correlation is between activity levels in VS and severity of overall negative symptoms
What are the positive symptoms neural correlates?
Allen et al 2007 - scanned brains of patients experiencing auditory hallucinations compared to control group as they tried to identify whether pre-recorded speech was theirs or others. S group made more errors and lower activation levels found in superior temporal gyrus and anterior cingulate gyrus - reduced activity in these areas is a neural correlate
What is one strength of the biological explanation of S?
Multiple sources of evidence - Gottesman 1991 shows genetic similarity and risk of S are very closely linked
Tienari 2004 - children of suffers of S are still at high risk even when adopted by non-s sufferers
Ripke 2014 - shows certain variations of molecular levels significantly increase risk of S
What is one strength and one weakness of the dopamine hypothesis? (Used as EVAL for biological explanation)
Support for number of sources for abnormal dopamine functioning in S - amphetamines that increase level of dopamine make S worse and can produce symptoms in non-sufferers - Curran et al 2004
HOWEVER
Does not provide a complete explanation for S. Some of the genes in Ripke’s study code for different neurotransmitters such as Glutamate which seems to be another important factor (Moghaddam and Javitt 2012)
What is one weakness of the biological explanation of S?
Correlation-causation problem of neural correlates
Does the unusual activity in a region of the brain CAUSE the symptom? Could it be that the negative symptoms mean less info is passed through the VS resulting in reduced activity?
What are the 2 main umbrella’s underneath the psychological explanations of S?
Family dysfunction - attempt to link S to childhood experiences in living in a dysfunctional family.
3 factors that increase risk of S - schizophrenogenic mother, double bind theory and expressed emotion
Cognitive explanation - focuses on role of mental processing saying cognitive processes are faulty
What is the schizophrenogenic mother?
SCHIZOPHRENIA CAUSING
Frieda Fromm-Reichmann proposed psychodynamic explanation, formed by talking to patients about their childhoods
Mothers were cold, rejecting and controlling, which created an atmosphere of tension and secrecy, which developed into paranoid delusions and then S