Researching Atypical Development Flashcards
Example of researching development
The Human Speechome Project
- researcher - recorded his child for approximately 10 hours a day, from 0-3 years
- trying to see / understand how children learn the meaning of words
- done through the analysis of observational recordings of child-caregiver interactions in natural contexts
- around 100,000 hours of multi-track recordings
The Human Speechome Project - ethical considerations?
- ethics? anonymity? consent?
- all issues to consider here!
- > > of those interacting with the child?
- > > what about the child themselves?
- acts of observations - general critiques / problems here anyway
General Guidelines for Ethical Research
Voluntary Informed Consent
P is told exactly what research entails and then volunteers to participate
- ascent? - any obvious signs that the child is not comfortable
- should get REAL consent
- 0-3 years - can they really give consent? - parents then give it, you just have to look out for signs that the child is not comfortable
General Guidelines for Ethical Research
Harm
What constitutes harm?
- loss of self-esteem, embarrassment, feelings of exclusion
- do we have to be careful with children because they are so early on in development?
- DANGER - over protection?
- may make us treat them even too much or over the top?
General Guidelines for Ethical Research
- wherever possible, the real consent of children and of adults with impairments in understanding should be obtained
What questions do we need to ask when we assessing atypical development?
How old is he / she?
- if we know age, it can help determine whether behaviour is normal or abnormal
Any recent trauma, divorce, death, abuse?
- could be a trigger for problem/atypical behaviour?
History of mental health in the family?
- genetic vulnerabilities? e.g. concordance rates for ScZ
What types of relationship does the child have with parents, peers, teachers, siblings etc?
- can get an understanding / a feel of the child’s behaviour
- can indicate problem areas that need work on
Harris (2008) - Questions to ask about research
- design - was it appropriate for the age and type of children?
- how and where were the children tested?
- ethical issues - do we need to worry about them?
- could there be any issues with children’s understanding of the task?
- any other factors?
> anything preventing them from completing the task
> anything that could have hindered their ability on the task? (language levels?)
Normal Developmental Milestones
- how do these guide us with researching atypical development?
- guidelines as to what to expect for each age
> BUT what about the experiences the child has? - we don’t want to rush putting on tables - personality and experience can have a big impact!!!
- environment - plays a big role!
> this may be causing the problem rather than something within the child!
Normal Developmental Milestones
- early interventions? potential problems?
- early intervention - is VERY important BUT we shouldn’t rush to a diagnosis
> problem with labels again!
> we really have to consider what is going on in the environment and see if there is anything there that may be causing this
> how many people the child interacts with etc
Down’s Syndrome vs Normal Development
- huge overlaps and range
- ranges are within where something may happen depending on surrounding factors
> they do reach the same milestones but just take a little longer?
Research examples:
- Byrne et al (2002) - mainstream schooling, single word reading
- Wright et al (2006) - learning via imitation
Do all children experience childhood in the same way?
- depends where you grow up?
- families of low vs high SES - clear differences
- abuse vs non-abuse
- different cultures - individualist vs collectivist cultures
- single parent vs two parent families
- refugee children - clearly different experiences compared to non-refugee children
- children growing up in war zones?
What are risk factors?
- significant things in the environment that can have an impact on development
- characteristics, events or processes that put the individual at risk for developing psychological problems
Risk factors - Person-centred
Temperament
Risk factors - Family centred
- parental mental health issues
- parental relationship conflict
- sibling issues
Risk factors - School / Society centred
- poorly performing
- over crowded
- under resourced schools
- poverty
- drug taking
- violence
What are protective factors?
Characteristics, events or processes that seem to protect individuals even when faced with adverse circumstances
Protective factors - Person-centred
- optimism
Protective factors - Family centred
- stable role models
- warm and supportive parents
Protective factors - School or society centred
- competent and caring teachers
- early intervention programmes
Nature vs Nurture
Interaction between genes and environment - can result in a high level of variability in developmental outcomes
Rich genetic & poor environment vs Poor genetic & rich environment
- may experience the environment differently even though they are shared
- very difficult to debate!
- variety of different factors that can contribute to atypical development
- COMPLEX INTERACTION BETWEEN THE TWO!
Brofenbrenner’s Bioecological Model of Development
- looking at a child’s development within the context of the system of relationships that form their environment
- defining complex layers of environment, each of which has an effect on a child’s development
- child’s own biology is a primary environment fuelling their development
- the interaction between factors in the child’s maturing biology, their immediate family/community environment and the societal landscape fuels and steers their development
- changes or conflicts in any one layer will ripple throughout other layers