Religous Language Flashcards
Cognitive statements
True or false
Non cognitive statements
Opinion or subjective, not true or false
Religious language
Richard Dawkins
Religious language is cognitive and false
Religious language
Via Negativa
Process of negation, working out what God is not
It’s not possible to say what he is, he’s beyond our understanding
Religious language
Mysticism and Via Negativa
Knowledge only comes from mystical experiences
Negation via meditation etc
Religious language
Neoplatonism on Via Negativa
Plotinus
God is beyond description and language
Image less and apopthatic meditation
Religious language
Pseudo Dionysius on Via Negativa
Language becomes restricted as thought becomes more complex
All terms must be denied of God
All language to describe God is evocative and non cognitive
Religious language
Process of Via Negativa
1- Start with the assertions of the lowest of creatures
2- Progress to deny god of the attributes of these creatures
3- Ascend into the divine realm via progressive denials
Religious language
Moses Maimonides on Via Negativa
Denying every attribute of god brings you closer to him
Talking of god in any other way anthropomorphises him which of forbidden for Jews
Religious language
Aquinas on Via Negativa
First cause underpasses human understanding and speech
Must acknowledge what falls short of what god is
Religious language
WR Inge criticism of Via Negativa
To deny god his positive descriptions would annihilate the relationship between god and man
Religious language
Pros of Via Negativa
Human ideas of God are poor
Positive talk limits him to a body and human attributes
Allows understanding of equivocal language
Religious language
Cons of Via Negativa
Is the highest reality is beyond words why speak of it
Says nothing about god, just things about nothing
Undermines the positive descriptions of god in scripture
Religious language
Via positiva
Cataphatic way
Positive language to describe God
Religious language
Eastern Orthodox Church on Via Negativa and Positiva
Use via Negativa and positiva
Theosis - unity of god
Leads to an ultimate understanding
Religious language
Pierre Teilhard on Via positiva
Finding god through our material sense is gods plan
It make senses to talk of Gods love through the love we experience
Religious language
Aquinas on Via possitiva/ analogy
We can speak analogically of god because he is the cause of all things
Eg) ‘God is good’ is okay because he created goodness
We understand God’s perfection and use our language as analogies
Religious language
Aquinas analogy of attribution
When one thing is applied to a second thing because one causes the other
Eg) a sickly look due to sickness
Religious language
Aquinas analogy of proportionality
A word referring to a quality that a thing possesses in proportion to its reality
We understand god as all powerful with our human idea is power, god is proportionally more powerful
Religious language
Hume criticism of Aquinas on analogy/ Via possitiva
All descriptions of god fall into the danger of anthropomorphism