Religiosity and Politics Flashcards
Is religiosity a personality characteristic?
Religiosity is driven by situational factors
- Religious socialization
- Negative life events
- Positive self-transcendent experiences 積極的自我超越的經驗
But religiosity
Also manifested 表現 in many behaviours across situations
e. g., praying, reading, attending services,…
- involves a variety of behaviours, thoughts, and feelings
Unlike personality traits, individual differences in religiosity
Depend on people’s beliefs, whereas personality traits do not depend on beliefs
Involve an entire way of living
Bonding
Belonging
Differences in motivations
“intrinsic religiosity” vs. “extrinsic religiosity”
Religiosity and personality dimensions
Saroglou: meta-analysis of 71 studies, examine the ‘personal religiosity’
‘Personal religiosity’: beliefs and practices referring to a transcendent being and legitimized, to some extent, by an established tradition or group
Associations with personality traits are not very strong
- Agreeableness (r = .19) and Conscientiousness (r = .16) are the two main personality characteristics of religiousness
Are high A and high C people more attracted to religion or does religion make people high in A and C?
Longitudinal study by Wink et al. (2007):
Personality in adolescence predicts religiosity in late adulthood
High A people: social harmony, positive qualities in human relations, and the idea of a protective and loving God
High C people: the meaningfulness of life and the world, order in the universe through a sense of transcendence, and disciplined pursuit of valued goals
Saroglou (2010) also investigated religious fundamentalism and spirituality
Religious fundamentalism: strict obedience and unquestioning devotion; authoritarian and dogmatic religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices
- Negatively related to O
Spiritualism: emphasis on individual experience (often intense feeling), independence of religious traditions and beliefs
Positively related to Openness to Experience
High O people
Inquisitive and unconventional: question religious traditions, rules, practices
Imaginative, feel connected to nature
-> seek spirituality
Religiosity of the family/household/parents strongly related to individual differences in religiosity
Personality variables may, however, affect this association
McCullough, Tsang, and Brion (2003):
Emotional (in)stability (= Neuroticism)
Sample of intelligent children from 1922-23 and follow-up in 1940-41
Weaker association (less religious) for emotional stable children compared to unstable children when the children have very strict religious upbringing - unstable are more religious
-> Emotionally unstable children may want to avoid conflict with parents/family, so they are more likely to stick with the religious
Altemeyer and Hunsberger (1997): Interviews with
“Amazing Apostates”: very non-religious people raised in a very religious household
“Amazing Believers”: very religious people raised in a very nonreligious household
Apostates - Conversion followed after thinking a great deal about their religion; period of reason and reflection and experiencing increasing doubts about their religion
Believers - conversion was more sudden, after a period of intense personal crisis; driven by passion and emotion suggesting a strong need for a sense of community and structure
Change and stability in religiosity: How do individual levels of religiosity change across the life-span?
McCullough et al (2005): Followed a sample of intelligent children from 1940 to 1991
Found a very small average increase in religiosity, But different patterns of change in religiosity
High - increasing
Low – declining
Parabolic - religious in early adulthood, becoming more so in midlife, then less religious through the remainder of the life course.
How stable are individual differences in religiosity?
McCullough et al (2005)
Fairly high level of stability Between 1940 and 1991 (51 years!): r = .55
For shorter spans (between 5 and 17 years): r’s = .61 to .92(!)
Religiosity and life outcomes
Health and Longevity 壽命
Life satisfaction
Health and Longevity: McCullough, Hoyt, Larson, Koenig, and Koenig (2000)
Meta-analysis estimated the extent to which religious involvement is significantly associated with the odds of being alive at follow-up
Religious persons were about 25% less likely to die during the period of the study
Because of a healthier lifestyle
- More support (psychological, financial,…) from community
- Better recovery from illness due to less stress/more optimism
Life satisfaction: Salsman, Brown, Brechting, and Carlson (2005)
Intrinsic religiousness and prayer fulfilment = greater life satisfaction
Partly attributable to greater optimism and more social support
Religion
- Is religiosity a personality characteristic?
- Religiosity and personality dimensions
- Change and stability in religiosity
- Religiosity and life outcomes
Politics
- The Authoritarian Personality
- Right-Wing Authoritarianism (RWA)
- Social Dilemma Orientation
- Dual Process Model of Ideology and Prejudice
- Social attitudes and personality
- Attitudes and behaviours towards non-human animals
- Genetic and environmental influence
- The Authoritarian Personality
Right-wing extremism = syndrome of authoritarian personality
Landmark study in social/political psychology
Psychodynamic (Freudian) theory of the development of authoritarianism
- Harsh, punitive parenting and rigid parental values cause a tension between anxiety/fear of disapproval and punishment and hostility/anger towards parents (“intra-psychic conflict”)
- Suppression of impulses leads to displacement of aggression towards ‘safer’ / ‘weaker’ targets such as ethnic minorities
- > Reflects the dynamics of authoritarian submission and aggression
Anti-Semitic attitudes co-vary with other characteristics such as anti-democratic tendencies, ethnocentrism, political and economic conservatism
Adorno et al. found positive associations between these constructs in survey studies
F-scale
- Based on interviews looking for common patterns in attitudes, behaviours, histories
The F-scale
- Conventionalism 傳統主義
- Authoritarian submission 專制順從
- Authoritarian aggression
- Anti-intraception: Opposition to the subjective, the imaginative
- Superstition 迷信 and stereotypy:
- Pre-occupation with power and toughness
- Destructiveness and cynicism
- Projectivity
- Pre-occupation with sex
Conventionalism
Rigid adherence to traditional, middle class norms and values
e.g. A person who has bad manners, habits, and breeding can hardly expect to get along with decent people
Authoritarian submission
Submissive, uncritical attitude toward in-group authorities
e.g. Young people sometimes get rebellious ideas, but as they grow up they ought to get over them and settle down.
Authoritarian aggression
Support for rejection and punishment of people who violate conventional norms 懲罰違反傳統規範的人
e.g. Sex crimes, such as rape and attacks on children, deserve more than mere imprisonment; such criminals ought to be publicly whipped, or worse