Rec 3 - Nukhbat al-Fikar

Question 1

Li g’ayrihi meaning ?

Answer 1

Supporting

Question 2

What are the 5 characteristics of عدل trustworthy narrator

Answer 2

1) Muslim
2) mature
3) sane
4) does not commit major sins and is not persistent in committing minor sins
5) does not commit lowly acts like shouting in public

Time 34:11

Question 3

Through what knowledge does one know the characteristics of a narrator

Answer 3

1) ilm ar- rijaal
2) ilmul jarhi va ta’diyli ( criticizing and validating)

Time 35:11

Question 4

While determining the sahih Hadith, if the chain of narrators are authentic will it make the Hadith 100 percent reliable ?

Answer 4

No

1) chain of narration
2) matn

38:15

Question 5

‏تامُّ الضبطِ describe 2 types of

Answer 5

ضَبْطُ الصَّدرِ

ضَبْطُ الْكِتابَ

Time 42:28

Question 6

If one tells you the Hadith in mustadrok is weak then what should be your next question acc to Sheikh ?

Answer 6

What does imam Zahabi say about it who was the student of ibn Taymiyya r

Question 7

What do we say to one who says a Hadith found in Bukhari is contradicting which is one in Tirmidhi or Abu Dawud r so the Tirmidhi’s Hadith must be neglected ?

Answer 7

1) chain of narration
2) abrogation
Bukhari’s Hadith might not represent full picture of the matter

Time 1:35:45

Question 8

How long can you spend searching for Ahadith to understand the issue of saying amiyn acc to Sheikh

Answer 8

3 month (2-3 months in today’s time )

Time 1:44:16

Question 9

What famous sheikh albani did.

Answer 9

He only accepted from narrators who matched his bias and ignored same narrators when mas’ala was muxtalafan fihyi

He was a biased sheikh

His parents were Albanian Hanafis so may be that’s why he didn’t like Hanafis

Mistakes coming in 1000s is problematic

Time 1:48:18

Question 10

What’s the only difference between sahih and hasan ?

Answer 10

Weaker level of memory خَفُّ الْضَبْتِ

1:52:30

Question 11

If we have multiple hasan Hadiths about same subject matter then what term is given to those ahadith then ?

Answer 11

Gets upgraded to Sahih li g’ayrihi

1:54:14

Question 12

Explain the meaning of hasan li g’ayrihi

Answer 12

When too many zaif (lightly) Ahadith gathers on one subject matter then they are called hasan li g’ayrihi

Ex. ( Hanafis say that laughing out loud in salah breaks the wudu ) there’s no authentic Hadith about that

1:58:00

Question 13

Is there a difference of opinion about accepting hasan Hadith as sahiyh

Answer 13

No

1:59:29

Question 14

What did imam Suyuti said about Tirmidhi’s sahih-hasan term

Answer 14

1) Tirmidhi himself was undecided
2) the scholars in general were undecided

Question 15

What is a شاذ

Answer 15

If a reliable narrator narrates smth in contradiction to a more reliable narrater’s Hadith ( mahfouz)

Shaaz ➡️ mahfouz
Time 2:13:07

Question 16

How do you call the terms for when a ( lightly ) weak narrator narrates a Hadith muqaabil to reliable narrator

Answer 16

Munkar ➡️ ma’roof

2:16 ish

Question 17

What does the term munkar mean acc to imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal

Answer 17

He also used it for ibn Hajar’s shaaz

Shaaz when a reliable narrator narrates muqobilatan to a more reliable narrator

2:18 ish

Question 18

Why did imam Bukhari r used the term layyin to a very weak narrator not to higher level narrators

Answer 18

Perhaps out of taqwa

2:24:00

Question 19

If all 4 madhabs agree upon something who might say something otherwise acc to Sheikh

Answer 19

A fool

Ex. 20 rakaat tarawih

2:26:50

Question 20

What is a fatwa shopping

Answer 20

Taking the easiest fatwas ( and speaking I’ll against today’s and past scholars and sahabas )

2:31:03

Question 21

Tell the Hadith of ALLAH s.w.t will not guide this umma up on error

When Ummah has agreed upon something it won’t be a smth dolaala

Answer 21

لا يجمع الله هذه الأمةِ على الضلالة

٢:٣٢:١٣

Question 22

QUESTION how about using wrong taqvim for ramadan