Real Property Flashcards
Concurrent Estates: Joint Tenancy
Characteristics
. Right of survivorship: last one takes all
. Alienability: can sell during life
. Not descendible or Devisable: cannot pass by intestate succession or will
Creation
. The Four Unities
1) T: at the same time
2) T: title, same title
3) I: Identical interests
4) P: Right to possess the whole
. Clear expression of intent to create: Magic words: To A and B 1) as joint tenants 2) with the right of survivorship
Severance
. Alienable: may sell during lifetime without other’s knowledge or consent
. Disrupts the 4 unities so the sale severs the joint tenancy to the seller’s interest and becomes a tenant in common- E.g. A 1/3, B1/3, C1/3- A Sells=A2 1/3, B &C 2/3
. Partition
1) Voluntary agreement of parties
2) Judicial Action/Partition in kind: action for physical division if in interest of all parties- use if property is large
3) Judicial Action/Forced Sale: land is sold and proceeds are divided- use if cannot partition, one building
. Will not result in severance:
1) Mortgage
Majority: Lien Theory of Mortgages: if JT encumbers mere lien, not enough to sever JT-JT execution in lien will not severe JT
Minority: Title Theory: encumbrance by lien will sever
2) Murder: if JT unlawfully and intentionally kills a co-tenant, any property is transformed into a tenancy in common
WISCONSIN: murder operates as severance
Concurrent Estates: Tenancy by the Entirety
. Marital estate that arises presumptively in any conveyance to married partners unless the language of the grant clearly indicates otherwise
. WISCONSIN: community property state, does not recognize this type of tenancy
. Protected:
1) Unilateral conveyance or encumbrance: one spouse cannot defeat the right of survivorship by unilateral conveyance
2) Creditors: unilateral creditors cannot touch to satisfy debit – but creditor of both spouses can
. Severance: death, divorce, mutual agreement, of execution by joint creditor can sever
Concurrent Estates: Tenancy in Common
. Concurrent estate with no right of survivorship, can have unequal shares: presumed over joint tenants unless magic words used
. Characteristics:
1) Each own individual part and right to possess the whole
2) Devisable, descendible, and alienable *Frequently tested bc no survivorship right
Rights and Duties
. Possession: right to possess all portions of the property but no right to exclusive possession of any part
. Ouster: if one co-tenant excludes another from possession of the whole, actionable wrong
. Rents & Profits: unless ouster- all rents and profits are split by fair share based on ownership amount, adverse possession- if one decides to mot use the property, the other cannot adversely possess unless hostility and ouster which leaves a legal remedy
. Carrying costs: taxes and mortgage- split based on fair share
. Repairs: notification and based on fair share
. Improvements: Need notification and consent of all tenants, Partition: improver gets credit for any improvement and debit for any loss in value of the property
. Waste:
1) Voluntary: willful destruction
2) Permissive: neglect that leads to waste
3) Ameliorative: unilateral change that increase value- knock down cabin to have drive in- can get sentimental loss
. Partition: voluntary, partition in kind, or forced sale- courts prefer partition in kind, must have reasonable nature and time
. Encumbrances: one may encumber their interest, but not the whole, will not dissolve TinC except when foreclosure sale
LL & T: Tenancy for Years
. End Date: Known, fixed determined period of time- 1 week-5 years
. Termination: automatically, without notice, at end date
. Breach of Lease: landlord reserves the right of entry if the lessee breaches the covenant e.g. fails to pay rent
. Surrender: if tenant surrenders and lessee accepts – may need writing to satisfy SOF
. Writing: SOF if greater than one year must be in writing or switches to a Periodic Tenancy for term
LL & T: Periodic Tenancy
. Successive intervals with no end date, continuous until properly terminated
. Creation:
1 Express: R conveys to O from month to month or year to year
2 Implication: land is leased with no mention of duration but provision is made for the payment of rent at set intervals
3 SOF is broken under Tenancy for Years, measured by the way rent is tendered
4 Holdover: if a landlord elects to hold over a tenant who has wrongfully stayed , an implied periodic tenancy arises if they accept the rent for the period out of the lease
. WISCONSIN ONLY: SOF violation- tenant becomes an implied month to month, if agricultural or nonresidential: year to year
. Termination: automatically renewed until proper notice is given
. Week: one week
. Month: one month
. Year: CL: 6 months Restatement: 1 month*Preferred bar approach
. WISCONSIN: 28 days to terminate all periodic, except year to year is 90 days
LL & T: Tenancy at Will
. No fixed duration- terminable at will of either: To T for as long as T or L desires
. Creation: must be created by an express agreement that it is at will
. Termination: can be terminated by either at any time, usually requires notice and reasonable time to vacate in most states, or by death
. WISCONSIN: termination is 28 days
LL & T: Tenancy at Sufferance
. Creation: tenant wrongfully holds over- landlord is permitted to recover rent
. Termination: short lived and only until the landlord either evicts or elects to hold the tenant to a new tenancy
Tenant: Duty to Repair
When Lease is Silent
. Obligation to Maintain: routine repair (clogged sink) obliged to make but not ordinary wear and tear
. Must not commit Waste
1) Voluntary: overt conduct damages the premises- nail holes
2) Permissive: fails to take reasonable steps to protect- windows open during storm
3) Permissive waste: unilateral alters the property increasing value-generally liable for cost of restoration Exception: long term tenant and change reflects changes in neighborhood
Express Covenants
. Destruction: CL tenant was responsible for any loss to the property including forces of nature
. Majority Modern View:
1) Residential: tenant covenant has express, landlord still liable unless damages caused by tenant
2) Nonresidential: covenant to repair is enforceable and landlord may be awarded damages for breach
Tenant: Duty to Pay Rent
. Evict: if tenant fails to pay rent, landlord can evict through courts and collect rent
. Sue: landlord can let the tenant remain and sue for back rent
. WISCONSIN: if week to week fails to pay, tenancy is terminated with notice and failure to pay for 5 days, month to month: 14 days notice, year to year: 5 day notice to cure, then 14 day notice to vacate without right to cure
. Self-help: landlord may not engage in self-help- changing locks, forcibly removing tenant or possessions- criminal and civil punishments
. Tenant Breaches but is out of possession:
. Surrender: choose to treat as an implicit offer of surrender
. Ignore: do nothing and hold them responsible for rent *Only in minority of states
. Re-let: on the tenant’s behalf and hold them liable for any deficiency *Majority
. Rent Deposits: require interest payment and used for damages, if not returned there are actions for damages- *Clauses that avoid damages are void
Tenant’s Duties
Duty to repair and pay rent
LL Duties
Duty to Deliver Possession
Implied Covenant of Quite Enjoyment
Implied Warranty of Habitability
Retaliatory Eviction
Antidiscriminatory Legislation
LL Duty to Deliver Possession
. Majority rule requires the LL put the tenant in actual physical possession of the premises, if not LL is in breach and T gets damages
LL Duty: Implied Covenant of Quite Enjoyment
. Tenant has right to quiet use and enjoyment of the premises without interference, occurs:
1) Breach by wrongful eviction: exclusion from whole or part, partial relieves the tenant of the obligation to pay rent for the entire premises, even though they occupy the remainder
2) Constructive Eviction: unsuitable for occupancy, rains=apartment floods, elements SING:
. Substantial Interference
. Notice to LL and they fail to fix
. Goodbye: the T must vacate
. Acts of Other Tenants: general rule- no duty, two exceptions
1) Duty to abate nuisance on site
2) Duty to control the common areas
LL Duty: Implied Warranty of Habitability
. ONLY RESIDENTIAL not commercial tenants
. Nonwaivable
. Premises must be fit for basic suman habitation- running water and plumbing, heat in winter
. Determined by local caselaw and housing codes
. Tenants Options if breached:
1) Move out and terminate lease, but do not have to
2) Repair and deduct
3) Reduce rent in escrow account to show good faith
4) Remain in possession, pay rent and seek money damages
*Differences between Quite Enjoyment and Habitability: QE: must leave, can be used by any resident or commercial resident, H: can stay, only residential
LL Duty: Retaliatory Eviction
. May not terminate lease or penalize tenant if they exercised legal rights- whistleblower
. Courts presume retaliation if LL acts within 180 days of complaint, must show valid, not retaliatory reason
LL Duty: Antidiscrimation Legislation
. Civil Rights Act: bars racial or ethnic discrimination in sale or rental of property
. Fair Housing Act: protects based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, or disability, exemptions:
1) owner-occupied buildings with 4 or fewer units ** ON EXAM
2) Single family homes rented who owns no more than 3
. Prohibited Actions:
. Refusing to negotiate , rent or sell housing
. Providing different terms or conditions for sale or rental
. Falsely representing that dwelling is not available
. Reasonable Accommodations: when FHA applies, LL must permit disabled tenants to make reasonable modifications to existing premises to accommodate their disabilities at tenant’s own expense. LL must make reasonable accommodations in rules to allow them to use dwelling
Assignment
May be subject to tort liability tenant
. Transfer of the entire remaining term of a lease, may need prior written approval
. Assignee: has privity of estate with LL, LL can sue them or the OG T
. OG Tenant: has privity of contract with LL, Assignee never agreed to that so LL can hold OG T liable if T2 bails
Sublease
May be subject to tort liability for tenant
. Transfer of less than the remaining time of the lease
. Subleasee is neither privity of estate or privity of contract- relationship between T1 and LL remains intact
. T1 can sue T2 for breach or LL can sue T1, LL cannot sue T2
LL Tort Liability: CLAPS
. Common areas: hallways, elevator, stairs
. Latent defects: LL has duty to warn not fix
. Assumption of Repairs: no duty to repair, but if undertaken, must have good faith effort free from negligence
. Public Use Rule: LL who lease public space is liable for any defects that cause injury to members of public bc no time for T to fix
. Short-Term Lease: under stricter duty, liability for any defective condition which proximately injures a tenant
Modern Trend: general duty of reasonable care
Easements
. Grant of nonpossessory property interest that entitles its holder to some form of use or enjoyment of another’s land
. Presumed to have perpetual duration unless expressly limited
Types of Easements
. Affirmative: right to go onto and do something in the servient land
. Negative: prevent the servient landowner from doing something otherwise permissible, must be created by express written easement; LASS
. Light
. Air
. Support: excavation of minerals that would damage the stability of your land
. Stream Water from an artificial flow
. Wisconsin: recognizes solar and wind negative easements
Appurtenant Easement
Automatic transfer without mention in the deed, when it benefits its holder in physical enjoyment of land, 2 parcels must be involved 1) dominant 2) servient
In Gross Easement
transferable only if commercial, confers a personal or pecuniary advantage, only one land is burdened: billboard on land, right to swim, lay power lines
Easement Creation
. Prescription: adverse possession, must be COAH- Continuous and uninterrupted, Open and notorious, Actual use that does not need to be exclusive, and Hostile use or without consent *WISCONSIN period of time is 20 year for prescriptive easements or 10 years if the possessor is a public utility
. Implication: quasi-easement, when parcels are split but use the same utilities 1) the previous use on the servient part was apparent and continuous, and 2) the parties expected the use would survive division
. Necessity: landlocked sale, must have implied easement of access
. Grant: memorialized in writing and signed by servient estate unless under SOF
*Cannot reserve an easement for another person, only oneself
Easement Termination: END CRAMP
. Estoppel: oral expression of intent to abandon must have writing or action, but if servient owner materially changes their position to reasonably rely, easement is extinguished- put in a pool
. Necessity: automatically expire when necessity ends, unless express grant
. Destruction: other than willful conduct of servient owner will terminate
. Condemnation: may require compensation
. Release: given by easement holder
. Abandonment: must show physical action as an intent to discontinue use- build building in way
. Merger: unity of ownership will extinguish
. Prescription: servient owner may extinguish by interfering with adverse possession COAH