Race Flashcards
define ethnicity
Buettner - a highly elastic concept applied to groups who say they share or are perceived to share some combination of cultural, historical, racial, religious, or linguistic features]
Defined from nation as nation has typically defined geographical borders - triggers patriotism.
Ethnicity triggers racism - Hutchingdon
Define ethnic
Greek noun ethnos and is commonly translated as ‘nation,’ or ‘people
What is the Barth definition of ethnic group?
- Biologically self-perpetuating
- Shares fundamental cultural values
- Makes up a field of communication
- Membership definable from others
Preference over culture than biology
What do the biological dimensions of ethnicity lead to?
Civilising missions,
Assimilation
Sexual reproduction control
Genocide
Tonkin on ethnic
Greek employment of the word tightly related to the language of undifferentiated swarms of animals - barbarians
Frequently implied inferiority
What are the foundations of race?
Physical, inherited, biological qualities
Wade
Divisions between race and ethnicity are imprecise
- Assigning cultural significance to race is choice
Stuart Hall
Experience in Jamaica - whiter skin colour = more respectable. Such a thing as a ‘local white’, which falls under black elsewhere
What does the radicalising of a group do?
Homogenisation into one distinct other
Obama on mixed race
“back and forth between my black and white worlds”
UNESCO declaration
1950 - no biological foundation to race categories
Why is gender closely related to gender?
Similar situation of biological determinism - Joan Scott - signifying hierarchies of power
What is interesting about the Roman identity?
Mutable - one could become a Roman, and could happily co-exist within other local or regional affiliations
卐 Nazis 卐
Rendered diverse Germanic speaking peoples of medieval periods as one unified German race
Good Jewish/ Moors case study
groups can co-exist despite religious, cultural and linguistic differences. Same group under extreme persecution in different eras in England and Spain - through massacres and expulsions between 11-15th C.
Conquest of Granada
1492, those not converted were expelled
Nirenberg
Religious identities were fused with race during the period, which supplanted other notions of identity
Impact of colonial encounter
Development of racial hierarchy - darker skin, more inferior - Iberia, 1492
Biblical allusions to racial identities
The Curse of Ham - racial identities given to the children of Noah
Scientific Racism (Buettner)
Developed and used by Europeans
Free trade agreements between Japan and England
Not fully honoured on the account of the Japanese not being civilised people
The Manchurian Crisis
Japanese perceived supremacy of the undermensch
Changing of the ethnic cloth of a race?
The Satsuma rebellion - Samurai rebuke of the westernising forces affecting the Meiji government
Historians on the scramble for Africa
Ranger, Iliffe, Vail - homogenisation of tribal traditions to make singular opposable ethnicity
What happened under the British Raj in 19th 20th C?
Caste and religious community presented as immutable
Pandey
British common sense made false totalities of ready-made religious communities - Hindu, Muslim, Sikh,
Gilman
‘illusion of an absolute difference between self and other’
What was characteristic of British racial decline?
Emphasis of the damaging impact of Irish and Eastern European Jews
Transition of immigration in America
1920-1960 - movement from race to alternate identifier - White, Caucasian, Hispanic etc. - formerly a race apart citizens (Jews, Irish) were de jure assimilated - indicative of fluidity of ideas
Although the boundaries of white became flexible, what happened to black identity?
veneer of fixedness - ethnically diverse backgrounds homogenised - the ‘one drop rule’ took any lineage of African origin to be considered as black
How can Germany’s nationhood be described in the Nazi years
ethnocultural
What did the 1935 Nuremberg Laws do?
Jews defined according to race, not religious faith
Mann
The defeat of Nazism was not the end of racial discrimination - ethnic Germans became the new disease
What happened in Rwanda?
Hutus massacred Tutsis - 800,000 killed
Where do women fit into the picture?
Naimark- women as carriers of the next generation of nation (hence ethnic cleansing focuses on women (William Wallace))
What did the 1948 Nationality Act do?
Shored up Britain’s colonial and commonwealth relations and formalised feee access for all colonial and commonwealth subjects
Despite being multiethnic, what does Gilroy suggests occurs in Britain?
‘ethnic absolutism’ - de factor exclusion from ideological conceptions of the nation
Du Bois
- Race as a fallacy
- Tool by white people to keep black people down
- Sees direct correlation between race and class
- Nurtured racial uplift
- so long as Americans preoccupied with colour over class, solidarity to avoid exploitation impossible
- Racism, through slave trade -economic god, “motor of worldwide industrialisation”
Marcus Garvey
Universal Negro Improvement Association - UNIA - black nationalism, repatriation to Liberia
Kidd, C - definition of racism
“A realm not of objective science, but of cultural subjectivity and creativity.”
Fredrickson, G - Apartheid
Fall of Apartheid sees the end of government committed to vertical categories of race
Guyatt
Race is either vertical or horizontal
Poverty and incarceration rates, 2010
3x more poverty for AAs
8x more convictions
Is race a neutral term?
NO - visceral, irrational, emotional
What is important between race and slavery in Ancient Greece?
- Greeks created xenophobia, but this is jingoism, not racism
- Slavery in Greece and Rome is not racialised
Role of enlightenment
- Enlightenment provided framework for racial hierarchy
- George L Mosse - Toward the Final Solution
- Enlightenment did not eliminate racism or anti-semitism by 18th C.
- Encouraged mania for the classification of nature and people
- Classification led to the framework for horizontal segregation of races
slavery/ racism dichotomy?
Which led to which?
Eriksen
- Ethnicity and class - distinguish either through Marx or Weber
Marx - economic aspects - capitalist, petit bourgeoisie, proletarian
Weber - multifarious - including political influence and education for e.g.
Rwanda and Yugoslavia
- Not racial, but ethnic
- Ethnicity no more benign than race
Barker - New Racism
Focus on cultural distinction, not on inherited characteristics - same purpose - installation of hierarchy
Variability of race and ethnicity
Discrimination in America more race than ethnicity
Division in India is religion, not race
Ethnic discrimination in Trinidad is deemed racism, whereas in Mauritius it is referred to as ‘communalism’
Differences between race and ethnicity
race is typically negative - a formation of a them
ethnicity is more positive - a formation of an us
word search programme on anthropological texts
- finds decline in the use of structure
- rise in the language of base and superstructure
- rise and commitment to language of ethnicity
Glazer
No such thing as the American melting pot - rather, fostered a distinct paranoia of identity which was formative in lifestyle
What are stimulants to indigenous group conflicts
activated at the wish for the majority group to control ecological, economic or human resources.
Botswana - the San people do not conform to ethnic dimensions for being fragmented politically and socially, but can be categorised as hunter-gatherers - alienated by the assumption of control by more dominant forces in Botswana
Multilevel belonging
Gellner
“modern society is both more homogenous and more diversified than those which precede it”
Impact of globalisation on the category of race
Ethnic boundaries collapsed through efforts of TNCs and media penetration - McDonaldisation and coca-cola effect. Further, the internet
However, has also spawned significant ‘localisms’ - usually ethnic, religious and regional in nature - Arabic Muslims and terrorism 9/11
Mauritian case study
Traditionally ethnically divided labour market
- Disbanded by democratisation and industrialisation
- rolling effect through education
Education for Death
- Gregor Ziemer - about the education process in Germany- more important of the adaptation it received by Disney
Frederickson - General
- sense of difference allows for ethnoracial treatment otherwise deemed unacceptable for our race
- Racism rooted in religion, but also not fully fledged ideology until modernity
- herrenvolk democracy in USA under Jackson - the period where franchise was given to only whites
- Racism is unique to each nation
Describe the Indian caste system
Fixed social stratification system based on varna and jati
Jāti - caste, and refers to birth. The names of jātis are usually derived from occupations, and considered to be hereditary and endogamous
Varna may be translated as “class”
In India, 36.3% of people own no land at all, 60.6% own about 15% of the land, with a very wealthy 3.1% owning 15% of the land
Jews connoted to Satan
John 8:44 Christ - “You are of your father the devil”