Environmental History Flashcards
First signs of environmental history in America
1926 study - ‘soil exhaustion as a factor in the agricultural history of Virginia and Maryland, 1606-1860’
dark green ecologism
James Lovelock/ Arne Naess
ejection of anthropocentric analysis of earth, belief in the right of the world to its own philosophical interpretation, in which everything forms a single whole, in which humans are just an equal component – a knot in a net
Mystical, philosophical approach which rejects science, arguing that it would be impossible to quantify the amount of damage inflicted upon the earth Holism, expressed through Gaia (everything is connected)
Everything, including non-sentient beings, is equal
What was the first real main-stream version of environmental history?
1963 - Silent Spring (Rachel Carson)
Leigh Shaw Taylor findings
- imply, it is a economic past, concerned with how mankind overtime has used resources to create wealth, shelter, food and bruises
- Boundaries of fluid and debatable
- Economic history starts with Adam Smith’s publishing of the wealth of nations in 1776
- It is then followed up in 1798 by Malthus’ essay on population
- By 1882, William Cunningham I published growth of English industry and commerce
- By 1884, Arnold Toynbee’s lectures on the Industrial Revolution published
- In the 19 century professional historians largely ignored economic and social life and focused primarily on the state
- During the 19th century political economy morphed into economics and became an essentially ahistorical discipline
- Fundamentally, the progenitor of economic history are focusing on the transfer and exercise of Capital from human and mineral extraction utility.
Davis
Focus on new econometric methods of economic history, in particular, the basis of the study conducted by Professor Fogel on Railroads and American Economic Growth: Essays in Economic History
Traditional economics vs econometric economics
Traditional economic history also has its models, but all too frequently they are implicit, not explicit. As a result, the reader is often asked to accept logical conclusions based on sets of assumptions or chains of reasoning that are very peculiar indeed and he is not made aware of the pecularities.
What does McNeill suggest about the nature of envrionmental history?
As interdisciplinary as they come - porous with disease history, economic history, the history of science and technology and social history
Colinvaux and Diamond
Tropical ecologists - socio-ecological explanations of world history - Fates of Nations 1980 and Guns, germs and Steel 1997
China
all roads lead to China colour country where wages were extraordinarily low, trade unions were brutally suppressed, and the state was willing to spend seemingly limitless funds are massive infrastructure projects–modern ports, sprawling highway systems, endless numbers of coal-fired power plants, massive dams–or to ensure the light stays on in the factories and goods made for it. A free traders dream, In other words –and a climate nightmare.
Sorlin
Env is the product of contemporary history - or modernity
Something Under the Sun 2000 - on env, sometimes consults world war, high politics
Env history is bridge builder to other humanities and disciplines
Bsumek
The field of international environmental history grows from various strands of historical inquiry rooted in questions about diplomacy, state formation, environmental politics, human impacts on ecology, the shifting cultural meanings associated with nature, and the flow of people, plants, animals, and diseases across the world
Impact of environmentalism
places disproportionate stress on capitalism (and thus economic history) as a causal factor of a teleological narrative of environmental decline.
Grove
- In the 19th Century - typically referred to as historical geography - culminating in Man’s Role in changing the face of the Earth (W L Thomas)
- Colonial environmental change important in galvanising subject
*
Henry Hobhouse
Seeds of Change; Five Plants that transformed mankind (1985) - focus on plant ecology
Anker - Imperial Ecology
Deep and discriminatory fears about extreme climatic events, racisal difference and identity run right through histories of empires and formulations of global environmental and climate change
What is the cultural turn
From 1970s onwards, to make culture the focus of contemporary debates; it also describes a shift in emphasis toward meaning and away from a positivist epistemology.
When did Chinese environmental history develop?
Also in 1980s, though not from within China - primarily done by Westerners (much weaker than Indian history)
Stimulated by the release of imperial archives to foreigners - led to focus on Qing Dynasty
Fossil fuel companies
Not only do fossil fuel companies receive $775,000,000,000-$1,000,000,000,000 in annual global subsidies, but they pay nothing for the privilege of treating our shared atmosphere as a free waste dump
What did the British government do in Iran?
Installed puppet state in 1953 w/ intent of securing oil flow
What did Ban Ki-moon assert in Copenhagen
“I have been urging them to speak and to act as global leaders; just go beyond their national boundaries,” UN secretary general Ban Ki-moon asserted in 2009 before a major climate meeting in Copenhagen
Vogt
‘Earth company’ - individualism good, bad for environment
What happened to Francis of Assissi?
Mendicant orders would also challenge this notion, whilst the original conception of the Order was the rejection of material wealth, but again, the Catholicising of the Order following the death of Francis of Assisi saw the transmogrification of the sect into a more materialistic entity.
What is important to note about environmental history?
It’s still relatively new, with around 7000 practitioners currently. Inherently a US dominated affair.
What is characteristic about environmentalism according to Crosby?
Typically subserviant to other matters - i.e. Spanish Flu killed 20 million people - higher than WWI death count by some 3 million.
East
The Geography Behind History - released in antebellum of WWII. Reflection of anxieties towards human ability to manipulate the environment - repsonsive to WWI
What are McNeill’s three areas of environmental enquiry?
1) Material environmental history - human interaction and involvement with all things. Most important for the last 200 years with the rise of the industrial revolution
2) policy related environmental history - conscious policy decision made on the subject of interacting with the environment o.e. soil erosion
3) Human thought on the environment - the process of mental regard of the environment
what was the benefit to mercantile capitalism of Venice and Genoa?
The attraction of Venice and Genoa, for instance, was its access to the sea, allowing economic trading routes to be firmly established.
What stimulated the adoption of environmental history globally in the 1970s
The popularity of ecologism