QA Flashcards
Define Quality
Degree of excellents; in the context of health care, it is the extent to which an organization meets client/patient/resident needs and exceeds their expectations
Define quality assurance
A system for reviewing procedures used by those who regularly perform a service or produce a product with the goal of ensuring that standards have been met
Why do we need QA in a pathology lab
- to provide documentation that the lab functions to an acceptable standard
- to identify the source of an error or areas that need to be improved
- to promote processes for reducing error and improving patient care
What is proficiency testing
A process for evaluating unknown specimens, carried out by pathologists or labs, in which the results are retained and evaluated against a reference standard and compared with the results from other participating labs
What is quality control
A system of routine techniques and activities performed to control that quality of the product being produced or the service being provided
List 3 examples of quality control
On slide pos and neg controls in IHC
Daily assessment of H&E stain quality
Daily checking of the temp and pH value of staining solution
What is a quality manual
ISO:
A document specifying the quality management system of an organization
Contqains all the lab’s policies
What is a medical error
The failure of a planned action to be completed as intended, or the use of an incorrect plan to achieve an aim
What is a pathology error
The failure of a diagnostic or surgical procedure to be followed by a timely, accurate, and complete pathology report that describes that disease and the findings in a manner that is concise and readily understandable
What is a near miss
An incident that has no impact due to timely intervention or chance
What is a critical incident
An incident that significantly alters treatment or results in death/disability. This type of incident must be reported to the provincial minister of health
What is a nonconformity report
A report on tests that hav enot been performed to the appropriate standard (ie lab error)
What is an adverse event
An unexpected event in health care delivery that results in harm to a patient and that is related to the care and/or services provided to the patient rather than the patient’s underlying medical condition. This include an incident, in the course of health care treatent, that results in a recognized risk of a nontrivial adverse outcome or consequence at some future time
Examples of activities in pathology of the physician competencies (CanMEDS framework)
Communicator: quality reports, critical values, rounds
Collaborator: interaction with pathology peers and clinicians
Medical expert: diagnostic expertise
Leader/Manager: quality management, resource management, workload assessment, client satisfaction
Health advocate: infection conto, critical values, education
Scholar: teaching, research, conferences, CME
Professional: respecting the call schedule, punctuality, appropriate behaviour
Difference between guidelines and standards
Guideliens are a recommended strategy or range of strategies of lab practice. Variation due to patient-specific or lab-specific factors is a reasonable expectation
Standards are accepted principles or lab practice in which variation is not expected
How is QA achieved
Measuring a set of performance indicators to determine whether performance conforms to accepted standards, and by seeking to improve performance when accepted standards are not met
Done on a continuing basis
Reports should be generated at least annually and discussed with lab personnel
What does quality mean in surgical pathology
A report is timely, accurate, complete, clear
QA procedures in surgical pathology
Preanalytical
* Specimen delivery timeliness and specimen condition
* Adequacy of clinical history, including completeness and relevance
* Specimen identification errors
* Lost specimens
* Errors in accessioning, fixation, grossing, embedding, cutting, staining
Analytical:
* Intradepartmental consultations, consensus conferences
* Intraoperative consultation-permanent section correlation
* Cytology-histology correlation
* Targeted case reviews
* Intra- and interdepartmental case conferences
* Interinstitutional consultations
Postanalytical:
* Monitoring turnaround time
* Reviewing report quality, such as use of synoptic reporting and standard terminology
* Reviewing amended reports
* Reviewing record-keeping and storage systems
List 5 types of peer reiew
Intraoperative consultation-permanent section correlation
Cytology-histology correlation
Intradepartmental consultation
Interinstitutional consultations
Audits
List 5 types of pathology audit
Randon review
Target review
Retrospective review
Prospective review
Accountability review
List 5 QA processes that might reveal diagnostic discrepancies
Peer review
Reviews of previous cases in light of follow up
Interdisciplinary conferences or tumor boards
Clinician requested reviews
Amended report rate
What is a critical diagnosis in AP
Any AP result that has the potential to negatively impact patient care if not communicated in an urgent and timely fashion
Examples of critical diagnoses in AP
- Crescents in >50% of glomeruli in kidney biopsy
- Transplant rejetion
- Leukocytoclastic vasculitis
- Fat in a colonic endoscopic polypectomy specimen
- Uterine contents without villi or trophoblasts
- Mesothelial cells in an endocardial biopsy specimen
- malignancy in superior vena cava syndrome
- Neoplasms causing paralysis
- Unexpected or discrepant findings
- Infections - any invasive organism in immunocompromised host, AFB in any patient, bacteria in heart valve or bone marrow, HSV in gynepath samples of pregnant patient, PJP
How should critical diagnoses be reported
Urgent (same day) verbal notification of the submitting clinician is required in cases of unexpected malignancy or identification of organisms in an immunocompromised patient
Timely notification should otherwise be initiated based on the findings and professional judgement
The notification date, time, method should be documented in report
List components of a complete surgical pathology report
Patient ID: name, DOB, health card number, hospital number
Physician ID
Dates when specimen was collected, recieved, processed, reported
Diagnosis
Gross description: labeling, container in which recieved, medium in which recieved, whether opened, orientation, dimensions, weight, sampling, block description
Microscopic description
If relevant: special stains, IHC, biomarkers, molecular, IF, EM, Adequacy, references, additiona comments, additional comments, intaoperative consultation diagnosis, cancer synoptic report, communication with physician, details if corrected/amended, addendum
Diagnosti SNOMED coding
Optional quality-type coding
CAP standards for acceptable turnaround times for reporting intraoperative consultations, surgial pathology specimens, and autopsies
Intraop consultation: 90% of cases reported within 20 min per block
Surgpath specimen: 80% of routine cases reported within 2 working days
Autopsy: prelim 3 working days, final 30d for routine, 3 months for complex
Retention of pathology materials and records
Most wet tissues 4 weeks after final report
Most slides/blocks 20y
QA indicators for intraoperative consultation
Turnaround time
Intraoperative consultation-permanent section discordant rate
4 casuse of intraoperative consultation-permanent section discordance
Technical issue: 10%
Interpretative error: 40%
Sampling error: 40%
Incorrect or incomplete clinical history: 10%
Categorize intraop consultation-permanent section correlation results and give thresholds for acceptable deferral and discordance rates
Agreement
Deferral, appropriate
Deferral, inappropriate (10% threshold)
Disagreement, minor
Disagreement, major (3% threshold)
Categorize clinical impact of intraoperative consultation-permanent section discordance
No clinical significance
Minor or questionable significance
Major or potentially major significance
QA elements in autopsy pathology
- Preautopsy process timely and complete
- Permissions appropriate and paperwork complete
- CLinical questions and medicolegal issues addressed
- Clionicopathological correlation provided in report
- Safety regulations adhered to during autopsy
- Consultation sought for subspec expertise
- Findings documented via photographs
- Tissue blocking and slide prep timely and of good quality
- Ancillary studies used appropriately
- Prelim and final reports acceptable TAT
- Cases reviewed at M&M rounds
- Peer review process followed