psychological explanations of offending : cognition theory 1 Flashcards
kohlberg
-individuals have different levels of moral reasoning
basic level of moral reasoning
rules are obeyed as they involve punishment if broken
sophisticated level of moral reasoning
considerations of factors such as human rights as they hold a personal set of ethical principles
offenders moral reasoning
-lower level of moral reasoning
-1973 study were violent youths were found to have lower moral development than controls
pre-conventional level
stage 1 - acting to avoid punishment
stage 2 - acting to further one’s own self-interest
-childlike and egocentric
conventional level
stage 3 - meeting the expectations of others
stage 4 - upholding laws to meet societal expectations
post-conventional level
stage 5 - personal values used to achieve social consciousness
stage 6 - self-selection of universal moral principles
strength
palmer and hollin (1998)
-convicted offenders showed less mature moral reasoning than controls
-consistent with kolhbergs suggestion that lower levels of moral reasoning is a factor in criminal behaviour
weakness
explaining offending through moral reasoning depends on the offence
-pre-conventional = robbery (think they can get way with it)
weakness
langdon (2010)
- intelligence may be a better predictor
- people with low intelligence and low moral reasoning are less likely to commit crime