PSYC 336 Flashcards
what does the essentialist approach to mental disorders say
“mental disorders are natural entities (categories) whose true nature can be discovered and described”
categorial approach, inherent structure of world
“categories represent “empirically verifiable similarities among and differences between people”
categories “depict the inherent structure of the world”
what is a natural category
“a grouping that reflects the structure of the natural world rather than the interests and actions of human beings”
- is naturally occuring as opposed to artifical or arbitrary
- has clearlt demarcated boundaries separating members from non members
- has observable features that are caused by internal properties of the category
- these casual properties can be used to objectively validate category membership
point of rarity
no people in the middle of curves
elab…
subthreshold symptoms
- are more prevalent than the full diagnosis
- = a full diagnosis in terms of functional impairment
- are associated with similar cognitive, biological, and social risk factors as a full diagnosis and are associated with many of the same etiologies and pathologies
Kendler and Gardener (1998)
put the two approaches of a point of rarity and a continuum of depressive symptoms against each other through a study
2000 female twin pairs assessed 3 times during a span of 5 years asking about depression symptoms, impairment of symptoms and duration of symptoms and predicted a risk of depression recurrence over 5 years and a risk of depression in co-twin over 5 years
important conclusions:
1. DSM diagnostic criteria are not reflective of a natural discontinuity in depressive symptoms as experienced in the general population
2. Line separating no diagnosis from diagnosis is arbitrary - a convention, not a truth or fact
the social constructionist approach
concepts of mental disorder are social constructions and “products of particular historical and cultural understandings”
they are “abstract ideas that are defined by people and thus reflect their values”