PS120 Psychopathology Term 2 Part 2 Flashcards
Paradigm
- A conceptual framework or approach within which a scientist works
- Paradigms often involve a concept or view of human nature
- A paradigm has profound implications for which questions scientists ask and
which answers they give - Proposed treatment procedures differ according to the paradigms within which
they are set up
Defining Mental Disorder
Personal distress
Violation of Social Norms
Disability and dysfunction
Personal distress
- Personal distress
- Personal distress can be part of the definition of mental disorder
- For instance: Anxiety and Depression
→ Not all disorders involve distress - e.g., antisocial type of personality
→ Not all psychological distress is related to a mental disorder - e.g., grief after death of a loved one
Violation of social norms
- Violation of social norms
- Social norms: Widely held standards defining what is considered to be normal
behaviour in a particular situation - Behaviour that violates social norms might be classified as disordered
- e.g., the conversation with imaginary voices that some people with schizophrenia engage in
→ Not all disorders involve violation of social norms - (e.g., individuals with some anxiety disorders rather rarely
violate social norms)
→ Not all violations of social norms are related to mental
disorder
→ Consider: Social norms vary a great deal across cultures and ethnicities
Disability and dysfunction
- Disability
- Impairment in some important area of life: social or occupational disability
- e.g., substance use disorders are defined in part by the social or occupational disability
→ Not all disorders involve disability - e.g., many people with bulimia lead lives without impairment, while binging and purging in
private - Dysfunction
- Psychological processes not functioning in normal way
(e.g., someone hears voices when objectively there are none)
What is psychological disorder?
- The disorder occurs within the individual
- It involves clinically significant difficulties in thinking, feeling, or behaving
- It usually involves personal distress of some sort, such as in social relationships or
occupational functioning - It is not a culturally specific reaction to an event (e.g., death of a loved one)
- It is not primarily a result of social deviance or conflict with society
Stigma
A label is applied to a group of people that distinguishes individuals with a mental illness from
others (e.g., “crazy”).
* The label is linked to deviant or undesirable attributes by society (e.g., crazy → dangerous).
* People with the label are seen essentially different from those without.
* People with the label are discriminated against unfairly (e.g., “a clinic for crazy people should
not be built in our neighbourhood”).
Ancient Times - psychology
Early demonology: Ancient times
* Before the age of scientific inquiry all good and bad manifestations of power
beyond human control were regarded as supernatural
* Behaviour seemingly outside of individual control was also ascribed to
supernatural causes
* The doctrine that an evil being or spirit can
dwell within a person and control his/her mind
→ Demonology
Early treatments involved exorcisms and trephination.
Hippocrates - Early biological explanations
- Hippocrates separated medicine from religion, magic, and superstition
- E.g., seizures are not sacred
- The brain as the organ of consciousness, intellectual life, emotions
- Content of dreams may be symbolic
- Three categories of mental illness:
- Mania, melancholia and phrenitis
- depended on a delicate balance of four humors/fluids
- an imbalance of these humors produce mental illness
- blood, black bile, yellow bile and phlegm
- The treatments were quite different from exorcism
- E.g., melancholia: prescribing tranquility, sobriety, care in choosing food and drink, and
abstinence from sexual activity
Plato - Soul and mental illness
- Plato (427 – 347 BC) soul as two-horse chariot
- Reason is the driver
- The two horses are:
- Spirit (noble emotions)
- Appetite (base drive)
→ Imbalance leads to mental illness
The Dark Ages and Demonology
The Dark Ages and Demonology (2nd – 17th century)
* Dark ages in Western European medicine and
treatment/investigation of mental disorder
* Christian monasteries replaced physicians as
healers/authorities on mental disorder
* The church gained influence
* Return to a belief in supernatural causes of
mental disorders
* The persecution of certain groups (non-Christians,
devil worshippers, witches)
Robert Burton (1577-1640)
- “Anatomy of melancholy” (1621)
- Comprehensive treatise containing personal disclosure
- Causes and symptoms of melancholy
- Good food, exercise
- Laughter, reading, friends, music
- ”be not solitary, be not idle”
Philippe Pinel and moral treatment
- Philippe Pinel’s reform during French Revolution: Primary proponent in
the movement for humanitarian treatment - Patients should be treated as sick human being rather than as beasts
- Moral treatment: Emerged in later 18th century
- Close contact with nursing staff/attendants
- Staff would talk and read with them
- Purposeful activities: residents should lead lives
as close to normal as possible (within the
constraints of their disorders)
Genetics: Francis Galton
- Often considered the originator of genetic research
with twins - Attributed behavioural characteristics to heredity
- Coined the term “nature/nurture” (i.e. genetics vs environment)
- Also ‘credited’ with creating the eugenics movement in 1883
(Brooks, 2004).
Eugenics and Psychiatry
“Undesirable” characteristics should be eliminated in the population
by selective breeding.
* People with the “undesirable” characteristics should not have children.
* Forced sterilisation: By 1945, more than 45,000 people with
mental illness in the US were forcibly sterilised (Whitaker, 2002).
* Euthanasia: Killing of people with mental illnesses
Biological approaches of the 19th century
Blood letting: Treatment for agitated behaviour
* Hydrotherapy: Another treatment for agitated behaviour
* 33-36 oC
* Hours to days
Mesmer (1734 - 1815)and Charcot (1825 – 1893):
In the 18th century many people were observed to be affected by hysteria,
which referred to physical incapacities, such as blindness or paralysis, for
which no physical causes could be found.
* Both Mesmer and Charcot used a form of hypnosis to treat hysteria
(psychological approaches)
Josef Breur (1842-1945) ‘discovered’ the cathartic method
Cathartic method: “reprocessing” under hypnosis
* Reliving an earlier emotional trauma and releasing emotional tension by
expressing previously forgotten thoughts about the event
* Recalling the event associated with the first appearance of that symptom under hypnosis
and expressing the emotion felt at the time
* Influences on Freud
Franz Mesmer
Believed that hysteria was caused by a particular
distribution of a universal magnetic fluid in the body
(biological cause)
* Applied a method that reminded of hypnosis
Jean-Martin Charcot (1825-1893)
Although he thought that hysteria was a
problem with the nervous system (biological
cause), he was also persuaded by
psychological explanations
* Developed hypnosis
* Influence on Freud, Piaget, Binet
Libido
Libido (=the source of id’s energy): biological and
unconscious
Defense mechanisms
- Un- or preconscious strategies used by the ego to protect
itself from anxiety (such as repression and identification)
Freud and psychoanalysis
Psychoanalysis → psychodynamic treatments
* Still practiced today, although not as commonly as it once was
* The goal is understand the person’s early childhood experience, the nature of
key relationships, and the patterns in current relationships
* By making conscious what was repressed (e.g., the Oedipus Complex) it is
possible to overcome mental disorders
Free association and interpretation
Technique to help people explore their repressed and
unconscious conflicts
* Mostly talking about dreams which are interpreted by
the analyst
* Defence mechanisms are a principal focus of the interpretations