Property Flashcards
Learn property law
Define: Fee simple absolute
An estate that runs forever and is freely alienable
Define: alienable
Can give, sell, divise in a will
Any attempt to put a LIMITATION on alienation of a fee simple absolute is
Void. Just ignore it.
Any attempt to put a CONDITION on the alienation of a fee simple absolute is
Allowed.
A right of first refusal is
A right by someone to try to buy the land first when the owner tries to sell it.
It’s NOT an invalid restraint on alienation.
Language necessary to create a fee simple absolute
Courts will presume a fee simple unless language shows a clear intent otherwise.
“To A” = “To A and his heirs” = Fee simple absolute
“To A”: What does A have?
A fee simple absolute.
“To A and his heirs”: What does A have?
A fee simple absolute.
Define: Fee simple determinable; language necessary; transfer; future interest
A type of defeasible fee estate
Definition: An estate that MIGHT end but only if a CONDITION occurs. The duration is NOT measured in years or lifetimes.
A fee simple determinable ends AUTOMATICALLY when the condition occurs. The GRANTOR holds the future interest and gets the land BACK when the condition occurs
Language: DURATIONAL words: e.g., “so long as,” “during,” “while,” and “until”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (ALWAYS subject to the condition)
Future interest: possibility of reverter (“FSDPOR”)
“To A so long as —-“: What does A have?
A fee simple determinable
“To A during —-“: What does A have?
A fee simple determinable
“To A while —-“: What does A have?
A fee simple determinable
“To A until —-“: What does A have?
A fee simple determinable
List of defeasible fee estates
Fee simple determinable
Fee simple subject to condition subsequent
Fee simple subject to executory limitation
Key difference between fee simple determinable and fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple determinable ends AUTOMATICALLY when the condition occurs.
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Define fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
“To A but if”: what does A have?
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
“To A provided that”: what does A have?
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
“To A however”: what does A have?
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
“To A upon condition that”: what does A have?
A fee simple subject to condition subsequent
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
What type is a fee simple subject to condition subsequent?
A type of defeasible fee estate
The fee simple subject to condition subsequent does NOT end automatically. The holder of grantor is the holder of the future interest and must take steps to reclaim the land.
Language: CONDITIONAL words: e.g., “but if,” “provided that,” “however,” “upon condition that.”
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition + grantor takes reclaims land).
Define “defeasible”
Open to future reversion
Define fee simple subject to executory limitation; language; transfer; future interest
Ends AUTOMATICALLY and then goes to a DIFFERENT grantee. Does NOT go back to the original grantor; grantor does not have future interest.
Language: No magic words.
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (but ALWAYS subject to the condition).
Future interest: shifting executory interest held by whoever grantor designates.
What type is fee simple subject to executory limitation?
A defeasible fee estate
Similarity and difference between fee simple subject to executory limitation and fee simple determinable?
Both end AUTOMATICALLY.
But fee simple determinable = possession goes back to grantor.
Fee simple subject to executory limitation = possession goes to another grantee.
Define life estate
Never measured by time, but by life. Only transferable during life, not at death.
The measuring life can be the grantee’s or another’s (life estate pur autre vie).
Language: Can create with express language (“for life” is most common but not necessary) or implication.
Transfer: Devisable, descendible, alienable (as long as measuring life is still alive).
Future interest: if it’s for grantor = a reversion; if it’s for a third party = remainder.
Define life estate pur autre vie
A life estate where the measuring life is a different one from the grantee’s.
“To A for life”: What does A have?
A life estate for duration of A’s life
A life estate is what type of estate?
A type of present estate
A life estate pur autre vie is what type of estate?
A type of present estate
“To A for the life of B”: What does A have?
A life estate pur autre vie
“To A for life”: What does A have?
A life estate
“To A for the life of B”: What does A have? What happens if A dies before B?
A has a life estate pur autre vie.
If A dies first, the possession goes to A’s estate.
“To A for life”: later, A sold her life estate to B. What does B have?
If B dies before A, who possesses the land?
B has a life estate pur autre vie for duration of A’s life.
B’s life estate passes to B’s estate for duration of A’s life.
Three types of waste
Voluntary waste, permissive waste, ameliorative waste
Define voluntary waste
Any AFFIRMATIVE ACT that causes harm to the premises, EXCEPT
ORGE: open mines doctrine, repairs, grant, exploitation.
Open mines doctrine: the mine was already there.
Repairs: can consume natural resources for repairs.
Grant: written grant of permission.
Exploitation: if normal use of land included exploitation (e.g., farming) it’s okay to do the same.
Define open mines doctrine
If the land already had a mine, it’s okay to mine.
If the land wasn’t already used for depletion of natural resources, then doing that is waste.
Duty of a life tenant
To maintain the estate, which means continuing normal use of the land in its present condition, which means no waste.
Define permissive waste
Where tenant has failed to maintain the estate through inaction.
Triggered in 3 ways:
Fails to repair
Fails to pay taxes
Fails to pay interest on mortgage of the property
Three scenarios that trigger permissive waste
Failure to repair
Failure to pay taxes
Failure to pay interest on mortgage of property
What happens to the holder of the future interest if the taxes don’t get paid?
The property is subject to a tax sale, which terminates the future interest. The purchaser at a tax sale gets a fee simple.
If there’s a life tenant and also a mortgage on the fee simple, then
The life tenant is liable to pay the interest on the mortgage.
Does a life tenant have to insure a property?
No.
Define ameliorative waste
A type of voluntary waste (i.e., affirmative act) that actually increases the value of the property
Modern exceptions to ameliorative waste liability
A tenant can commit ameliorative waste if any one is true:
(1) market value of the future interest is not diminished
or
(2) remainderman don’t object
or
(3) if conditions changed and made the property useless in its current form.
Define future interest; list the six types
A present interest in the land with a future right of possession
Two possibilities of who owns the future interest: the grantor or transferee.
Grantor: (1) possibility of reverter; (2) right of entry; (3) reversion.
Transferee: (1) vested remainder; (2) contingent remainder; (3) executory interest.
Possibilities of who can own a future interest:
The grantor or some transferee
Types of future interests available to a grantor:
(1) reversion
(2) possibility of reverter
(3) right of entry
Types of future interests available to a grantee:
(1) vested remainder
(2) contingent remainder
(3) executory interest
Define reversion:
A future interest kept by the grantor when the grantor gives a grantee LESS than the durational estate the grantor had.
Pairs mostly with life estates and terms of years.
“O to A for life”: A has what? O has what?
A has a life estate
O has a reversion in fee simple.
*Does not matter how old A might be.
“O to A for life; A gives B a 50-year lease”: A has what? O has what? B has what?
A has a reversion in a life estate.
B has a term for years.
O has a reversion in fee simple.
“O to A for life, then to B if B survives A”: A has what? B has what? O has what?
A has a life estate
B has a contingent remainder
O has a reversion in fee simple (that is speculative)
What is never subject to the rule against perpetuities?
Future interests in grantor: (1) A reversion, (2) a fee simple determinable, (3) a right of entry.
Vested remainder (EXCEPT the vested remainder subject to partial divestment (i.e., the one to a class)).
If the grantor has given away a full interest then the grantor does NOT have
A reversion
Define fee simple determinable with possibility of reverter
A type of future interest in the grantor.
ONLY paired with Fee Simple Determinable (“FSDPOR”)
When the grantor gives something away and keeps a possibility of reverter.
The fee simple determinable ends AUTOMATICALLY when the condition happens.
“Right of entry” versus “power of termination”
Mean the same thing. Both are a future interest in the grantor.
When a grantor gives a fee simple subject to a condition subsequent, the grantor keeps the right of entry.
When a grantor gives a fee simple subject to condition subsequent, what does the grantor keep?
A right of entry, but grantor MUST EXPRESSLY reserve the right to re-enter if the condition occurs. (Without that, it’s a mere expression of hope and does not matter.)
ONLY pairs with fee simple subject to condition subsequent.
The right does NOT go back automatically, the grantor must take action to retake.
“A to B for so long as no alcohol is consumed on the premises”: What does A have? What does B have?
versus
“A to B, provided that no alcohol is consumed on the premises”: What does A have? What does B have?
B has a fee simple determinable (type of present interest)
A has a possibility of reverter in fee simple (type of future interest)
versus
A has nothing and B has fee simple absolute. The language is a mere hope/intention, not a condition.
“O to A for life, then to B”: What does A have? B? O?
A has a life estate
B has a vested remainder in fee simple (no contingencies here)
O has nothing (gave away everything!)
“O to A; provided that if alcohol ever consumed on premises, O may reenter and retake premises”
A has fee simple subject to condition subsequent
O has right of entry in fee simple
Define vested remainder
There’s nothing (no condition) in the way of someone taking possession, it just happens after the earlier expiration.
“A to B for life, then to C”: What does A have? B? C?
A has nothing (gave away everything!)
B has a life estate
C has a vested remainder in fee simple (no contingency)
Define vested remainder subject to open
Vested remainder = no condition for the possessory interest, it just happens after the earlier expiration.
Subject to open = the remainder is being conveyed to a CLASS of people, but we don’t know exact number. Typical classes are children, heirs, and issue/descendants.
Define classes for vested remainder subject to open:
“Children”
“Heirs”
“Issue” or “descendants”
Children = someone’s children from all marriages, children born outside marriage, and adopted children.
Heirs = presumptively who would take if person died intestate
Isse or descendants = lineal offspring of the designated person
Open class versus closed class
Open class = possible for more members to join
Closed class = not possible for more members to join
When does a class close?
Rule of convenience: A class is closed when any member can demand possession.
Rule of convenience
A class is closed when any member can demand possession
“To A for life, then to B’s children”: A has what? B’s children have what? When does the class close?
A has a life estate. B’s children have vested remainder subject to open.
Class closes upon A’s death.
Womb rule
A class that closes upon someone’s death WILL include a child in the womb at the time of the death.
“To A’s children upon my death”: at time of death, this includes B and C. D is born after the death. Does D get anything?
No.
Define contingent remainder
Something has to happen before the remainder becomes possessory (UNLIKE the vested remainder, which needed nothing to become possessory).
This includes a grantee who’s not in existence at the time of the grant: the CONTINGENT part is that the grantee has to eventually exist.
“A to B for life, then to C if C survives B”: A has what? B has what? C has what?
A has a reversion in fee simple
C has a contingent remainder in fee simple (the CONTINGENT part is C surviving B)
B has a life estate
Define vested remainder subject to divestment
The taker identified, but there is a condition subsequent.
Note: The condition will be in the clause RIGHT AFTER the clause that creates a future interest in the grantee.
“A to B for life, then to C; but if C does not marry D, then to E”
A? B? C? E?
A has nothing (gave it all away!)
B has a life estate
C has a vested remainder subject to divestment
E has a shifting executory interest in fee simple
“A to B for life, then to C; but if C dies before B, then on B’s death to D”:
A? B? C? D?
A has nothing
B has a life estate
C has a vested remainder subject to divestment
D has a shifting executory interest in fee simple
Define executory interest
It divests or cuts short the interest before it.
If a future interest in a grantee is not a remainder, then
it MUST be an executory interest (which means it divests or cuts short the interest before it).
If a future interest in a grantee cuts short an earlier estate, then
it MUST be an executory interest (which means it divests or cuts short the interest before it).
Can an executory interest sue a life tenant for waste?
No.
(Makes sense because it’s not certain that the executory interest will EVER get the property, so why should he be able to sue on it?)
“A to B for life, then C; but if C does X, then to D”:
A? B? C? D?
Can C sue B for waste? Can D sue B for waste?
A has nothing
B has a life estate
C has a vested remainder subject to divestment
D has a shifting executory interest in fee simple
C can sue B; D cannot (because executory interests can’t sue previous life tenant for waste).
Define shifting executory interest
Operates by taking title from one grantee and giving it another grantee
Define springing executory interest
Operates by taking title from grantor and giving it to a grantee
Shifting executory interest versus springing executory interest
shifting executory interest = operates by taking title from one grantee and giving it another grantee
springing executory interest = operates by taking title from grantor and giving it to a grantee
“A to B for life, then if C does X, to C”: What is C’s interest, springing executory interest or shifting executory interest?
Springing executory interest because it goes right from grantor to him.
Rule against perpetuities applies to what type of future interests?
(1) contingent remainders
(2) executory interests
(3) vested remainders subject to partial divestment
Define rule against perpetuities
An interest that is to vest, if at all, later than 21 years after the death of a life in being is VOID.
If there is any chance the interest will vest later than 21 years after death of life in being, then the interest is void.
Critical question: ask “is there any chance that the interest will vest later than 21 years after everyone alive in this scenario dies?” If yes, then VOID.
“A to B so long as no alcohol is consumed on the premises; and if liquor is consumed, title passes to C”: What’s the intention for A and B, and who has what after applying RAP?
Intention: A has nothing, B has fee simple subject to executory limitation.
After RAP: A has possibility of reverter, B has fee simple determinable.
“A to B; provided, however, that if alcohol ever consumed on premises, then to C”: Apply RAP, who has what?
Apply RAP: strike the language creating the executory interest. What’s left is: “A to B.” So A has nothing and B has fee simple absolute.
General rule re: class gifts and RAP
If it is possible that a member of the class could vest outside the LIB+21 years time period, then ALL interests are void.
Applying RAP to wills versus deeds: when do we look at the transfer as the time to apply RAP?
Will = time of testator’s death
Deed = time of the deed
Charity-to-charity exception to RAP
The RAP is NEVER violated if the gift is from one charity to another.
List and define the three forms of co-ownership
Tenancy in common
- default form of co-ownership
- each tenant is entitled to possess the whole
- freely alienable
- no right of survivorship
- right to partition
Joint tenancy
- must be created by express language
- must have “four unities”: time, title, interest, possession (meaning the joint tenants are co-owners who obtained same interest, at same time, by the same instrument)
- allows right of survivorship: when one tenant dies, her interests pass by law to the surviving joint tenants
Tenancy by the entirety (just for married couples)
- right of survivorship
- cannot unilaterally terminate, only terminate by death or divorce
Define tenancy in common
One of the three forms of co-ownership
Tenancy in common
- default form of co-ownership
- each tenant is entitled to possess the whole
- freely alienable
- no right of survivorship
- right to partition
Define joint tenancy: requirements to create and features
One of the three forms of co-ownership
Requirements to create:
(1) must be created by express language “joint tenants” and “right of survivorship”
(2) must have “four unities”: time, title, interest, possession (meaning the joint tenants are co-owners who obtained same interest, at same time, by the same instrument)
Features:
(1) allows right of survivorship: when one tenant dies, her interests pass by law to the surviving joint tenants
(2) may be partitioned: by agreement, by court order of partition in kind (favored), court order by partition by sale (disfavored)
(3) an interest can be mortgaged, and majority rule says this does not sever the joint tenancy (“lien theory”).
If an interest is sold, it destroys joint tenancy as to that interest; the remaining interests retain their joint tenant rights as to each other and they own the same percentage interest as before. The buyer of that interest (the new guy) = tenant in common.
Define tenancy by the entirety
Tenancy by the entirety (just for married couples)
- right of survivorship
- cannot unilaterally terminate, only terminate by death or divorce`