Property Flashcards
Concurrent Estates
The Joint Tenancy
Two or more own with the right of survivorship
The Tenancy by the Entirety
A protected marital interest between spouses with the right of survivorship
The Tenancy in Common
Two or more own without the right of survivorship
Joint Tenancy
Right of survivorship
Deceased JT’s share goes automatically to surviving JT
Alienable inter vivos? Yes
Devisable? No
Descendible? No
Attempt to dispose of the property by will is void.
Multiple survivors, only part of interest gets severed if sold
Creation of JT (4 Unities)
Time
Title
Identical Interests
Right to Possess Whole
Severance of JT
Sale: JT sells/transfers during lifetime even without others knowledge or consent
Partition:
Voluntary: amicable end
Judicial: in Kind (physical division); forced sale (division of proceeds)
Mortgage
Majority of states (lien theory): no severance
Minority (title theory): severance
Tenancy by the Entirety
Between married partners only
No unilateral transfer or encumbrance
Severance: divorce, death, execution of lien
Tenancy in Common
No right of survivorship
Co-tenant owns individual part + right to possess whole
Devisable, descendible, alienable
Presumption favors TiC
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Possession
No ouster (wrongful exclusion from part/whole)
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Rents and Profits
None from co-tenant in exclusive possession (unless ouster)
Fair share if leased to third party
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: AP
Not unless ouster
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Carrying Costs
Each pay fair share
Taxes, mortgage interest payments
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Repairs
Contributions for reasonable, necessary repairs with notice
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Unilateral Improvements
No contribution (credit at partition equal to increases in value)
So-called improver also suffers a debit if value decreases
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Waste
Voluntary: willful destruction
Permissive: negligence
Ameliorative: Unilateral changes increasing value
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Judicial Partition
Partition in kind preferred
Forced sale allowed if fair division not possible
Rights and Duties of Co-Tenants: Temporary restraint on partition
must be reasonable in nature and duration
Tenancy for Years
Known, fixed period of time
Termination automatic (on end date)
No notice to terminate needed
Writing typically needed if > 1 year
Periodic Tenancy
Continues for successive intervals until properly terminated
Creation:
Express
Implication
No mention of duration but rent at set intervals
Oral term of years violating statute of frauds
Holdover tenant after lease ends
Periodic Tenancy: Notice of Termination
Common law: At least equal to length of period
Year to year: Six months under common law
Except year-to-year which is 1 month under restatement
^Preferred approach
Tenancy at Will
No fixed duration
Terminable at will of either party (“To T for as long as L or T desires”)
Tenancy at Sufferance
T wrongfully holds over past lease expiration
L proceeds to recover rent
Terminates when L moves to evict or holds T to new tenancy
T’s Duty to Repair if Lease Silent
Maintain premises
Make routine repairs
Not ordinary wear and tear repairs
Don’t commit waste
T’s Duty to Repair with Express Covenant
Maintain in good repair/condition
Residential vs. Nonresidential Contexts
If a residential tenant covenants to repair, the landlord usually remains obligated to repair (except for damages caused by the tenant) under the nonwaivable “implied warranty of habitability”. However, a nonresidential tenant’s covenant to repair is enforceable, and a landlord may be awarded damages for breach based on the property’s condition when the lease terminates compared with its condition when the lease commenced. In the absence of a specific reference to ordinary wear and tear, a covenant to repair usually includes such repairs. However, repair covenants frequently exclude ordinary wear and tear.
T’s Duty to Pay Rent: If T breaches and remains on premises
Evict
Continue relationship and sue for rent
No self-help
T’s Duty to Pay Rent: If T breaches and is out of possession
S - Surrender: End lease
I - Ignore: Do nothing (hold T liable for rent)
R - Relet: New Lease (hold T liable for deficiency)
Majority view says LL must at least try to relet
T’s Duty to Pay Rent: Rent Deposits
Most states restrict the amount of security deposits to one month’s rent, require landlords to pay interest on security deposits, and allow statutory or punitive damages for a landlord’s improper refusal to return a security deposit
LL’s Duties: Duty to Deliver Possession
Duty to place T in actual, physical possession
LL’s Duties: Implied Covenant of Quiet Enjoyment
T has right to quiet use and enjoyment without interference from L (residential and commercial)
Breached by:
Wrongful eviction
Constructive eviction
T can:
Stop paying rent
Sing Elements for Constructive Eviction:
Substantial Interference
—Chronic or permanent problem
Notice
—T must notify L
Goodbye
—Get out, must vacate
LL’s Duties: Implied Warranty of Habitability
Residential only
Premises must be fit for basic human habitation
Standard: case law and housing code
Triggered by:
No heat in winter, no working plumbing, no running water, etc
T’s Options if L breaches:
Move
Repair and deduct
Reduce or withhold rent
Remain and seek damages
LL’s Duties: Distinguish Implied Promises
Covenant of quiet enjoyment: T must vacate
Warranty of habitability: T may vacate (doesn’t have to)
LL’s Duties: Retaliatory Eviction
L can’t terminate/penalize T in retaliation for T’s exercise of legal rights
Applies to any harassment or raising rent etc
Fair Housing Act
No housing discrimination on basis of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, national origin
Prohibited Actions:
Refusing to negotiate, rent, or sell housing, or give mortgage
Providing different terms for sale/rental
Falsely representing dwelling unavailable
Reasonable accommodations for tenants w/disabilities
Fair Housing Act Exemptions
Owner-occupied buildings with 4 or fewer units
Single family homes if owner has no more than 3
Assignment vs Sublease
Assignment: Transfer of entire remaining term of lease
Sublease: Transfer of part of remaining term of lease
Assignment
Assignee T in privity of estate with L
—-Liable on covenants that run with the land
Original T in privity of contract (but not estate) with L
—-Remains liable for original lease obligations
LL and T2:
—-In privity of estate after assignment
——–Because in possession, liable to each other for those that run with the land
—-T1 no longer in privity of estate
Not in privity of contract
—-No original promissory words
—-T1 remains in privity of contract
——–Secondarily liable to each other
——–T1 can be held liable if T2 doesn’t pay
Sublease
T2 has no privity (estate or contract) with L
T1 and T2 responsible to each other
Relationship between L and T1 remains intact
T2 has issues, they can go to T1 who goes to L
Caveat Lessee (tenant beware)(common law)
L has no duty to make premises safe.
Exceptions:
Common areas
Latent defects (L must warn)
Assumption of repairs (L is liable if negligent)
Public use (short lease, significant defect)
Short term lease of furnished dwelling (defective conditions)
Easements
Grant of a nonpossessory property interest entitling holder to use/enjoyment of another’s land
Affirmative: Right to go on to and do something on another’s land
Negative: Right to prevent landowner from doing something (light, air, support, stream water from artificial flow)
Creation of negative easement:
Can only be created expressly
Easement Appurtenant
Benefits holder in use/enjoyment of own land
Dominant: derives benefit
Servient: bears burden
Easement appurtenant to B’s dominant tenement
Two parcels involved
Easement in Gross
Confers upon its holder only some personal or pecuniary advantage that is not related to their use or enjoyment of their land.
Servient land is burdened.
No benefited or dominant tenement (because the easement benefits the holder rather than another parcel)
Ex, The right to place a billboard on another’s lot, The right to swim in another’s pond, The utility company’s right to lay power lines on another’s lot
Transfer of Easements
Easement Appurtenant
transfers with the dominant tenement, even with no notice
The burden of the easement appurtenant also passes automatically with the servient estate, unless the new owner is a bona fide purchaser without notice of the easement.
Easements in Gross
Not transferable unless for commercial purposes
Creation of Affirmative Easements
Prescription
Implication
Necessity
Grant
Signed writing unless outside SoF (deed of easement)
Prescription
Continuous
Open and notorious
Actual
Hostile
Creation of Affirmative Easements: Prescription
Continuous
Open and notorious
Actual
Hostile
Scope of Easements
The scope of an easement is determined by the terms of the grant or the conditions that created it
If not, will be implied by sufficiency
No unilateral expansion
remember that such use does not terminate the easement. The appropriate remedy for the servient owner is an injunction against the misuse.
Termination of Easement
Estoppel (servient owner materially changes position in reliance on easement holders assurances that easement will no longer be enforced)
Necessity (expires when need ends unless reduced to an express writing)
Destruction (of servient land, other than through willful conduct of servient owner)
Condemnation (of servient land by government eminent domain)
Release (by holder to servient owner)
Abandonment (physical action, ie. building a wall blocking road; never good enough to just express potential interest in abandonment)
Merger (when title of easement and title of servient land held by the same person, easement ends and merges)
Prescription (by servient owner, similar to AP)
License
Mere privilege to enter another’s land for narrow/delineated purpose
—Not an interest
No writing required
Freely revocable at will of licensor (unless estoppel applies)
Note: neighbors talking by the fence
—Violates statute of fraud if oral easement
—But creates freely revocable license
Estoppel applies if relied upon and investments made
Profit
Entitles holder to enter servient land and take some resource
All of the rules governing creation, alienation, and termination of easements are applicable to profits.
A profit may be extinguished through surcharge (misuse that overly burdens the servient estate).
Covenant
Promise to do or not to do something
Negative/Restrictive:
Refrain from doing something (ie. “not to build for commercial purposes”)
Affirmative
Do something related to land (ie. “maintain fence”)
Covenant vs Equitable Servitude
Money damages: construe as covenant at law
Injunction: Construe in equity as equitable servitude
Requirements for Burden to Run with the land
Writing
Intent
Touch and Concern
Horizontal and vertical privity
Notice
Horizontal and Vertical Privity
Horizontal:
Nexus between original promising parties (succession of estate)
Vertical:
Nexus between successor and original covenanting party (non-hostile)
Requirements for Benefit to Run
Writing
Intent
Touch and Concern
Vertical privity
Equitable Servitudes
Injunctive relief
Promise equity will enforce against successors of burdened land (regardless of whether it runs with the land)
Creation of ES:
Writing
Intent
Touch and Concern
Notice
Equitable Servitude (not factor just for acronym)
Common Scheme Doctrine
If a developer subdivides land, and some deeds contain restrictive covenants while others do not, the restrictive covenants will be binding on all parcels provided there was a common scheme of development and notice of the covenants.
Elements:
Scheme of development (including D’s lot) when sales began
D had notice of promise when they took
Important:
If the scheme arises after some lots are sold, no implied servitude can arise with respect to the lots already sold without express covenants