Property 1 Flashcards
Why is solicitor needed on property transactions?
Advise on rights/obligations/restrictions on property
Highly valuable asset
Lots of documentation
Buyer’s aims (speed/quality/cost)
- ensure seller has right to sell property
- adequate physical condition of land + buildings
- property is worth the £ paid
- identify all the rights the property enjoys/3rd party rights affecting property
- property free from any security interests
- contract reflects the terms agreed between parties
- sufficient funds to finance purchase
Lender’s aims
Same as buyers +
- property is marketable (sells easy on open market)
- property’s £ is sufficient to cover any losses if buyer does not repay mortgage
- no discrepancies between lender’s understanding of deal and borrower’s circs
- security document (mortgage) is valid and enforceable
Seller’s aims
- contract reflects terms agreed by parties
- provide buyer’s solicitor with what’s necessary to proceed with deal
- tie timing of sale to related purchase
- transfer legal ownership + responsibility of property to buyer
- collect money from sale, repay mortgage, account to seller for the balance
Conveyancing process
Pre-exchange: agree on price, surveyor reports on value + condition, B’s solicitor investigates title (most work)
Exchange: S + B enter into contract w/ completion date, B pays 10% deposit (serious consequences for both for pulling out from now)
Pre-completion: B’s solicitor orders mortgage funds , S confirms all paperwork necessary to transfer the property on completion
Completion: B’s solicitor send purchase price to S’s solicitor, S’s solicitor sends trader paperwork, B gets keys (both physically move house)
Post-completion: S’s solicitor pays off S’s mortgage + pays balance to seller, B’s solicitor pays SDLT within 14 days of completion (Wales- Land Transaction Tax- 30 days) and registers buyer as owner at Land Registry
Caveat emptor : Buyer beware
Buyer takes the property as they find it (after exchange of contracts can’t withdraw even if problem found)
Seller has no obligation to disclose patent encumbrances (obvious flaws) or physical defects - buyer must investigate
Buyer investigates property
- The title (Land Registry/deeds if not registers)
- Seller’s replies to enquiries
- Searches (ROIs from local authority/land registry/statutory undertakers (water/drainage)
- Property survey - value/structural defects/necessary repairs - flag issues for solicitors to investigate more (boundary issues, physical evidence of rights of way)
Caveat emptor - Hardy v Griffiths
deposit paid, mould found, C claimed reckless misrepresentation
C had to pay full deposit- failed to compete (no onus on seller, should have done professional structural survey prior to exchange, no reliance on misrep)
Something wrong with the property before exchange
Before contracts exchanged- B can walk away w/o legal liability (can’t recover costs though)
Condition of the sale contract- B can require S to remedy problem before completion
Initial advice: Energy Performance Certificate
Seller must provide free of charge to buyer - valid 10 years, available online
Initial advice: likely timescale and costs
avg. residential sale - 6-8 weeks from sale agreed to completions (fixed costs)
large value commercial- exchange in 2 weeks, completion in 4 weeks
Co-ownership: 2 or more owners
Legal ownership: max 4 legal owners registered at LR, over 18, sole/joint tenancy. Hold on trust for beneficial owners.
Beneficial ownership: may be same/diff as legal owners, not registered at LR, no max. no. , any age, sole/joint tenancy/tenancy in common
BO joint tenancy- couples (not passed in will/business)- single entity + right of survivorship
BO tenants in common: can leave in will/unequal contributions/business - each owns undivided share - no right of survivorship
Negligent if co-ownership not done correctly- declaration of trust of land written + signed by declarant (LPA s53.1b),confirm share entitlement if TiC
Surveys
Buyer should always instruct surveyor (allows them to withdraw/renogotiate/get contribution from seller)
If defects serious, lender may refuse to lend
Basic valuation- major obvious defects (need more detailed survey)
Homebuyer report- suitable for most properties in reasonable condition under 150 yrs old
Full structural survey- listed prop/extensive renovation/extensive alterations planned (most £)
Tax considerations
Stamp Duty Land Tax - over certain £ in England + NI (rates depend on residential/commercial)
Land Transaction Tax- Wales (after 1 Apr 2018)
Capital Gains Tax- gain taxed not £ received- not for most residential (Private Residence Relief)(seller pays)
VAT- existing residential properties exempt, some others must pay VAT- seller pays
Funding the purchase- Buyer
Cash to pay deposit on exchange
Balance of price on completion
Agreed price for extras (contents)
Tax
Solicitor’s fees (always subject to VAT)
Solicitor’s disbursements (search fees/ LR fees)
Residential buyer funding
Own resources
Mortgage loan
Proceeds of any related sale
Commercial buyer funding
Public company- equity finance (selling shares to raise capital)
High value properties - group of lenders (syndicate)- limits their risk
Lender can fund development (of buildings)- lender requires power to complete development if buyer fails to
Types of residential mortgage
Capital repayment: monthly payments of capital sum + interests
Interest only: B only pays interest (less per month but still owe full capital at end of term - capital repaid on sale of property). B may be better off as they have equity. (B2L)
Endowment : generally no longer in UK, interest only + payment invested in endowment policy (which repays capital at end of term). Unsuccessful- B makes up shortfall out of their own £.
Deducing registered title (proving ownership to buyer)
Seller’s solicitor deduces title from:
Title documents
- Land Registry official copies of the register
3 separate registers in 1:
1) Property register (rights benefitting property)
2) Proprietorship register (registered proprietor’s name + address, class of title, entries affecting ownership)
3) Charges register (rights burdening property- mortgage/covenants/easements/leases)
- Land Registry title plan
- Copies of any documents referred to in the official copies of the register (noting other rights)
Buyer’s solicitor investigates the title ensuring:
- seller has right to sell
- title is adequate for buyer’s purposes
- no title defects affecting the value of the property or the ability to sell in the future
Property Register
- Property description
- freehold/leasehold
- address, ref to title plan
Buyer’s solicitor sends title plan to buyer -> confirm size + location - Rights benefitting the property
- extracted (all relevant info here) or filed (in filed doc- provided by seller’s solicitor)
- right of way/light/ to run services (service media)
- excluded rights (minerals under land)
Property has benefit of right of way
Consider
- Registration of the burden
Benefit: Proprietorship register
To be enforceable, burden must also be registered (against land over which it passes (servient land- if unregistered issue caution against 1st registration)
- Adequacy
Legal/physical - inspect that its sufficient (narrow, car only)
- Maintenance
Common law- if using right of way, must maintain
- Adoption
Private road adopted (made public) -> owners of properties facing road required to pay costs of making road adoptable
Proprietorship register
- Registered proprietor name and address
- Class of title
1. Title absolute (freehold/leasehold)
Best + most common, no issues- true + proper owner - Qualified title (freehold/leasehold)
specific defect in title (covenant/easement missing on 1st registration - Possessory title (freehold/leasehold
Registered proprietor has physical possession but no title deed or has adverse possession (squatters rights) - Good leasehold title (leasehold only)
Leaseholder cannot provide evidence of the landlord’s title to the land (upgraded easily if landlord’s title registered) - Entries affecting ownership
- Price paid/value if acquired after 1 April 2000
- Restrictions on registered proprietor’s right to sell
- indemnity covenants to observe positive covenants -> numbered entry
Issues with class of title
Title absolute - no issue
Qualified/possessory/good leasehold title- buyer’s solicitor must
- report it to client + explain
- check mortgage lenders’ requirements (may not accept or conditional)
- advise on title indemnity insurance to cover risks
- consider if possible to upgrade to title absolute (can locate missing docs)
Registered proprietor
Individual/company/LLP
up to a max of 4 legal persons (all must sign/execute purchase deed)
Verify with Companies House searches
Owner unless executor of deceased’s estate
Co-ownership
Legal title always held as joint tenants
Beneficial title held as:
1) joint tenants
- assume if no restriction
- survivorship
2) tenants in common - restriction in proprietorship register - “no disposition by sole proprietor unless ordered by court”
- transferable by will
Co-ownership: title investigation
- If all co-owners living -> should all sign contract + transfer deed
- Surviving beneficial joint tenant selling- sign contract + transfer deed and provide copy of deceased joint tenant’s death cert.
- Surviving beneficial tenant in common selling -> appoint second trustee (their solicitor) to sign contract + transfer deed with them and provide copy of deceased tenant in common’s death certificate.
Buyer can take property free from beneficial interests where transferred by at least 2 trustees and purchase price paid in good faith (overreaching beneficial interests)
Charges Register
Rights burdening the property
Mortgage in favour of lender- undertaking given on completion to discharge this (buyer takes free of mortgage)- 2 entries in Charges (1st : date of mortgage, 2nd :name + address of mortgagee (lender)
Leases- w/ their terms
Easements
Restrictive/positive covenants- their burden
Report all to client
Registration of mortgages
Legal mortgage must be created by deed
Legal mortgages entered in charges register so mortgagee (lender) has legal interest (1. date, 2. name + address of bank)
Lender usually requires restriction in proprietorship register preventing mortgagor (owner) from selling without lender’s consent (no disposition without consent of proprietor of charge)
Modern mortgages not transfer of ownership
Third party in land law
new owner burdened by the right
Property always sold free of mortgage
- ensure seller has sufficient funds to clear the mortgage
- ensure it is a term of contract before exchange that mortgage will be redeemed on completion
- obtain undertaking from seller’s solicitor to redeem mortgage from proceeds of sale on completion
Burden of covenants shown on charges register
Restrictive covenants on register are binding.
Positive covenants only binding on original covenanter unless there is a chain of indemnity (noted on proprietorship register)
If buyer buying from original covenanter/unbroken chain of indemnity covenants then the buyer will be required to give indemnity covenant to seller (if none, refuse)
Unknown covenants (assume some restrictive) - should be reported and appropriate insurance obtained
Indemnity covenant
Covenant given by buyer to seller to observe positive covenant
Chain of indemnity - if covenant broken , seller can sue buyer
Buyer’s options for dealing with covenants
- Land’s current use in breach of covenant but no objection received -> Indemnity insurance policy (at seller’s expense)
- consent from Person With Benefit (PBW) (may be difficult to chase/ask for £) (check insurance first!)
- Restrictive covenants only- application to Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) to discharge (£££ + impractical)
Proposed use breaching covenant- insurance (insurers require PWB not contacted (alerted of breach -> claim for loss)) -> approach PWB for consent
Buyer fixes past breach-ends breach unless person owning land claims loss
FSMA allows solicitor to arrange insurance policy for breach of restrictive covenant
Not excluded under FSMA (insurance) but incidental (small part of buying) and arises naturally (complementary- discovered after title investigation)
Compulsory first registration of unregistered land
On any sale- 1 December 1990 /gift of property from 1 April 1998 - buyer’s solicitor must register buyer’s title
Imposed in phases on areas too- if not done, seller’s solicitor should do at their expense before buyer purchases
First registration at Land Registry can take months
Deducing unregistered title
Seller’s solicitor deduces by
- examining bundle of deeds + documents for property (held by owner/any lender)
-> relevant deeds listed in epitome of title
Send copies of listed docs to buyer’s solicitor (seller’s solicitor undertakes to send originals on completion) along with bundle of deeds
Most important: root of title document
Root of title (deed proving title)
Usually most recent deed that meets reqs. (legal mortgage/sale conveyance preferred - title investigated 15 years before that so 30 years at least)
Requirements s44 LPA
1. dated more than 15 years ago
2. deals with both the legal and beneficial title to the property (not ‘bare legal title only’)
3. adequately describes the extent of the land being conveyed
4. doesn’t cast doubt on seller’s title
Chain of title
Deed 1 -> Deed 2 -> Root of title -> Deed 3 -> Deed 4 (to seller)
Seller’s solicitor identifies root of title and establishes chain to seller
Root of title, Deed 3, Deed 4 in epitome of title
Deed 1 and 2 only relevant if they have covenants/easements referred to in root of title
Epitome of title
Copies of relevant title deeds w/ front sheet setting out details proving the ownership history of a property, where a property is not yet registered at the Land Registry
Include power of attorney (if any deed done under that)
Death certificate for survivorship
Grant of representation/assent for will/intestacy
Any mortgages created after root of title even if discharges
NO trust deed/expired leases/land charges searches/planning permissions (can be provided elsewhere)
Buyer’s solicitor investigates title to unregistered land
- ensure its registrable at LR
- check valid root of title and uninterrupted chain of title up until seller’s title
- check each conveyance/deed in chain of title, including root, is validly executed (clear that deed is a deed, signed, sealed, delivered) and stamped (Particulars Delivered stamp (after 1931) and certificate of title or ad valorem stamp- show stamp duty paid)
- if conveyance not properly executed/stamped, buyer’s solicitor should insist that seller rectifies this at their expense before completion
+ interest + penalties for late stamp duty
+ diff rates of stamp duty for different years
Most deeds before LPMPA (31 July 1990) - common law formalities (sealed with wax/paper- company -> in presence of 2 directors/ 1 director + company secretary who have both signed)
Index map search (SIM) of property
reveals
- any registered titles within the boundaries
- any pending applications for registration
- caution against first registration -> investigate further (claiming right against property)
Unregistered land: extent of land
Root of title may include a scale plan /refer to plan in pre-root doc (included in epitome of title)
If not, residential addresses can be identified by postal address
Unregistered land- assume that seller (surviving co-owner) was beneficial joint tenant (survivorship) if:
- Conveyance from seller to buyer states the seller is beneficially entitled to whole property
- No memorandum of severance converting interest to tenancy in common attached to conveyance to seller
- No bankruptcy order/petition registered against seller
If not all 3 -> treat seller as surviving tenant in common (same as registered- overreach by transferring by 2 )
Conveyance
Transfer
Unregistered land- land charges
Rights burdening property will only bind unregistered land if registered at the Land Charges Department of Land Registry (1925)
Different to charges register (registered)
Leases not registrable (if still running then in epitome of title)
- Puisne mortgage c(i)
- Estate contract c(iv) (protect buyer if long period between exchange + completion)
- Restrictive covenant d (ii)
- Equitable easement d (iii) (legal not registrable- apparent from epitome/inspection)
- Home right F (protect right of spouse to occupy)
Must investigate title with search of Land Charges Department registers - online/Form K15 by years of ownership + full name (spelling/middle names not nicknames), do for each owner in chain of title
Puisne mortgage
Second/ subsequent mortgage of unregistered land of which the title deeds are retained by a first mortgagee (lender)
Unregistered land- mortgages
Should be discharged on completion
All mortgage deeds on epitome of title
If discharged (repaid in full) -> vacating receipt signed on behalf of lender
1st legal mortgage not registrable as land charge because mortgage lender doesn’t release original deeds until repaid (protection) unlike subsequent mortgages ( c(i) charge)
Unregistered land- rights benefitting/burdening
Buyer’s solicitor should review deeds provided in epitome of title and identify any covenants/easements/leases
Root of title refers to earlier deed then provided in epitome, otherwise buyer’s solicitors not allowed to see earlier deeds
Positive- only bind if chain of indemnity covenants (check each deed), not registrable as land charges
Restrictive- only bind if d (ii) land charge
Unknown- arising from missing deed (raise with seller who takes indemnity insurance and report to buyer and lender)
Report on title
Solicitor reports to client on investigation of title, search results, replies to enquiries.
Material facts of property, issues and their implication, solutions available
Buyer shouldn’t exchange contracts before understanding report on title
Report on title confidential to the client + sets out limitations on solicitors liability
No opinion on value/commerciality of transactions.
No physical inspection - advice to carry out survey
Report on title contents
- Interpretation
- Scope of the review and limitation of liability
- Executive summary
- Purchase price and other contract terms
- The Property
6.Matters benefiting the Property - Matters burdening the Property
- Search results
- Replies to enquiries
- Planning and building regulations
- Insurance
- Stamp Duty Land Tax
- Conclusion
Report on title protects solicitors from claims from professional negligence
CCS 6.4 - Solicitors must ensure client is aware of all information material to the matter of which they have knowledge
CCS 8.6- Solicitors must give clients information in a way they can understand (lay language, offer to talk through)
Caveat emptor -> searches
Carried out by buyers solicitor (usually once contract received)
Seller’s solicitor might if dividing land between buyers
Lender’s solicitor might for a remortgage
Submitted as early as possible as take a few weeks
Standard searches - always necessary, some optional
Standard searches
Local search - local authorities, local land charges
Drainage + Water
Desktop environmental search
Chancel repair liability
Unregistered land - land charges search
Search of index map - mineral rights
Companies search
Optional searches
CON29O- commons registration search
Highways
Coal mining
Cheshire salt
Tin/clay/limestone
Phase 1/2 survey
Flood
Utility providers
Railways - over/under, cross rail, HS2
Waterways
National Land Information Service (NLIS)
intermediary between solicitors and various institutions
order searches online here from channel providers (search flow etc.)
some available immediately/some a few weeks later
Local search: all matters of property in knowledge/records of LA (always done)
- Standard enquires (CON29)
- planning/building regulations, roads, public rights of way, environmental notice - Optional (CON29O)
commons search, pipelines, low noise zones - Local Land Charges Search (LLC1)
Each LA keeps register (some transferred to LR) - some require money (make road adoptable) or affect use (listed building, granted planning permission, tree preservation, restrictions on development)
Drainage and water search (always done)
check with relevant water service company - check mains water supply, contamination
CON29DW- residential
CommercialDW- commercial
Desktop environmental search (always done)
Owner can be liable for costs of cleaning contamination even if not responsible
Local search - notices served but desktop shows historical records of contaminative use (industrial )
Flooding, subsidence, industrial land used in 250m
Chancel repair search (always done)
Properties in parishes with pre-Reformation churches. Responsibility for repairing church roof shared amongst parishioners- can be very expensive so requires indemnity insurance.
Highways search (depends)
CON29 shows adopted highways (LA £ for public use)
Mostly commercial properties need
If property doesn’t directly border highway - ensure rights of access
Mining searches (depends)
Coal mining (CON29M)- areas affected listed in free gazette, identify subsidence risk and if compensation already paid (can’t be paid in future)
Cheshire salt search- brine subsidence in Cheshire, similar to coal mining search
Tin, clay, limestone - dependent on area (tin in Cornwall + Somerset), similar to coal mining search but for minerals
Environmental searches (more detailed than standard desktop) (depends)
Environmental Phase 1 Survey- with site inspection
Environmental Phase 2 Survey - where Phase 1 shows risk of contamination, test soil/water samples
Flood search- where property has flooded in past
Other searches (depends)
Utility providers- new development/site for development , checks connection (electricity, gas, telecom, broadband)
Railways - passes nearby or proposed- no standard search but check relevant rail company about access rights/other issues
Waterways search - river/canal passing by, liability for maintenance of river bank, rights of way, drainage, fishing rights and owner’s liability for flooding (not flood risk)
Pre contract enquiries with seller (always done)
Commercial property - CPSE1 (standard enquiries)
Residential property-
- Property information form (TA6) - boundaries, alterations, neighbour disputes, work done, occupiers, utilities
- Fittings and contents form (TA10) - items included/not included in sale- curtains, lights etc.
Other additional enquiries - bounce back and forth
Seller’s liability for pre-contract enquiries
Rely on seller being co-operative, they can decline if no knowledge,
‘ not so far as seller aware’ - still liable if answer is yes - should make reasonable investigations
Seller cannot deliberately mislead buyer (concealing defects/lying.) - action in misrepresentation
Searches for title/seller (investigation of title)
Index map search (SIM)- unregistered/ unregistered + registered/ registered notes mineral rights -> shows extent of registered titles and unregistered land in area searched (doesn’t show ownership- official copies needed)
MapSearch- LR free map of registered titles - LR doesn’t guarantee result (like SIM)
Central Land Charge Search (K15) (not land charges register in local search)- unregistered property, check full names of seller/previous owners in epitome of title
Bankruptcy search - against seller if not at full market value (at Central Land Charges Registry) and buyer taking out mortgage
Companies search- check existence/liquidation/dissolution, shows security interests company given
When is planning permission needed?
Whenever there is development of land (building works or material change of use of land) unless:
- building works exclusively on interior or
- building works which don’t materially affect external appearance or
- changes of use within the same use class (shops, financial, food, business, hotels, dwellings,) - some are Sui generis (unique) so always require planning permission