Professional Conduct 1 Flashcards
Money Laundering
Financial transactions where proceeds from serious crime are cleaned so the source is harder, if not impossible, to trace.
Lawyers are vulnerable to being exposed to ML.
Money Laundering Legislation
Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (PoCA)
Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017 (MLR)
How do firms tackle ML?
Compliance Officers for Legal Practice and Finance and Administration (COLP, COFA)
Each firm must nominate a money laundering reporting officer (MRLO)
Policies obliging employees to report suspicions/knowledge of ML
Reg 18 MLR- law firms + other business should assess the risks of ML and Terrorist Financing
Anti ML Risk Assessment required
Process of Money Laundering
- Criminal source of funds disguised
- Form of funds converted (cash to bank acct.)
- Trail by which conversion occurs disguised
- Launderer retains control of funds directly/indirectly
How is a solicitor at risk from ML?
Client depositing £ in firms client acct. for purposes of redirecting to 3rd party
C buying property/assets/investing using £ from crime
Setting up legal structures to money launder/hide source of funds (complex trusts)
C using firm’s client acct. to mix dirty and clean cash to clear audit trails
^ Solicitors should be careful about revealing details of client accts. (breach SRA code)
Money Laundering: Warning Signs
- Instructions outside of firm’s expertise
- Use of client accts
- Clients paying large sums in cash
- Money coming in/out of offshore tax havens (parties are offshore vehicles)
- Money coming from high risk jurisdictions
- unusual retainers
- setting up a trust
- property purchase
- buyers and sellers w/ similar names/signatures
High risk instruction = suspicious attribute + suspicious activity
Financial Action Task Force (FATF) and European Commission publish lists of countries with higher risk of ML
DPRK, Iran, Myanmar, Cayman Islands
Direct involvement offences PoCA- ML
s327 : concealing/disguising/converting criminal property
s 328: involvement with arrangement which you know/suspect helps the acquisition/retention/use/control of criminal property
s 329: acquiring/using/possessing criminal property
Apply to everyone. Can be guilty of multiple.
Non direct involvement offences PoCA
Applies to those working in the regulated sector (insurance/investment/acct./insolvency/tax/financial/property)
s 330: failure to disclose suspicions to nominated officer/MLRO
include- identity/whereabouts of property/reason for knowledge/suspicion
s 333A tipping off client after disclosing Wait for further action after reporting to NCA (7 bdays notice period -> 31 days moratorium period if NCA refuses consent)
Defence to direct/non direct involvement
Authorised disclosure to a nominated officer under s338
can be made before /during /after doing the prohibited act
during/after- didn’t know it was illegal/threatened + made disclosure ASAP during course of employment
Golden rule: DISCLOSE
no offence if outside UK and not unlawful in that territory
Enhanced CDD Regulation 33 MLR 2017
-where high risk of ML/Terrorist Financing
-high risk third country (requires source of funds of client and client’s beneficial owner, approval of senior management at firm, further examining patterns of deals)
-Politically Exposed Person (PEP) or associate of a PEP- someone entrusted with a prominent public function
-complex transaction
-unusually large transaction/pattern of transactions/ transactions with no economic or legal purpose
Method: independent reliable verification of info, examining background and purpose of T and monitoring relationship
Customer Due Diligence (CDD)
MLR requires regulated businesses to identify and verify the identity of their clients - CDD
should be done when establishing a business relationship/ carry out the occasional transaction/suspect ML/doubt the veracity of ID given
Company: must identify name/number/registered office/constitutional docs/names of directors
Company/trust/partnership - identify the beneficial owner (more than 25% shares/voting rights)
ongoing monitoring required - Reg 28
Penalty for PoCA offence
imprisonment/fine
MLR 2017 (Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Info on the Payer) Regulations
Organisation must be in a position to identify + report potential money laundering.
applies to a number of organisations/institutions/professional advisors (Reg 8(2)) including independent legal professionals and trust/company service providers (most legal work/providing address)
but doesn’t apply to employment/most litigation cases but firms take all required steps regardless in practice
Simplified CDD- Regulation 37 MLR 2017
Never for individuals
low risk of ML/TF considering risk assessment done under Reg 18 and low risk factors (publicly owned/financial institutions/listed company)
Adjust extent/timing/type of CDD measures but still carry out sufficient monitoring to detect unusual/suspicious behaviour
Customer Due Diligence timing
Reg 30 - before the establishment of business relationship/carrying out the transaction or during if delay is necessary/little risk of ML/TF
CDD - can rely on CCD of another person, but you will be liable for 3rd party’s failure to comply with MLR
second solicitor relies on first solicitor’s (3rd party) CDD
in practice large firms do their own (lower risk)
UK - can only rely on CDD from authorised classes- auditors/insolvency/accts/solicitors/licensed financial institutions
ML - Customer Due Diligence evidence
Legal Sector Affinity Group published Anti-Money Laundering Guidance for the Legal Sector
ML CDD Evidence: UK natural person
current signed passport/driving license
data service providers : electoral roll/CH/Credit agencies/Passport office/DVLA
ML CDD Evidence: Partnership
Partnership is not legal entity so need info on individuals -
if well known partnership- name, trading address, registered address, name of business
Individuals running smaller partnerships/unincorp business- identified as private individuals
Larger partnerships/Unincorp business/LLPs- treated as private companies
ML CDD Evidence: Companies
Reg 28(3)- corporate client requires name/company number/registered office/principal place of business
Beneficial owner should be verified (if unable to report to NCA)
ML CDD Evidence - listed company
if listed on regulated market- simplified CDD only- no beneficial owners just confirmation of company’s listing on regulated market + ongoing monitoring
Further CDD for listed if necessary may be copy of audited accts./cert of incorporation
ML CDD Evidence: Private and unlisted company
Name, company number. address of registered office and principal place of business
Law the company is subject to and its constitution
full names of board of directors and senior persons in charge of operations
Cert of incorporation/articles/filed audited accts./company registry
Financial Services Regulation
FS- advising on merits (particular client+particular transaction)/dealing(buying/selling)/arranging (paperwork) investments
Heavily regulated to protect consumers from negligent advice
Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 FSMA governs this
Regulated Activities Order 2001 establishes what it governed by FSMA
2 regulators - Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)
FSMA s19 - General Prohibition on solicitors carrying out regulated activity
Regulated Activity = Specified Investment + Specified Activity (e.g. advising on shares)
Consider: is investment (shares/bond/mortgage) and activity (advising/dealing/arranging/managing investments) specified under FSMA?
if not excluded exemption may be possible or authorisation may be required (if fulfilling s327 FSMA and SRA Scope Rule 2)
art 53 RAO Generic advice/explanations are okay (not recommendation on course of action)- outside of FSMA scope
excluded activities can be done without authorisation (regulated activities that are a necessary part of other services in profession/sale of a body corporate- can advise on merits here art 70 if buying/selling more than 50% of voting shares in company )
For Regulated Activities to be exempt, all conditions need to be met s327 FSMA
- person doing RA must be a member of the profession
- must not receive commission from 3rd party for RA unless client is accounted for commission (client must give informed consent for them to keep it)
- RA must be provided incidentally to provision of professional services (a small part of what the firm does for its clients overall)
- must only do RAs permitted by their relevant designated professional body (SRA Scope Rule 2 - activity arises out of/is complementary to the provision of a particular professional service to a particular client- must arise naturally)
if none of the above apply, firm must be authorised by PRA/FCA, if not breaching s19(1) FSMA- crime
FSMA applies (not excluded regulated activity)
solicitor needs to be directly authorised (FCA/PRA) or supervised by a designated professional body (The Law Society or SRA)
Civil Court Structure
Supreme Court
Court of Appeal
High Court (1st instance)
Country Court (1st instance)
(Tribunals -> Appeal Tribunals-> Court of Appeal)
Start in County Court or High Court?
High Court if over £100k (over £50k for Personal Injury)
consider complexity of facts/law/remedies/procedures or importance to the public
Fatal accident - must start in High Court
County Court
1 National County Court with 170 hearing centres. Some admin done online. No separate divisions, low value claims not requiring specialism
Deputy District Judges/ Recorders/Circuit Judges
High Court
Royal Courts in the Strand (start claims from London here) + regional District Registries (start claims in London or here)
3 divisions :
Chancery
King’s Bench
Family
High Court Masters/Judges
Chancery + KBD known as Business + Property Courts
HC: King’s Bench Division
General KBD (Personal Injury/Professional Negligence/ Breach of statutory duty
Specialist courts:
Administrative Court (JR) (Planning C- planning permission)
Commercial Court (business disputes- often intl.)
Circuit Commercial
Tech + Construction
Admiralty (Shipping/Maritime)
Overlap between King’s Bench and Chancery
Bankruptcy, Partnerships, Company/Commercial, Contract, Tort
Financial List- both - financial dispute of £50million or more
Chancery Court
Property (land, mortgage, estates)/Trusts/Probate
IP
Insolvency (CA 2006)
Revenue (HMRC as party)
Competition Law
Court of Appeal
Civil and Criminal Division
final court of appeal for majority of cases
Judges of the Court of Appeal- Lord/Lady
Supreme Court
must have public importance
12 Justices
Lord Chief Justice
Most senior member of the judiciary
Solicitors’ Rights of audience
advocacy in Magistrates, County, Tribunal, Upper tribunal
Higher Rights of Audience (exams needed) needed for higher courts
Rules of Precedent: Stare decisis
Binding precedent - lower courts are bound to apply the judgments of senior courts. Certain courts bind themselves - CoA, High Court Upper Tribunal
Precedent: Court of Appeal
Civil division- bound by previous decisions
3 exceptions Young v Bristol-
a) CoA faced by 2 conflicting decisions of its own
b) CoA must refuse to follow decision conflicting with UKSC/HoL even if CoA not expressly overruled
c) Previous CoA decision done per incuriam not bound to follow (w/o care- not where prev not fully argued/misinterpreted authorities or statute)
Criminal division- same as civil, 4th exception in the interests of justice where the liberty of an individual is at stake (Taylor)
Precedent: Supreme Court
Was binding on itself until 1966.
As of Practice Statement 1966, it will only depart from previous decisions if right to do so (rare- done if no detriment to public administration usually)
Funding
A solicitor has a duty to try to find the best funding option for a client.
Private Funding
Professional Funding
Before/ after the event insurance
Community Legal Service
Conditional Fee agreements
Damages based agreements
Third party funding
Precedent Divisional Courts of High Court
Bound by itself and follow same exceptions as Court of Appeal for civil and criminal divisions.
Civil- bound by UKSC/HoL/Court of Appeal Civil
Criminal- bound by UKSC/HoL/Court of Appeal/Divisional courts
Decisions of HC binding on County Court and Magistrates
Privy Council
Final appeal court for UK and some commonwealth/overseas
often decided by SC judges
English + Welsh courts not bound by PC decisions unless PC expressly directs that domestic courts should treat their decision as binding
Precedent: Inferior courts
Do not bind themselves or other courts
Crown Court- bound by all incl KBD, doesn’t bind another Crown Court/Magistrates
Private funding
Using client’s private resources
normal for business
less so for individuals except conveyance/drawing up a will
Professional funding
Legal work funded by trade union/professional organisation.
Most likely for civil/criminal litigation (professional negligence, employee claiming against employer)
Before the event BTE insurance
Insurance pays out for legal work (may include disbursements)
Sold in conjunction with other insurance policies (Household/motor)
Often have financial limit
Low premiums (>1%)
not recoverable from other side if claimant wins
after the event ATE insurance- civil litigation
insurance taken after dispute has arisen
covers clients and opponents costs and disbursements in event of losing case
used in conjunction with Conditional FA/Damages FA (this covers client’s solicitor and ATE covers disbursements and opponent’s costs )
depends on merits of case and level of cover- premiums can be 25% of insurance cover sought
not recoverable from other party (except clinical negligence reports)
Conditional Fee Agreement (CFAs)- civil litigation
no win no fee
if successful normal fee+ success fee of up to 100% of normal (cannot recover success fee from opponent, comes out of damages)
Personal injury- success fee cannot be more than 25% of damages
Must satisfy certain conditions to be lawful
doesn’t fund disbursements (Expert/court fees), separate funding needed
if lose- liable for disbursement/opponent’s costs
if win- recover normal fee/disbursement/damages
Community Legal Service (CLS)(Legal Aid)
Stricts constraints on eligibility.
Eligibility for civil CLS funding:
must be individual, family/homelessness/DV disputes, low income and capital, must have meritorious claim
Damages based agreements (DBAs)- funding civil litigation
no win no fee
solicitor won’t get paid unless case wins- then paid a proportion of damages (not solicitors fees) (max amount is 25% damages in PI (excluding LOFI), 35% employment and 50% in other (nothing if fails)
does not cover disbursements
Third party funding (civil lit)
independent funding from 3rd party (banks, PE, hedge funds) in hope of successful claim, money back + uplift
Association of Litigation Funders guidelines- must not be misleading/try control litigation/have sufficient funds
limited to commercial cases of high value (not consumer cases)
Ways of charging a client
Hourly charging
Fixed fees
Unbundled legal services - fee for a specific legal task rather than generally representing client
Undertakings: Good Practice
Firms maintain registers as they are specifically enforceable.
They are drafted to be
Specific
Measured
Agreed
Realistic
Timed
Ambiguity construed in favour of recipient
Undertaking
A statement (oral/written) to someone that is reliant on it (makes it binding), that you will do/refrain from doing sth.
Doesn’t need the word ‘undertake.’
CCS 1.3 requires solicitors to perform all undertakings and to do so within an agreed timescale/reasonable amount of time
can be given to any individual in the firm
serious disciplinary offence to disobey
Solicitor dealing with the court
s50(1) Solicitors Act 1974- Solicitor is an officer of the court (overriding duty to the court, req. good behaviour)
CCS 2- must not waste the court’s time/be in contempt of court/ only put forward arguable statements
Solicitor misleading the court
CCS 1.4- must not mislead/attempt to mislead clients/court/others through act/omission or being complicit in those of others
Must immediately inform the court with client’s consent if accidentally done/cease to act if no consent
(draft non-arguable docs/facts, make case-unrelated allegations of crime, call on lying witness)
CCS 2 duties to the court
2.1 attempt to/or misuse/tamper with evidence
2.2 influence the substance of evidence (falsify/tamper witnesses)
2.3 do not bribe witnesses
2.4 only made assertions which are properly arguable
2.5 don’t be in contempt of court
2.6 don’t waste the courts time
2.7 draw court’s attention to relevant cases/statutes/procedure
Instructed to act by someone other than arrested client
CCS1.1- free to choose/not choose any client as long as not unlawfully discriminating.
CCS3.1- only act for client on instructions from them/someone properly authorised. Make sure instructions represent your clients wishes.
PACE- access to solicitor can’t be delayed because someone else called them
Practice- contact police and tell them someone else has contacted you, they inform client who confirms that they wish to instruct you (but their solicitor of choice/duty solicitor may have already been retained)
Conflicts of interests between clients
CCS 6.2 + Law Society notes
if conflict/signif risk of conflict between 2 or more clients, you must not act for all or possibly any of them
exceptions not applicable in criminal litigation: you must not act
1 litigator for all co-defendants in legal aid case- must be satisfied that they don’t signif. conflict (inc. future conflict, consider you must act in your client’s best interest)
confidential info may need to be disclosed to other client if relevant to their case (with consent- if no consent, both must therefore know that you are advising multiple clients
Confidentiality and Disclosure- criminal lit
Confidentiality- CCS 6.3 - (eternal) duty to protect confidential information of current and former clients unless disclosure required/permitted by law/client consents
Disclosure- CCS 6.4 - advisor must make client aware of all information material
CCS 6.5 don’t work for A where confidential information held for B which is material to A unless confidential information can be protected CCS 6.5a/b don’t apply to criminal cases- no information barriers
Duty of confidentiality more important than duty of disclosure but if duty of disclosure cannot be complied with, cannot continue to act, must not disclose reasons to client
When a conflict arises
e.g. if D changes plea/evident
decide between duty to disclose info to retained client puts you in breach of duty of confidentiality to the other and vice versa- if so must not act for either
cannot pass client to another member of your firm (no information barrier crim lit)
Guilty client but not guilty plea
not misleading the court (as long as not maintaining a positive case innocence- simply silent)
prosecution must prove the guilt of the defendant not innocence
Perverting the court of justice - breaching CCS
manufacturing false evidence- ccs 2.2
destroying/concealing evidence
interfering with witnesses
knowingly acting for D who assumes a false name with intent to deceive the courts and deliberately assisting your client to evade arrest