Professional Responsibility Flashcards
Professional Responsibility Rules from Outline
What is the duty of Loyalty?(Pr)
The lawyer’s duty to his client that requires the lawyer to put the interest of his client above all other interests and to avoid any conflicts of interest.
How can a concurrent conflict of interest arise between current clients?
Between current clients if representation of one client is directly adverse to another client
When is there a concurrent conflict between a current client and a lawyer’s responsibility to another client, former client, third person, or personal interest?
When there is a significant risk that representation of one or more clients will be materially limited by these responsibilities.
Can a lawyer represent clients with interests that are directly adverse?
No.
When can a lawyer represent a client despite concurrent conflict?
Lawyer reasonably believes can competently and diligently represent each affected client, clients not directly adverse, written informed consent, not prohibited by law.
What is the California no risk limitation regarding Concurrent Conflicts of Interest?
Lawyer must always provide written disclosure of conflicts and meet exceptions to concurrent conflicts of interest when any lawyer in firm has any relationship to party or witness, or another party’s lawyer is related to lawyer/client of lawyer/intimate relationship with lawyer. Even in absence of significant risk.
3 primary types of conflict. Conflict between client and ____
Client, Third Party, Attorney’s personal interests
In California, can a lawyer represent both the insurer and the insured?
Yes, where the insurer has contractual right to unilaterally select counsel for the insured.
Who does lawyer employed by organization represent? In whose best interests must lawyer act?
Represents organization and must act in best interest of organization.
Is representation of organization and its officers/directors/employees/other constituents a concurrent conflict?
Yes.
Under the model rules, what should a lawyer do when she identifies misconduct of employee/officer/other person associated with an organization.
If the lawyer knows person associated with organization is engaged in or intends to engage in action that is violation of legal obligation and is likely to result in substantial injury to the organization, lawyer shall report up UNLESS lawyer reasonably believes not in best interest of org to do so.
CA: lawyer knows or reasonably should know - higher standard
If a corporation’s lawyer identifies misconduct, reports up, and the highest authority fails to take action, should the lawyer report out?
Model Rules: Lawyer MAY report out and reveal information if disclosure necessary to prevent injury.
California: Lawyer can report out ONLY if necessary to prevent a criminal act likely to result in death or substantial bodily harm. (Can urge reconsideration, withdraw from representation)
Can a lawyer represent multiple defendants in an aggregate settlement or guilty plea?
Only with informed written consent.
Under what circumstances are conflicts of one attorney NOT imputed to all attorneys in the firm?
When the conflicts are personal in nature and doesn’t present significant risk of materially limitation representation by other firm attorneys, or conflicts based on former client at prior firm; written notice for former client and proper screen.
Generally, are conflicts for one attorney imputed to all attorneys in the firm?
Yes
How can a client waive imputed disqualification
Client can waive with informed written consent.
When does a conflict exist between attorney’s client and third party?
Conflict exists if there is significant risk that representation of a client will be materially limited by lawyer’s loyalty/responsibility to a third party.
Under what circumstances can lawyer accept compensation from third party to represent client?
Only if client gives informed consent. (CA: Consent must be written) AND no interference with lawyer/s independent professional judgment or with lawyer client relationship, and information relating to representation remains confidential.
When does conflict exist between client and lawyer’s personal interest?
Significant risk that representation of client will be materially limited by lawyer’s personal interest
Can a lawyer’s personal beliefs result in a conflict between client and personal interests?
Yes.
Types of conflicts between client and lawyer’s personal interest
Lawyer’s personal relationships and belief, sexual relations with client unless consensual sexual relationship existed before lawyer-client relationship; business transactions with clients; solicitation of gifts from client that creates conflict; proprietary interest; financial assistance/advances to clients; limiting malpractice liability; settlement of claims with former client
Can a lawyer represent client if there is conflict with his personal beliefs?
Yes - with full disclosure and written consent.
CA distinction: when must lawyer issue written disclosure regarding lawyer’s personal relationships?
one lawyer is client of the other lawyer, two lawyers cohabitate, two lawyers have personal intimate relationship
Under what circumstances can a lawyer enter into a business transaction with client, or knowingly acquiring an interest adverse to client?
terms are fair and reasonable to client,
terms fully disclosed in writing (CA: lawyer’s role in transaction fully disclosed);
client advised in writing to seek independent counsel (CA: client actually represented by independent lawyer);
client gives informed written consent to essential terms.
Can a lawyer solicit a gift from a client or prepare an instrument giving the lawyer a gift? Ca rules?
Lawyer cannot solicit gift or prepare instrument giving lawyer (or personal relating to lawyer) a gift unless lawyer/person is related to the client.
CA: lawyer can accept if client has been advised by independent lawyer who has provided certificate of independent review, or if gift is fair/no undue influence
Can a lawyer acquire proprietary interest in cause of action or subject matter of litigation?
Yes, lien to secure attorney services, or contract for reasonable contingency fee in civil case.
Can a lawyer provide financial assistance to client?
ABA: Only contingency cases, and advance court costs/ expenses of litigation for indigent clients.
CA Rule: Lawyer can lend for any purpose if client promises in writing to repay.
Can a lawyer limit malpractice liability under MR? Under CA Rules?
ABA: only if client represented by independent counsel
CA: Not allowed. Ever.
Rule: lawyer settlement a claim or potential claim for liability with unrepresented/former client.
ABA: Only if client is advised to seek (and given reasonable opportunity to seek) advice of independent legal counsel. CA: Client actually represented by independent counsel.
Rule: Duty to Communicate (to client)
Lawyer shall prompty inform client of any decision that informs client’s informed consent, keep client informed of status of case including settlement/plea offers, and promptly respond to client.
CA: Lawyer can delay transmission if lawyer reasonably relieves client would react in a way that would cause imminent harm to client or others.
Rule: Scope of Representation
Client: Substantive decisions (settle/plea/waive jury trial, testify,appeal) Attorney: Legal strategy (motions, discovery, witness, evidence use.)
Exceptions to duty of Confidentiality - ABA Rule
No revealing, EXCEPT Cats and Dogs Can Cuddle And Dream : Consent, Disclosure impliedly authorized, disclosure to prevent Death/harm; prevent client from committing Crime or to mitigate crime/fraud injury to financial interests; Comply with court order, secure legal Advice about lawyer’s compliance with ethics rules or establish claim or Defense on behalf of lawyer in controversy between lawyer and client.
Duty of Confidentiality - CA Rule
MUCH STRICTER THAN ABA Rule.
lawyer shall not revel information relating to representation of client without the informed consent of the client, except:
- when necessary to prevent a crime that would cause reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm. (First good faith effort to persuade client, inform client, only reveal as much information as necessary);
- when compelled by court order
- to establish claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in controversy between lawyer and client
Attorney Client Privilege: Rule
Allows client to keep communications with his attorney confidential. Communictions must be intended to be confidential and for the purpose of facilitating legal services. Client can refuse to testify and prevent attorney from testify.
What does the attorney client privilege apply to?
Communications, not physical evidence.