Professional Practice Flashcards
Standard of Care
providing a service that is equal to the standard in the area - doing the same thing another architect under the same conditions would do expected quality of service - determines if an architect is at fault
Why is a warranty not included in the contract?
you are creating a “guarantee” with a warranty - this creates an unacceptable level of risk and obligation. This would not be covered by professional liability insurance
the following phrases in a contract may void professional liability insurance
-as necessary
-as required
-Hold Harmless
-Indemnification
Standard AIA contracts are…
prepared for and by the AIA. these are the most common contracts used. Sections may be adjusted by a client or architect
Which building typology is most prone to litigation?
Condos
-expensive to build and own
-condo association - Lawyer’s on staff
-residential risks are higher in general
-clients not experienced with construction industry
emotional attachment to homes
What is the goal of Risk management
not about eliminating risk but about ASSESSING and MANAGING it
- understand the risk in a project and build it into the fee
-do not take every project
unknown clients, inexperienced owners, history of litigation = higher risk
Addendum
drawings that are issued after they have gone to bid but before a contractor/bid has been selected
Allowance
Providing a sum built into the contract to allow for something to be bought in the future for the project
- casework, appliances, specialty light fixtures
Change Order
occurs after the contract has been signed by the contractor when something needs to be changes
contractor, owner and architect must all agree and sign this
Underbidding
contractors can underbid and plan to request change orders so they can charge a premium
-unethical
-why there are requirements to be met when selecting bidders
Construction Change Directive
Architect will direct a contractor to change something
- usually happens when there is a dispute but the project needs to move forward as the dispute is managed (could be cost of a change order)
Design-Bid-Build
Traditional form of architecture/construction project
Architect > Bid > Contractor is selected
(CSP)
Linear, roles clearly defined
Architect + owner contract
Contractor + owner contract
takes a long time - the owner and architect want documents as correct as possible to minimize change orders
less expensive because its a final bid
not good if youre in a hurry
contractor cannot sue directly to architect here because they dont share a contract
Contractor responsibilities
-everything in the contract, no matter what, and nothing that isnt in the contract
Owner responsibilities
-responsible for everything needed that is NOT in the contract documents, even f the architect overlooked something
could be
-change order, site condition, asbestos, hazardous materials
Architect Responsibilities
(AIA contracts protect the architect)
-liable for not much
-responsible for a lot
-instruments of service (drawings, specs, models, etc)
-arriving on time
-being under budget
-coordination
Owner Responsibilities
What is on site
-geotech
-hazardous materials
-site conditions
-site boundaries, easements etc
-permitting/legal
-surveyors
-regulations, permitting and compliance
-traffic -
Paying contractor
Paying owners consultants
Change orders
With or without cause hiring and firing of architect
Contractor Responsibilities
everything in the contract (documents, specs, etc)
Architect Responsibilities
(AIA contracts protect the architect)
-liable for not much
-responsible for a lot
-instruments of service (drawings, specs, models, etc)
-arriving on time
-being under budget
-coordination
-administration
Architect Base Services (consultants)
Structural Engineer
MEP engineers
Architect Additional Services (Consultants)
Civil Engineer (sometimes hired by owner)
Landscape Architect
Security Consultant
Tech Consultant
Lighting Consultant
Acoustic Consultant
AV Consultant
Cost Estimator
Code Consultant
Sustainability Consultant
Contractor/Construction Manager (Consultants)
Plumber
Demolition Company
Subcontractors, etc
AIA B101 (owner-architect) insurance requirements
Automotive Liability Insurance
General Liability Insurance
Professional Liability Insurance
Workers Compensation Insurance
Employers Liability Insurance
Consultants are required the same insurance
AIA B101
owner-architect agreement
for design-bid-build
requires we consider environmentally responsible design alternatives
practice standard of care
keep to a schedule (on time and on budget (+10%)
obliges architect to get a cost estimate after SD, DD, CD - owner in writing states it is ok to proceed - approval after CD allows you to bid
(if architect does not meet bid budget, it can be on architect to redesign for free)
EXCUSES architect from mistakes associated with OWNER hired consultants (add service to coordinate)
obliges the architect to visit the site one year after substantial completion
takes no responsibility for contractor
takes no responsibility for shop drawing accuracy - only for intent
administration of the construction contract bid process
administration of the contract
-checks that project is running smoothly, not responsible for contractor’s work, architects drawings must depict necessary details for the contractor
responding quickly to Requests for Information (RFIs)
architect can be fired “for convenience” - owner has to pay up to what the architect has done and what the consultants are owed + the profit the firm expected from the project
the architect cannot transfer the contract
-if an owner changes, they must acquire the contract
one year warranty required
AIA A101
owner-contractor agreement
for design-bid-build
Automotive Liability Insurance
car accidents are one of the biggest risks for a firm
-owner may require firm to have this
-it extends to personal cars and taxis, not just company cars
General Liability Insurance
Basic insurances that covers physical property damage and injury claims against the firm
-covers legitimate and fraudulent claims
Professional Liability Insurance
Errors and Omissions insurance
provides protection if someone accuses you of not doing your job correctly
covers mistakes made by the architect
Workers Compensation Insurance
in case of an injured worker it provides wage replacement and medical care costs. Employees waive the right to sue the firm.
Business Interruption Insurance
Pays expenses and loss of profits if work is interrupted
usually due to natural disasters, fires, hurricanes, floods, etc
Intellectual Property Insurance
covers you if someone else claims you infringed on their copyright or pays out the claim if you didnt steal the idea
Employment Practice Liability Insurance
Lawsuits
-wrongful termination
-discrimination
-sexual harassment
Contractual Liability Insurance
covers you when something goes wrong and you are held responsible for it by the contract. this is covered under general liability insurance. Covers liability owner assumes from the contract. To pay on behalf of the indemnitor the damages to the third party. is for non-professional incidents like a fall or dog bite at the office.
Disciplinary, Regulatory or Administrative Expenses
Sub-component of Professional Liability Insurance
- state licensing board, OSHA, ADA, Fair Housing act etc — this protects you in they say you violated a rule
Professional Liability Insurance
Covers you if you do something wrong unintentionally
General Liability Insurance
Accidental Insurance
Aggregate Limit (insurance)
max amount paid by insurance company
Pay application
Architect acts as the owners representative as a professional in the industry - it is the architects responsibility to review pay apps and confirm the amounts the contractor is charging align with the work completed/purchased on site
Contract Change
Scope Change (program, cost, time etc)
this is an addendum to the contract, owner must review and sign
Who owns the drawings after the building is built?
Architect
architect gives owner and contractor a limited license to use the drawings
Architects can sell the drawings (usually when they want to build multiple)
-charge for drawings + lost profits for what you would make if we designed the other x amount of buildings
-requires a clause indemnifying the architect - owner must take full responsibility for how the drawings will be executed by other architects and contractors
Indemnify
Hold harmless, remove liability
When can the owner get rights to the drawings, even if the architect doesn’t want to give them away?
Architect was terminated for cause
- the architect and consultants still have copyrights to their drawings in this case
Additional Services
(this was AIA’s way of getting the architect more money)
Programming
Multiple Preliminary Designs
Measured Drawings
Existing Facilities Surveys
Site Evaluation and Planning
Building Information Modeling
Civil Engineering
Landscape Design
Architectural Interior Design
Value Analysis
Detailed Cost Estimating
On-site project representation
Conformed Construction Documents
As-Designed Record Drawings
As-constructed record drawings
Post-Occupancy Evaluation
Facility Support Services
Tenant-related services
Coordination of owner’s consultants
Telecommunications/Data Design
Security Evaluation and Planning
Commissioning
Extensive Environmentally Responsible Design
LEED Certification
Fast-Trak Design Services
Historic Preservation
FFE - Fixtures, Furnishings and equipment design
Circulation Area
Circulation, including elevator lobbies, hallways and corridors
Gross Area
everything inside the OUTSIDE edge of the enclosure (so everything)
Net Area
total identified program space, not including circulation, mechanical, toilets etc. Just where work will happen
Rentable Area
everything that isn’t shared on other floors (mechanical, elevators, stairs, etc)
Usable Area
Everything but the core
Floor Area Ratio (FAR)
Floor area x levels / site area
measures efficiency of the plan
Net to Gross Area
Net area / gross area
usable space out of total space - closer to 1.0 the better
Direct Salary Expense Multiplier
generally 3-4 of base salary
this is what gets charged over the base pay of employees to cover indirect salary, overhead, profit
Same as net multiplier
Overhead Rate
Indirect expenses / direct expenses
Total overhead / Direct Salary
for every $1 we pay our employee, we have an additional $x expense for the firm (does not include profit)
Break-even multiplier
Overhead Rate + 1
Total overhead + Direct Salary / Direct Salary
Direct Salary Expense Multiplier (DSE)
Total Overhead + Direct Salary + Profit goal
________________
Direct Salary
How much we need to charge about the direct salary of employees to cover overhead and profit
Utilization Rate
Total Direct Salary / Base Salary
Base Salary is direct + indirect salary (what the employee is paid by the company)
How efficient is the employees hours (billable to client)
Revenue Factor
yield on total payroll
measures firm profitability
Fee revenue per dollar spent
Utilization rate * Direct Salary Expense Multiplier = revenue factor
(70% * 3) = 2.1
over 2 is a good indicator of a healthy balance of work and fees
Negotiated Select Team
Construction Manager is included early
sub-flavor of Design bid build
bring contractor in at early design with a contract and incentives
allows difficult portions of work/fabrication to begin early
quicker, better quality (you get the pick the contractor), can be more expensive because there is no bid
Negotiated Bid
better quality
Competitive Bid
Lower construction cost
Invited Bid
Special qualifications needed for program
Cost Plus Fixed Fee (contractor)
contractor is disincentivized from allowing construction costs to inflate
Time + materials + overhead (coordination) + fixed profit
another type of design-bid-build
contractor is selected after documents, but it is not a typical bid
Fixed Fee allows contractor to keep profit and be flexible with owner and architect if something changes
good if there may be unknowns on the site (brownfield)
Construction Manager as Advisor
Owner hires the construction manager early and they work with the architect. usually has expertise that can reduce cost and time. owners rep
Owner has separate contracts with architect, construction manager, contractor
Construction Manager as Agent
Owner hires construction manager to manage and administer the contract in their place. CM has More authority and control, minimal risk, brought on early
Owner > CM
CM > architect and contractor
Construction Manager as Constructor/at Risk
Construction manager IS contractor
Construction manager and architect are engaged at the same time
quicker and less risky for owner, but typically more expensive
minimal bidding
Design Build
Owner has one single contract that covers the architect and contractor.
The architect is no longer the agent of the owner. The architect and contractor are a team.
less risk
quicker because there is no bid process
Can reduce Quality
Bridged Design Build
The owner hires a “bridging consultant” usually the design architect who designs SD and maybe DD set. they represent the owner with the contractor.
owner has design architect contract and production architect/contractor contract (the design build team)
Design build teams designs CD set and constructs building
Integrated Project Delivery (IPD)
owner, architect, and contract are all under one contract together
join together as a single entity
share information with each other w/o fear of litigation
share benefits and risks of the project with each other
works well with BIM
used mainly for large and complex projects right now (hospitals)
less time spent covering self and more time on design (minimal disputes)
Challenges
owners are resisitant
insurance industry doesnt know how to cover
oversaring - intellectual property
not for risk adverse
Strategic Alliance
a temporary teaming agreement
a group of people agreeing to work with each other to get or for a project and then are no longer bound (friendship/group project)
they share information and technology
(if one person get sued, everyone can get sued)
Joint Venture
2 companies get together to make a 3rd company that is jointly owned (baby company)
usually after project is awarded to architect (an architect may join a joint venture with engineers for a project)
may dissolve at the end of the project or continue
profits are shared
(if one person get sued, everyone can get sued)
Partnership
like a marriage, everything is shared and acts as 1 company
(if one person get sued, everyone can get sued)
C Corporation
large public company like Apple or Google that has a lot of stock
has liability protection
is double taxed - corporate income tax and taxes on bonus wages/dividends
good for medium to large firms
Double Taxed, profits, then after dividends the profit is taxed again
Limited Liability Corporation (LLC)
provides simultaneous liability protection and avoids double taxation
file this with the state
federal tax ID
if you are sued at work, you can lose your home/assets - LLC separates personal investments from your professional activity
can still have partners - all equally liable
good for all size firms
Tax Classification: Sole proprietorship, S Corporation, C Corporation, Partnership (lots of options)
Sole Proprietorship
not registered with the state
provides no liability protection
no separation between personal and professional assets
no double taxation
not enough protection for architecture or construction professionals
can be sued easily
Tax Classification: Sole proprietorship (all taxed as one)
General Partnership
like a sole proprietorship - no liability protection
important to get everything in writing (partnerships dissolve often because it isnt documented)
document ownership structure, management structure, risks, liabilities, roles of partners etc
Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)
provides simultaneous liability protection and avoids double taxation
almost identical to LLC but can have partnerships at different levels of interest/liability (investors)
file this with the state
federal tax ID
if you are sued at work, you can lose your home/assets - LLC separates personal investments from your professional activity
good for all size firms
Tax Classification: Sole proprietorship, S Corporation, C Corporation, Partnership (lots of options)
B Corporation
(think Ben and Jerry’s)
allowed to define “success” more broadly than a typical bottom line
often includes social and environmental responsibility
establishes another motive for future growth to hold onto
Triple Bottom Line
Profit + People + Planet
Scheduled Performance Index (SPI)
earned value / planned earned value
what have you been paid / what should you be paid at this point
closer to 1 means you are on track
The Fair Labor Act
Establishes minimum wage
establishes which employee is management - management is not entitled to overtime pay
people that are not part of management require overtime pay for time worked over 40 hours per week (1.5x)
forbids child labor
The Davis Bacon Act
public works projects - says a fair local prevailing wage shall be paid
The Occupational Safety and Health Act
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
protects workers from hazards on the job
-excessive noise levels, dangerous mechanical conditions, unsanitary conditions, excessive heat or cold, physical stress
enforces workplace safety regulations for things like construction falls, exposure to dangerous elements, requires safety vest and hardhats
The Affordable Care Act
Obamacare
applies to architecture firms, HR specifically
requires firms that have more than 50 employees to provide health insurance to 95% of employees or a fee will be charged
Phased Bid
Fast track construction
portions of the construction will be bid on piecemeal
design and fabricate parts before plans are finalized
Negotiated Bid
Contractor works with the architect from the beginning of the project
final bid is between contractor and the owner
increased quality at higher cost because the contractor is working with the architect in real time
Invited Bid
Design-Bid-Build
only open to prequalified contractors
Surety Bonds
works like insurance that protects the owner if the contractor doesn’t follow through with completing the project
the third party insurer will pay the owner to finish the project
regulated by the state insurance oversight agency
works like posting bail
the contractor buys to guarantee payment to the owner
Bid Bond and Performance Bonds (types of surety bonds)
Bid Bond
AIA Document A310
an agreement that if the low bidder cannot follow through the work, the bid bond should pay the difference of low bidder’s bid and the next lowest bid to complete the work
both the owner and contractor are protected
Performance Bond
the third party offers to pay for the project to be completed if the contractor defaults
Business Performance Bond
used in building operations
third party insurer
Contractor’s License Bond
Insures contractors against breaking construction laws
some states require this to maintain contractor license
Why are late bids not accepted on public projects?
the opening of sealed bids is done publicly. A late bidder cannot wait and see everyone elses bid and underprice the lowest bid to win. this prevents corruption
Sealed Bids
very strict rules
we look for
lowest responsive bid (most responsive to entire RFP - make sure it includes everything in the project)
lowest responsible bidder (contractor reputation)
Contractor / continuing warranty
lasts one year
everything must be completed correctly
must fix anything during project and 1 year past substantial completion
if something breaks 8 months in, contractor must fix/replace then it is a new 12 month warranty
ends when statute of repose expires (25 year roof warranty means contractor is responsible for 25 years)
does not cover improper operation/normal wear or work that was not done by the contractor
contract can state to extend this period
Substantial Completion
when the building is fit for its intended use
job is not finished, but meets intended use and the owner can move forward/in
begins the 1 year warranty period
if substantial completion is not met at the specified time, it is late
Final Completion
If it comes after the deadline, it is not considered late
after substantial completion, there may still be work to be finished like landscape or other small items that do not prevent you from using the building
architect declares the project in final completion (after punch list is complete)
Punch List
required to be completed by contractor not architect
Weather Delay Days
built into contract
if abnormal weather, architect can decide if contractor is allowed to take extra time without penalty
weather log shall be submitted with pay app
What is the path of the contractor’s invoices to the owner? AIA G702
Contractor-Architect-Owner
application and certificate for payment - to be signed and notarized by contractor
What is included in the pay app?
Change order summary
the amount of money needed to complete the project
the amount of current retainage for the work-in-place
the amount of current retainage for stored materials
certification that the subs have been paid
Retainage
Money owed to the contractor but intentionally not paid yet
a % defined in the contract per invoice that is held and paid at the end of the contract - this makes sure the contractor finishes the job so he gets his money at the end
materials stored does NOT equal wok completed - there may be additional % retained for materials stored and not installed yet
retainage gets paid at substantial completion but if there is a punchlist, an amount double the value of the punch list items is still held, to be released after the punch list is completed
Mechanic’s Lien
Laws to make sure the subcontractor gets paid by the contractor
if it goes to court, the owner will have to pay sub even if contractor says they did, if court determines sub was not paid, the can put a lien on the building until it is paid
Architect’s can file too if a building is designed but not built
a claim against the owner’s property due to unpaid debts
Shop drawings/Product Data submittals
architect to review for design intent, but contractor is responsible at the end of the day
architect is responsible to review in a timely manner