Preliminaries To Prosecution Flashcards
what are police powers?
Police powers include arrest, detention, questioning and interrogation ,entry and search of possessions, personal search and the taking of samples, procedures for identification and largely governed by PACE Act 1984, associated with PACE codes of practice
what happens if police powers are not done in accordance with PACE?
If they are not done in accordance with pace then it can give rise for the evidence which is gathered to become inadmissible in court.
when is use of force by the police allowed?
S. 117 PACE act 1984 allows reasonable force to be used by a constable in the exercise of a police power where necessary, for:
- stop and search
- entry and search of premises
- arrest
- detention of person at police station
- intimate search of person detained
- search of a person
- fingerprinting without consent
- use of force in connection with visual identification
- taking intimate sample
- prevention of crime
the degree of force which is allowed by the police?
- the force which is used have to be necessary and reasonable in the circumstances
- to determine whether the force is reasonable, court takes into account all the circumstances in the situation.
- Degree and nature of force used, gravity of the situation
- Preventing the harm by other means
- The fact that the force used has resulted in a serious injury does not amount to unreasonable force.
- Use of excessive force will not render the use of force unreasonable
police use of handcuffs
- Only to be used where it is reasonable and necessary to prevent an escape
- Prevent the violent breach of the peace of a prisoner
- Same rule applied when handcuffs are used in court
- Where handcuffs are unlawful, it is classified as a trespass to person
can the lawfulness of an arrest be challenged?
- If the lawfulness of an arrest is challenged, it is for that arresting officer to prove that the arrest was made in good faith
- The burden of proof of the lawful arrest is on the police, if arrest was lawful, proving excessive force is on the complainant
what is an arrest?
There is no set definition
The loose definition is that where someone is under suspicion of committing a crime, their movements are restricted and they are under compulsion.
what happens if an officer takes hold of someones arm whist considering an arrest?
this amounts to a trespass to the person
what happens if an officer, without or before an arrest, restrains a person to a confined space, such as a cell, and therefore restricted their movements completely?
this amounts to unlawful imprisonment.
An arrest to motivate or to further investigate into a serious offence is…
…not unlawful
No assumption that an arrest will be followed by…
…a charge
Where the officer knows there is no possibility of a charge being made, then arrest will be…
…unlawful
what happens if a complainant removes or withdraws a complaint to the police?
Officer may still arrest even if complainant removes or withdraws a complaint, in the hope officer will obtain a confession
what are the formalities when arresting someone?
- An arrest is unlawful unless the person is informed as soon as it is practicable that they are arrested and on what basis.
- Even if an arrest was obvious, officer still needs to communicate on what basis the arrest is made
- Person has to be told in simple, non-technical language. All considering the circumstances of the arrest
- When and where the alleged offence happened needs to be communicated when arrested
- Person must be cautioned at the time of the arrest or as soon as it is practicable
- Failure to caution does not render the arrest unlawful but it can give grounds to have evidence excluded
- All must be recorded by the officer’s notebook
- Record must be made at the time of the arrest or if impracticable at the time as soon as it is practicable to do so.
- Must also be attached in custody record
what actions are to be taken following an arrest?
- Constable needs to take the person to a designated police station as soon as practicable after the arrest.
- If a constable finds no other reason to continue the arrest and no bail, then they must release person.
- Exceptional circumstances provide situations where person may not be taken to designated police station
police bail following arrest
- Arrested person may be released on police bail instead of being taken into custody
- Constable has to think it is necessary and proportionate to release individual on police bail in consideration to the circumstances
- Has to be confirmed by a custody officer
- Police bail may have conditions attached, like the surrender of a passport or curfew. These can be varied.
is a suspect has been arrested and the police suspect they have committed a further offence, what must the police do?
further arrest that suspect for the additional offence.
A constable may arrest without a warrant—
(a) anyone who is about to commit an offence;
(b) anyone who is in the act of committing an offence;
(c) anyone whom he has reasonable grounds for suspecting to be about to commit an offence;
(d) anyone whom he has reasonable grounds for suspecting to be committing an offence.
If a constable has reasonable grounds for suspecting that an offence has been committed, he may arrest without a warrant anyone whom…
…he has reasonable grounds to suspect of being guilty of it.
If an offence has been committed, a constable may arrest without a warrant—
(a) anyone who is guilty of the offence;
(b) anyone whom he has reasonable grounds for suspecting to be guilty of it.
for a lawful arrest, what does it mean for a constable to have reasons for the arrest?
(a) to enable the name of the person in question to be ascertained (in the case where the constable does not know, and cannot readily ascertain, the person’s name, or has reasonable grounds for doubting whether a name given by the person as his name is his real name);
(b) correspondingly as regards the person’s address;
(c) to prevent the person in question—
(i) causing physical injury to himself or any other person;
(ii) suffering physical injury;
(iii) causing loss of or damage to property;
(iv) committing an offence against public decency; or
(v) causing an unlawful obstruction of the highway;
(d)to protect a child or other vulnerable person from the person in question;
(e)to allow the prompt and effective investigation of the offence or of the conduct of the person in question;
(f)to prevent any prosecution for the offence from being hindered by the disappearance of the person in question.
arrest for breach of the peace
Both police and civilian have the power to arrest for breach of the peace
Criteria
- Breach of peace is committed in persons presence
- Person arresting thinks breach of peace will happen immediately
- Breach of peace has occurred or arresting person thinks it has occurred.
Reasonable belief is objective test
can the crown court issue an arrest warrant?
yes. if the defendant fails to attend court and has been bailed to do so.
Magistrates power to issue an arrest warrant
magistrates can issue an arrest warrant:
- when the offence is indictable
- when the offence is imprisonable
- when the person’s address must be insufficiently established for a summons to be served; or
- when the individual has failed to appear after summons
Custody officer:
- Must be of a rank of at least sergeant
- Custody officer ensures that the person is held in accordance with Code C
- Detention for longer than 6 hours the person should be taken to designated police station
Custody Records:
- Opened and done as soon as practicable when the person has arrived at the police station
- All records of the persons arrest and length of detention is recorded here
A separate custody record must be opened as soon as practicable for each detainee whether a person is brought to the police station under arrest, or arrested at the police station, or surrenders voluntarily at the police station, or surrenders to bail at the police station. All information required to be recorded under must be recorded on the custody record.
Basic information to be recorded must include:
* the requirement to inform the person of the reason for his arrest;
* the circumstances of the arrest;
* why the arrest was necessary; and
* any comments made by the arrested person.
right to notification.
- Arrested individual has the right to have someone notified upon their arrest
- This can be a friend, relative etc
- To be to be as soon as practicable
- The detainee can request this every time he/she is moved to a different station
- Detainee has 2 alternatives if the first one does not reply
- All at public expense
- Custody officer has discretion to allow further attempts if necessary
- Custody officer should provide local volunteers for when detainee needs advice
right to legal advice
- Everyone is entitled to legal advice when held in custody, this is a human right
- This does not apply even if the custody time period is about to run out and no legal advice is available, the person detained must be released if the time runs out
- Detainee should be told about right to consult solicitor when they are brought to the station
- Should be done before interview, or re-interview, when custody time period is being updated etc.
what must a custody officer do if they suspect that an individual is a child or vulnerable person?
treat them as such until proven otherwise
role of an Appropriate adult:
- Make sure police are acting properly and fairly
- Still subject to legal privilege
- Appropriate adult must be present unless delay would significantly hinder the evidence, other people or the case at hand
- That must be authorised by a Superintendent or above
- Appropriate adult for a person who is aged 14-18 can give consent, otherwise any child below 14 needs a parent or guardian to give consent for strip searches
relevant time for detention time limits - hospital
- Relevant time does not count time spent and travelling to and from the hospital
- Person who is hospitalised shall not be questioned without consent from doctor
- Person is still entitled to solicitor if questioned in these circumstances
- It involves psychiatric and psychological treatment in hospital
In the circumstances where interviews can be conducted elsewhere other than a police station, once the risk has been averted…
… the interviewing must cease in these circumstances and be conducted in a police station
special warnings
In addition to the caution, where a suspect is interviewed at a police station or other authorised place of detention following arrest and:
a) is asked to account for any object, mark or substance, or mark on such objects found on his or her person, in or on his or her clothing or footwear, otherwise in his or her possession, or in the place where the arrest took place; or
b) to account for his or her presence at the place where the arrest took place,
a special warning must be given. Inferences cannot be drawn if the warning is not given. The requirement to give a special warning does not apply where the person who has requested a solicitor is interviewed without having been given an opportunity to consult the solicitor, since inferences from refusal or failure to account cannot be drawn as a result.
reminding suspect of access to legal advice
officer must always remind suspect of access to solicitor. This does not apply when they have representation which is delayed
where must an interview take place?
designated police station
what is an interview?
questioning of a person regarding their involvement or suspected involvement in a criminal offence or offences
what must happen for a suspect to be interviewed?
individual needs to be cautioned
when is a caution not necessary to interview?
(a)solely to establish identify or ownership of a vehicle;
(b)to obtain information in accordance with a statutory requirement, (note that the statutory drink-driving procedure is not an interview)
(c)in furtherance of the proper and effective conduct of a search (although if questioning goes further, e.g., to establish whether drugs found were intended to be supplied to another, a caution will be necessary
(d)to seek verification of a written record of comments made by the person outside an interview.
information that should be given to the suspect
before an interview takes place, the suspect and their solicitor (if they have one) should be given all sufficient information for them to understand what offence they are suspected to have committed and why.
what is the caution, verbatim?
You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence.
consequences of failing to give caution
Failure to administer a caution in circumstances where it is required is a significant and substantial breach of Code C, although it will not necessarily result in exclusion of evidence of the interview
does the caution have to be given word for word?
Minor deviation from these words is permissible provided that the sense of the caution is preserved.