Precise Impact in Decline of Magical Belief Flashcards
What were the reasons for decline in magical belief?
- Changing attitudes
- Intellectual context
What were changing attitudes and what impact did they have?
- A growth in scepticism
- Led to fraudulent cases being discovered and sceptic publications.
- Ultimately, added to judicial scepticism.
What was intellectual context and what impact did it have?
- Involved making sense of the universe and increase in human knowledge.
- Added to judicial scepticism.
What are examples of fraudulent cases?
1597- The Boy of Burton Case
1634- The Pendle Swindle Case
1662- The Demon Drummer of Tedworth Case
1712- The Jane Wenham Case
How did the the Boy of Burton Case lead to a scepticism of exorcism with witches? (1597)
- Darrell’s reputation lent the case significance- a well-known exorcist was proved to have been committing fraudulent practices- led to scepticism of exorcism.
How did the Boy of Burton Case (1597) affect witness testimonies in witch trials?
The exposure of Darling’s lie was also evidence of the unreliability of witness testimonies- questions around using children as witnesses/reliability of evidence.
How did the Boy of Burton Case (1597) cause a change in the church?
The case did provoke change within the church- a canon was drawn up in 1604 forbidding the practice of exorcism without a license- although not evidence of scepticism, it is more likely Church protecting its reputation.
How did the Boy of Burton Case (1597) allow more scepticism?
A Discovery of the Fraudulent Practices of John Darrell (1599) made knowledge of the case more widespread and led to the pamphlet war- theological debate around power of the Devil and reliability of exorcisms.
How did the Boy of Burton Case (1597) NOT lead to a change in magical belief?
- Did not lead to an overall disbelief in witchcraft, the case was viewed more as a one-off discovery of fraudulence.
- 1604 Act, which actually showed the increase of legal severity of witchcraft.
- Key debate was over validity of exorcisms rather than witchcraft.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) change belief in witchcraft through the Privy Council?
The involvement of the Privy Council and King Charles shows the case gained relevance amongst the powerful elites -> may have influenced the scepticism of the King.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) change belief in witchcraft through evidence?
The evidence-based approach, through further questioning and involvement of surgeons, does reveal a more careful, sceptical approach to witchcraft trials was developing.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) change witchcraft accusations?
The trial proved that witchcraft accusations can be motivated by reasons that have nothing to do with the supernatural, and accusers should be viewed sceptically.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) change belief in witchcraft?
John Webster personally met Robinson, he was influenced by the case and went onto write sceptical publication on witchcraft in 1677.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) NOT change belief in witchcraft?
The Pendle Swindle case provoked little change; there was no justice for the accused women, with many of them still held in custody three years later.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) NOT change witchcraft in the sense of sceptical publications?
There were no significant publications of this case at the time so its impact on the opinions of those outside of the trial was very limited.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) NOT change belief in witchcraft with the accusers?
Edmund Robinson went on to be a professional witch-hunter - proof the case did not impact his credibility or cause people to doubt witches existed.
How did the Pendle Swindle case (1634) NOT change belief in witchcraft in the long term?
The importance and influence of witch hunters still would rise before it declined-> 11 years before the biggest witch hunt in East Anglia during the Civil War.
How did the Demon Drummer of Tedworth case (1662) change belief in witchcraft through scepticism?
The case was continually revisited throughout the 17th century and used as an argument for scepticism.
How did the Demon Drummer of Tedworth case (1662) change belief in witchcraft in relation to publications?
The numerous publications and involvement of the Royal Society elevated the notoriety of the case and spread scepticism.