Police Ethics-Chapter 9, An Ethic to live by Flashcards
“There is no other story. A man, after he has brushed off the dust and chips of his life, will have left only the hard, clean questions: Was it good or was it evil? Have I done well- or ill?
John Steinbeck, East of Eden
Police Responding to a Higher Duty
Oct 4, 2000 Kolubara, Yugoslavia. Thousand of people gathered to protest. Peoples concern was the results of a recently held democratic election were being ignored by government. Sitting president refused to swear in candidate who had defeated him. Police called in to break up the protest. Police refused to follow orders and use force on their own people. The police had a high duty and sided with people.
Morality is rooted in and grows out of ____
character
the limits of Kant and MIll
Kant: duty trumps the good
Mill: What counts as Good
What is the purpose of good character?
it shows itself in a person as habitual tendency to understand the decent, the non-self centered thing to do, and what is good for everyone involved.
Where the police have the power to do such things, there is very little street crime- the deterrent effect of having vicious, brutal and unethical police officers is great
totalitarian states
an Ethic to Live by
Maximizing the good in a just way
two basic principles of obligation:
The resulting ethic would be something like this: We ought always to maximize good in a just way.
- principle of maximizing good
2. principle of justice
___means, Good will, charitableness, kindliness.
Benevolence
to be benevolent, is to think well of people and to attempt to act well toward them
____involves doing good deeds, acting charitably and behaving in a kindly manner.
Beneficence..its is active and not intentional.
Principle 1 of Beneficence
Obligation to do good and to prevent harm
implications of the Principle of Beneficence
- not to inflict evil or harm
- prevent evil or harm
- remove evil
- to do or promote good
axiom from physician’s code of ethics
Hippocratic Oath
principle 2- Distributive Justice
We ought to make the same relative contribution to the goodness of the lives of others
A central tenet of ___ ___ suggest that justice involves dealing with people according to their merits. Those who are more worthy receive more.
Western liberalism