Pleadings Flashcards
Complaint
- Starts action
- states basis for courts jurisdiction
- basis for Plaintiff’s claim AND
- demand for relief
Complaint Requirements
- Statement of SMJ
- Short & Plain Statement of Claim showing entitlement for relief, and
- Historically - Prim. Function = Notice, Req. short & plain statement that gives notice & allows reasonable response
- Modern - ∏ must plead facts supporting a plausible claim
- Demand for relief sought
Service of Complaint
Plaintiff must serve summons & complaint within 90 days
Complaint - Special Matters
Must be pleaded with particularity if going to be raised at trial
- Fraud
- Mistake
- Special Damages - Damages that don’t normally flow from the event
- Conditions Precedent - Plaintiff must state generally that she complied w/ all cond. precedent
- Shifts burden to ▵ to identify conditions precedent that ∏ didn’t perform
Answer
Response to Plaintiff’s complaint
Answer - Requirements
- Respond to allegations of Complaint - ▵ states in short & plain terms defenses to each claim and:
- Admit
- Deny - Failure to deny is an admission (But not on damages)
- State lack of sufficient information to admit or deny - Not avail. if lacking info is in control of ▵ or is public knowledge
- Raise Affirmative Defenses - Must plead in answer of defense is waived
- Joinder of Claims
- Counterclaim - Against opposing party
- Impleader - ▵may implead 3d P they believe is liable to her for all of Plaintiff’s claims against ▵
Answer - Timing
Within 21 days of service of process OR within 14 days of denial of Rule 12 Motion
- Exception - Waiver of formal service of process ➞ 60 days
Motion (Rule 12)
Request for a court order (granted or denied)
- 12(e) Motion for more Definite Statement
- 12(f) Motion to Strike
- 2(b) - Motion to Dismiss
12(e) Motion for more Definite Statement
- If complaint is ambiguous, can only be made pre- answer
when is a 12(f) Motion to Strike appropriate
- Plaintiff included redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous material
2(b) Motion to Dismiss
Can be raised by motion or in the answer
- Lack of SMJ - Never waived can be raised anytime ➞ can be raised 1st time on appeal
- Lack of PJ - Can Waive, Must include in 1st response
- Improper Venue - Can Waive, Must include in 1st response
- Insufficiency of Process - Can Waive, Problem w/ summons itself, must include in 1st resp.
- Insufficiency of Service of Process - Can Waive, Prob. w/ manner of process, 1st response
- Failure to State a Claim - Can Raise anytime during trial
- Failure to join indispensable Party - can raise anytime during trial
Amended Pleadings - When?
Allowed one as matter of course b/f response or by leave of court (when justice so requires)
- Right to Amend as Matter of Course - Only Once within 21 days of serving the pleading
- Responsive pleading required - 21 days after service of responsive pleading or pre-answer motion
- After 21 Days ➞ Leave of court required
- At Trial - Amend. will aid the Merits, If no right to amend, it may be granted by express consent, implied consent, or by seeking leave of court
- Express Consent - Written consent of adverse party
- Implied Consent - If issue is brought up at trial & no objection
- Over Objection at Trial - Ct. has discretion to grant leave to amens so long as no display of delay or prejudice & Party is given notice & has ability to litigate
Amended Pleadings - Relation Back
Adding New Claim
(Avoids SOL problems) Amendment takes place after SOL has run, treats amended pleading as though it was filed with the original pleading
-
Adding New Claim - If claim arose out of conduct, transaction, occurrence set forth in original pleading, amendment relates back to date of the original pleading
*
Amended Pleading - Relation Back
Changing Defendant
Changing ▵ - Amended Party relates back if:
- Concerns the conduct, transaction or occurrence as original complaint
- New Party knew of the suit within 120 days of original claim, AND
- New party knew that but for the mistake, the new party would have been named originally
Rule 11
Pleadings (Not discovery documents) Must be signed by attorney or unrepresented party