Discovery Flashcards
Scope of Discovery - Standard
Anything relevant to claim or defense in the pleading & must be proportional to needs of the case
- Privileged Material not dicoverable
Discovery - Relevance
Party can discover inadmissible evidence if relevant and proportional to needs of case
Relevant - it is likely to make any fact in dispute more or less likely to be true, regardless of whither it is admissible
Scope of Dicovery - Proportional
Proportional to needs of Case
- Party can’t refuse discovery by making boilerplate objection that its not proportional
Scope of DIcovery - Work Product
Material prepared in anticipation of litigation
- Absolute protection from discovery by opposing counsel (Work Product Doctrine)
- Mental Impressions
- Opinions
- Conclusions
- Legal Theories
- Witness Statements May be Discovered if there is substantial need & info isn’t otherwise avail.
Scope of DIscovery - Objections
Objections must be Stated with Specificity
- the grounds for objection & whether any responsive materials are being withheld
Required Discovery
Must be produced even if opposing P doesn’t explicitly request the info
Required Discovery - Initial Disclosure
Initial Disclosures - Within 14 days of rule 26(f) conference
- List of relevant witnesses - name and address (if known) and #
- Documents supporting claims or defenses - copies or electronically stored information
- Computation of Damages
- Relevant Insurance Policy
- any insurance agreement where insurance business may be liable to:
- satisfy all or part of possible judgment in the action or
- to indemnification or reimbursement for payments made to satisfy the judgment
- any insurance agreement where insurance business may be liable to:
Required Discovery - Pretrial
Must give detailed info about trial evidence no later than 30 days b/f trial including:
- documents and
- ID of witnesses to testify
When are discovery tools available?
Only after Rule 26(f) Conference
Depositions
Witnesses out of court testimony that is reduced to writing for later use in court or for discovery purposes.
- Deponent gives sworn oral answers to questions by counsel
How many depositions is each party entitled to ?
10 but the court may grant more
Deposition - Non party
Not required to attend without subpoena
Depositions - Party
No subpoena required
- Notice of deposition properly served on a Party is sufficient to compel his appearance at the deposition
Deposition - Limitations
- Time Limit
- Can’t exceed 1 day of 7 hours
- BUT ct. must allow additional time if needed to fairly examine deponent, another person, or any other circ.
- No duplicate depositions - can’t depose same pers. twice
- Max 100 Miles from residence or place of business for nonparty
Depositions - Experts
Trial expert - may be deposed (expert whose opinion may be presented at trial)
Consulting expert - can NOT be deposed (expert retained in anticipation of lit. but wont testify at trial (Unless exceptional need)