Persuasion CH Flashcards
Heuristic Message Processing
shortcuts to make decisions and process info
7 Heuristics Messages
- Fixed-action Patterns
- Trigger Feature
- Mimics
- Click, whirr
- Judgment heuristics
- Contrast principle
- Controlled responding
Fixed-action Patterns
-involve intricate sequences of behavior that occur in virtually the same fashion and in the same order every time (Ex: Chicks cheep, mother nurtures)
Trigger Feature
often just one tiny aspect of the total stimulus which sets off a predictable response (Ex: Cheeping sound from chick)
Mimics
copy the trigger feature of the animals in an attempt to trick these animals into mistakenly playing the right behavior tapes at the wrong time (Ex: Grouper Fish and Saber Tooth Fish
click, whirr
humans tend to respond in the same way animals do; that is, with the predictable response to a specific stimulus
judgment heuristics
shortcuts that allow for simplified thinking works well most of the time but leaves us open to occasional, costly mistakes
contrast principle
if the 2nd item is fairly different from the first, we tend to see it as more different than it actually is
controlled responding
reacting on the basis of thorough analysis of all information (making a decision after having all the info)
4 Reasons for studying persuasion
- becoming an effective persuader is helpful
- persuasion as a field of study fulfills a knowledge function
- by understanding the process of persuasion, you will be better equipped to deal with persuasive situations
- you will come to understand what persuasion really is, not what it is perceived to be.
Pure Persuasion
includes clear-cut cases of persuasion on which people would agree
Borderline Persuasion
incorporates cases of persuasion that lie at the periphery of what is normally considered social influence
5 Persuasion Criteria
- intentionality
- effects
- degree of free will
- symbolic action
- interpersonal vs. intrapersonal communication
intentionality
focuses on the source’s intention for communicating
pure: source-based where intent on the part of the source is necessary
borderline: suggest persuasion can occur absent of intent. People don’t know what they intend. Situation may include individuals the source never intended to receive the message. difficult to ascertain one’s intent.
effects
focuses on the outcome of the communication
pure: receiver-based orientation where a successful outcome is necessary (implies a linear view of persuasion)
borderline: suggests persuasion occurs even if the attempt is unsuccessful or only somewhat successful.
- tend to view persuasion as a process rather than a product
- difficult to measure persuasive outcome
degree of free will
focuses on the extent to which an individual feels coerced or pressured to conform
pure: receiver-based orientation where individual feels free to determine how to act
borderline: considers some degree of coercion acceptable
- what one considers coercive, another may not
symbolic action
focuses on the type of communication that can be construed as persuasion
pure: symbolic expression, including language and other meaning-laden acts (non-verbal)
borderline: incorporates a variety of cues as means of persuasion such as aromas, involuntary actions, and physical attributes (Ex: auntie anne’s pretzel smell/george winking due to grapefruit in the eye from Seinfeld/tall=leader)
interpersonal vs. intrapersonal communication
focuses on the # of individuals involved in persuasion
pure: suggests two or more people are necessary for persuasion to occur (interpersonal)
borderline: incorporates self-persuasion as a possibility (interpersonal)
4 Persuasive Responses
- Response-changing process
- Response-shaping process
- Response-reinforcing process
- Response-extinguishing process
response-changing process
changing one’s attitudes, beliefs, or behavior
response-shaping process
creating new attitudes, beliefs, or behaviors not yet held
response-reinforcing process
strengthening attitudes, beliefs, or behaviors already held
response-extinguishing process
eliminating attitudes, beliefs, or behaviors already held
Persuasion (definition)
- involves 1 or more persons who are engaged in the activity of creating, reinforcing, modifying, or extinguishing beliefs, attitudes, intentions, motivations and/or behaviors w/in the constraints of a given communication context
- the potential for persuasion exists in most human communication, but not in all human behavior (e.g. breathing, sleeping, etc)
Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM)
-suggests there are 2 routes to persuasion; a central route and a peripheral route
Persuasion through a central route
Requires motivation, comprehension, and careful thought (processing) about the content of the message.
Tends to be longer lasting and more resistant to change
Persuasion through the peripheral route
occurs through cues rather than through careful consideration of the message
short term and highly subject to change
Attitude
a learned predisposition to respond favorably or unfavorably toward some attitude object
4 attitude characteristics
- attitudes are learned
- attitudes direct behavior (to a large extent)
- attitudes have an evaluative component
- attitudes are directed towards things
Attitude measurement
- attitudes are difficult to measure bc they are in people’s heads and therefore cannot be directly observed
- attitudes are often measured through self-reports
- scales are often used to measure attitudes
Likert scales
- consist of declarative statements followed by a continuum of choices ranging from “strongly agree” to “strongly disagree”
- numbers are associated with each response category are then averaged to estimate one’s attitude
Semantic Differential scales
- consists of bipolar adjectives separated by a number of spaces
- numbers associated with each space are then averaged to estimate one’s attitude
Visually oriented scales
- consist of some type of visual representation to approximate attitude such as faces and thermometers
- useful for respondents who are less well educated or otherwise unfamiliar
Measurement difficulties
- social desirability
- non-attitudes
- acquiescence bias
- mindfulness
social desirability
respond in a politically correct manner
non-attitudes
make up attitude
acquiescence bias
agreement tendency
mindfulness
must be aware of attitudes
Theory of reasoned action
attitude toward, and subjective norms associated with the behavior predict one’s intent to engage in the behavior; one’s intent is a good predictor of actual behavior
Psychological consistency
individuals motivated to maintain consistency both internally and externally.
6 steps to resolving inconsistency
- denial
- bolstering
- differentiation
- transcendence
- modifying
- communicating
denial
deny or ignore inconsistency
bolstering
rationalizing or making excuses
differentiation
separating or distinguishing inconsistent attitudes
transcendence
focus on larger or higher level issue
modifying
altering one or both attitudes
communicating
convincing others that this inconsistency is ok
balance theory
- individuals try to maintain a balanced state between 3 or more entities in a relationship
- can also be used to explain use of celebrities
4 ways to create commitment
- brand loyalty
- cognitive dissonance
- selective exposure
- counter-attitudinal advocacy
Brand Loyalty
refers to methods used to maintain consistent behavior among consumers (e.g. essays, coupons, frequent user programs)
-these tactics work well bc they get consumers to actively commit and consistent behavior follow
cognitive dissonance
- after making a decision, consumers worry about whether the choice made was the right one, and thus experience dissonance (linked to buyer’s remorse)
- the amount or magnitude of dissonance one experiences is positively related to the amount of freedom one had in making the choice
- since dissonance is uncomfortable, we try to reduce it
Selective Exposure
- refers to the process where we seek confirming info. and avoid disconfirming info
- studies suggest that while individuals do seek confirming information, they do not necessarily avoid disconfirming info.
Counter-attitudinal advocacy
- process of having an individual create a message advocating a position that goes against existing attitudes
- some attitude shift will occur as the individual reconciles inconsistency