Personal Injury, Workers Comp, ADA, Child Custody And Neglect Flashcards
Christie Bros v Turnage
1928
You can recover damages from mental suffering, humiliation, or embarrassment (considered personal injury)
ANY unlawful touching of a person’s body
Dillon v Legg
1968
Suffering emotional injury only (with no physical injury) can permit suing for negligence
Legg hit a child of Dillon, Dillon sued for emotional damages
Initial case was thrown out because Dillon herself was not in the “zone of danger,” however the CA SC reversed noting you don’t need to be within a “zone”
Closed enough to the scene, shock was a direct result of observing the accident, closely related to the direct victim
Tort
The event or events that give rise to a lawsuit
A “civil wrong” - requires a breach of duty
Three types of relief sought in civil lawsuits
Monetary damages for harm suffered
Injunction (prevents the defendant from doing something)
Specific performance (getting the defendant to do something they were supposed to do)
Cause of action
The elements for one of the various torts that are necessary for the legal theory of the lawsuit
Must prima facie (on its face) demonstrate wrongdoing
- One must prove liability to receive damages
Canterbury v Spence
1972
Plaintiff is responsible for all harm caused conduct, no matter how disproportionate it may seem
“Take the victim as he finds him”
Types of torts
Intentional torts - volitional act, tortfeasors goal was to cause harm, conduct caused the injury
Defamation - false utterance, must be about the plaintiff, transmitted to a third person, results in damage to plaintiffs reputation
Privacy torts
Strict liability - liability without fault
Negligence - no intention but a failure to act
Vicarious liability
Requirements for intentional torts
Defendant engaged in a volitional act
Intent - tortfeasors goal was to cause harm
Cause - conduct caused the injury
Elements of a defamation tort
(Libel is written defamation, slander is spoken defamation)
False, defamatory utterance
About the plaintiff
Transmitted in some form to a third person
Resulting in damage to the plaintiff’s reputation
Types of privacy torts
Appropriation - unauthorized use of image for commercial advantage
Intrusion - intrusion into plaintiffs private life
False light - misattribution of the plaintiffs values
Public disclosure of private facts
Strict liability
Liability without any kind of fault
Defendant engaged in an act so inherently dangerous that they do so at their own risk and accept any damages that result
Negligence
Duty
Breach
Damage
Nominal damages
Plaintiff proved liability but has suffered no harm
Receives a small amount of money
Compensatory damages
Most common type of damages sought
An amount to pay the plaintiff for actual losses suffered as a result of the injury (and nothing more) - could look like covering medical or mental health expenses, lost earnings, etc.
Loss of consortium
The loss of benefits of the relationship that one person is entitled to receive another (companionship, cooperation, sexual relations)
Punitive damages
Intended to punish the defendant for their blameworthy conduct, or to set an example to deter future behavior
The evaluation model for personal injury cases
Determine the presence of sxs in four areas:
Cognitive, affective, physiological, and interpersonal
And how they impact functioning in four ways:
ADLs, relationships, workplace, and hedonics (quality of life)
Five distinct time intervals for evaluating personal injury
Time before the tort occurred
Time during which the tort occurred
Time since the tort up until the evaluation
The evaluation
Projecting into the future
Legal test for workers compensation
Whether there is a connection between work activities and the injury
Burden of proof for workers comp cases
Preponderance
Three major types of workers comp
Total disability - paid out over lifetime or large number of weeks
Permanent partial disability - percentage of total impairment
Temporary total/partial disability - paid weekly for the duration of the disability
What a beneficiary must demonstrate for workers compensation
Injury or disability
Arose out of employment (during normal work hours doing normal duties)
Is accidental/unanticipated
Three kinds of emotional damages cases
Workers compensation
Physical trauma causing mental injury
Mental stimulus causing physical injury (protracted stress leading to heart issue)
Mental stimulus causing mental injury (seen as less legitimate)
Commonality between tort law and workers compensation
Both require proximate cause
Aka. Recent cause, straw that broke the camels back
Most important kind of testing to workers compensation cases
Response bias and impression management
Impact of diagnosis on workers compensation cases
Compensation does not hinge on diagnosis alone, you can have no formal diagnosis (ex. Experience headaches, irritability) and still be entitled to compensation
How to establish proximate cause
Have some knowledge of the alleged event (accident)
Know what research suggests may be common sequelae
The fact finder ultimately decides if there is proximate cause
Prognosis in tort and workers compensation cases
Tort prognosis - related to the damage award the plaintiff will receive
WC prognosis - used to determine the likely duration of the impairment caused by the injury
How disability is defined in tort and workers compensation cases
Tort - disability is defined by case law
(Can win a LOT of money…wild wild west)
Workers compensation - disability is defined by statute in your jurisdiction
(Pay out amounts are fixed)
Four main ways to obtain benefits when your ability to work is compromised
Private disability insurance - privately purchased, commonly seen in self-employed arena
Employer-paid disability insurance - provided as part of employer-provided health benefits
Workers Compensation - illness or injury MUST be related to the work
Social security disability - eligibility is contingent on work history and contributions to the social security system
Leading causes of disability in the US
For those between ages 15-44
Depression
Four domains of consideration for sx exaggeration in disability claims
Motivation and incentives
Atypical, exaggerated, incongruent symptoms
Discrepancies in interviewer presentation/noncompliance
Activity outside the interview (noncompliance with tx)
Doctor-patient duty case law
Ryans v Lowell - no malpractice if no relationship
Ervin v American Guardian Life Insurance Co - no relationship if a doctor conducts a file review for an insurance company
Case law for disability as it pertains to loss of job
Damascus v Provident Life and Accident Insurance Co - if negligence is the reason for your loss of license, companies can refuse to pay out
Massachusetts Mutual v Ouellette - inability to work because of a criminal conviction isn’t compensable
Meritor Savings Bank v Vinson
1986
Hostile work environment sexual harassment is a form of sex discrimination that is actionable under Title 7 of the Civil Rights Act
Olmstead v L.C. ex rel Zimring
1999
Financial constraints cannot entirely determine whether states comply with the 1990 ADA guidelines concerning placement in community treatment for the mentally disabled