Performance Appraisal Flashcards
Performance Appraisal
Ongoing, systematic evaluation of how well an individual is carrying out their responsibilities
Typically includes assessment of individual’s need for future development
Key Points of Strong Performance Appraisal System
Ongoing
Systematic
Evaluation
Development
Ongoing
Often annually
Systematic
Logical assessment, closely tied to attributes of the job
DO JOB ANALYSIS
Evaluation
Judgement of goodness or badness
Must have comparability so that personnel decisions can be accurately made
Development
Areas for improvement in present job
Potential for future jobs
Guidelines for Performance Appraisal
Use objective performance measures with clear standards
Provide raters with written instructions and training
Better when raters are diverse
Have review of the ratings
4 Types of Performance Appraisal
Written Essays
Rating Systems
Ranking Systems
Appraisal by Objectives and Standards (MBO)
Narrative Essays
Rater, usually manager, writes essay for each employee
Modern versions include keeping a diary for each employee
Advantages of Essays
Detailed and rich
Tailored to individual employee
When used in diary form, seen as especially fair
Disadvantages of Essays
Time consuming
Writers often focus on extreme examples
Unstandardized, making comparison difficult
Quality depends on author’s writing ability
Common Rating Scales
Graphic Rating Scales (GRS)
Checklists and Forced Choice
Behaviorally-Based (BARS & BOS)
Graphic Rating Scales (GRS)
List of attributes associated with the job
Rater provides numerical rating from high to low
Forms often include comment section
Common GRS Dimensions
Productivity Quality of Work Dependability Adherence to Values Contribution to the Effectiveness of Others
Advantages of GRS
Easy to Use
Quick & Efficient
Standardized factors can cover many jobs
Numerical ratings allow for calculations and comparisons
Disadvantages of GRS
Vague definitions of factors Subjective interpretations No objective/factual basis for definition Often not closely related to job Prone to various rating errors Courts are often skeptical
Checklists
Obtain behavioral incidents
Rater indicates whether or not they occured
2 Types of Checklists
Conventional Checklist (Sometimes weighted) Forced Choice (Always weighted)