Partnerships Flashcards
Elements of a partnership
- An association of two or more persons (inc. legal entities) for for-profit purposes.
PERSONS must have capacity to contract.
INTENT must be to carry on a business for profit as co-owners (doesn’t need to be intent to create a partnership)
AGREEMENT may be implied.
PASSIVE CO-OWNERSHIP of property by itself does not create a partnership. Courts will consider the amount of related activities directed toward achieving a business’s end goal when determining whether a partnership exists
S/F
Partnerships may be formed w/o a written agreement, but the agreement itself is subject to the statute of frauds.
KEY TEST
Look for sharing of profits - PRESUMPTION that it’s a partnership if profits are shared.
BUT PRESUMPTION NOT CREATED IF:
i) Debt payments, including installment payments;
ii) Interest or other loan charges, even though the payment varies with the profits of the business;
iii) Rent;
iv) Wages or other compensation paid to an employee or independent contractor;
v) Goodwill payments stemming from the sale of a business, including installment payments; and
vi) Annuities or other retirement or health benefits paid to a beneficiary, representative, or designee of a deceased or retired partner.
Joint ventures
A joint venture is not a clearly defined legal entity. Frequently, courts use the term “joint venture” to describe a partnership for a specific, limited purpose. Courts usually apply partnership rules to a joint venture when the association has a business purpose rather than a personal purpose.
Subpartnership
A subpartnership, which is not a true partnership, refers to an agreement between a partner and a third party that the third party will share in the partner’s profits from the partnership. The third party does not become a member of the partnership and has only a contractual claim against that partner for a share of the partnership’s profits.
Partner by Estoppel
Generally, if a partnership does not exist, a person cannot be liable to a third party as a partner. RUPA 308(e). However, even though a partnership does not exist, a person may, under circumstances enumerated below, be treated as a partner of a purported partnership. Similarly, there are situations when someone who is not a partner of an established partnership may still be treated as one. In either case, the person is characterized as a purported partner (or a partner by estoppel).
For liability as a purported partner to be imposed, the following elements must be established:
i) There must be a representation—orally, in writing, or implied by conduct—that a person is a partner in an actual or purported partnership;
ii) The purported partner must make or consent to the representation;
iii) A third party must have reasonably relied on the representation; and
iv) The third party must have suffered damages as a result of that reliance.
Partnership Agreement
Although a formal agreement is not required to create a partnership, if the partners have entered into such an agreement, then the agreement, rather than RUPA, generally governs the relations among the partners and between the partners and the partnership when there is a conflict between the agreement and RUPA.
Duty of Loyalty
a. Duty of loyalty
Under the duty of loyalty, a partner is required to refrain from the following activities:
i) Competing with the partnership business;
ii) Advancing an interest adverse to the partnership; and
iii) Usurping a partnership opportunity or otherwise using partnership property or business to derive a personal benefit, without notifying the partnership.
Limitation of Duty of Loyalty
A partnership agreement may not eliminate the duty of loyalty. However, the agreement may identify specific types or categories of activities that do not violate this duty, if not manifestly unreasonable. For example, a real estate partnership agreement could permit a partner to retain commissions on partnership property bought and sold.
Loyalty Safe Harbor
In addition, the agreement may provide a safe harbor with respect to a transaction between a partner and the partnership. Under a safe harbor, a certain number or percentage of the other partners—after full disclosure of the material facts—could authorize or ratify the transaction.
Duty of Care
Duty to refrain from engaging in grossly negligent, reckless, knowing, or intentional misconduct, and knowing violation of the law.
May not unreasonably limit this duty.
Timing of fiduciary duties
PROSPECTIVE partners not subject to FDs but may be subject to general K duties to deal honestly without fraud.
DISSOCIATED partners not subject to duties unless winding up (but if winding up, noncompete duty does not apply)
Obligation of good faith and fair dealing.
In observing the duties of loyalty and care and in exercising any rights, a partner has the obligation of good faith and fair dealing. RUPA 404(d). The partnership agreement cannot eliminate this obligation, but it can prescribe reasonable standards by which the performance of the obligation is measured.
Rules for Profits and Losses
If agreement speaks to share of each, CONTROLS.
If silent as to PROFITS, presumption is that each partner is entitled to equal share.
If silent as to LOSSES, the losses follow the profits.
Transfer of Partnership Interest
- May freely transfer some or all of interest, unless forbidden by the partnership agreement (and transfer is ineffective as to a transferee who has notice of the restriction)
- Does NOT result in dissolution.
- EFFECT ON TRANSFEROR: The transfer of a partner’s partnership interest to a third party does not trigger the partner’s dissociation from the partnership. Instead, the transferor partner retains all rights and duties of a partner in the partnership apart from an interest in the distributions transferred.
- EFFECT ON TRANSFEREE: The transferee has the right to receive distributions from the partnership to which the transferor partner would otherwise have been entitled, including both distributions made by the partnership as an ongoing concern and those made upon dissolution of the partnership and the winding up of its business. In addition, the transferee may seek a judicial order for dissolution of the partnership. In the event of dissolution, the transferee is entitled to an accounting, but only for the period beginning from the date of the last accounting agreed to by all of the partners.
Partnership Property
All property acquired by a partnership, whether by contribution from a partner or by purchase or other transfer from a partner or a third party, is partnership property and belongs to the partnership, not to the individual partners. RUPA 101(11), 203. A partner cannot transfer an ownership interest in partnership property, voluntarily or involuntarily.
When property is not regarded as partnership property, the intent of the partners controls in determining whether the property belongs to the partnership or to the individual partners. Two statutory presumptions are applicable in ascertaining that intent.
1) Presumed partnership property—purchased with partnership funds
Property is presumed to be partnership property if it was purchased with partnership assets or if partnership credit is used to obtain financing. RUPA204(c).
2) Presumed partner’s separate property
By contrast, property is rebuttably presumed to be a partner’s separate property when (i) the property is acquired in the name of one or more partners, (ii) the instrument transferring title to the property does not indicate the person’s capacity as a partner or the existence of a partnership, and (iii) partnership assets were not used to acquire the property. The use of property for partnership purposes is not enough to overcome this presumption. RUPA 204(d).
Adding a new partner
To become a partner, a person must secure the consent of all of the existing partners.
Ordinary Partnership Business
A majority of the partners can make a decision as to a matter in the ordinary course of the partnership’s business, such as a distribution of partnership profits. Acting individually, a partner has the actual authority to commit the partnership to usual and customary matters, unless the partner has reason to know that: (i) other partners might disagree; or (ii) for some other reason consultation with fellow partners is appropriate.
Special Partnership Business
A decision as to a matter outside the ordinary course of the partnership’s business requires the consent of all partners. An amendment of the partnership agreement also requires the consent of all partners. Acting individually, a partner has no actual authority to take unusual or non-customary actions that will have a substantial effect on the partnership.
Remuneration and Reimbursement
A partner is not entitled to remuneration for services performed for the partnership. An exception exists when the partner renders services in winding up the business of the partnership, in which case the partner is entitled to reasonable compensation.
A partner may make a loan in furtherance of the ordinary business of the partnership or to preserve the partnership’s business or property. The partnership is required to repay the loan or reimburse the partner for the advances, including interest from the date of the loan or advance.
Use of Partnership Property & Obligation to Compensate
A partner may use or possess partnership property only on behalf of the partnership. RUPA 401(g). A partner who derives a personal benefit from the use or possession of partnership property is required to compensate the partnership for such benefit.
Access to Records
Pship must provide this during business hours; cannot be limited unreasonably.
In addition, each partner and the partnership must furnish to a partner (or the partner’s legal representative), without demand, any information concerning the partnership’s business and affairs reasonably required for the proper exercise of the partner’s rights and duties under the partnership agreement or RUPA and, on demand, any other information concerning the partnership’s business and affairs unless the demand or the information demanded is unreasonable or improper.
Events Causing Dissociation
i) The partner’s notice to the partnership of the partner’s express will to withdraw;
ii) An occurrence specified in the partnership agreement;
iii) The expulsion of the partner pursuant to the partnership agreement;
iv) The expulsion of the partner by the unanimous vote of the other partners, if it is unlawful to carry on the partnership business with that partner;
v) The expulsion of the partner by court order because the partner has either (i) engaged in misconduct that adversely and materially affected the partnership business, (ii) willfully and persistently caused a material breach of the partnership agreement, or (iii) breached a duty owed to the partnership or other partners;
vi) The partner’s voluntary or involuntary bankruptcy, a general assignment of the partner’s interest for the benefit of the partner’s creditors, or appointment of a trustee, receiver, or liquidator of the partner’s property;
vii) The partner’s death;
viii) The appointment of a guardian or general conservator for the partner, or a specific judicial determination that the partner has become incapable of performing his duties under the partnership agreement; or
ix) The termination of an entity partner (such as a limited liability company), or the distribution by an estate or a trust of the partnership interest.