observations Flashcards
non participant observation
researcher simply observes the group or event without taking part in it
participant observation
researcher engages in the groups activities being observed, or takes on a role within the research group
overt observations
researcher makes their true identity known to those being studied
covert observation
research takes place without the observed group knowing the true identity of the sociologist/researcher
semi-overt research
researcher may reveal their identity to someone in a group but not all
3 advantages of overt observations
makes it easier to gain access to groups the researcher doesn’t have the usual qualifications for entry (e.g. age or gender)
more objective and ethical than covert
participants are aware they’re being researched so can write and record observations more easily
3 disadvantages of overt observations
hawthorne effect of the participants knowing researcher is present
time consuming- longitudinal study
requires training an observational skills
give 3 strengths of non-participant observations
it can be conducted systematically using observation charts (practical strength) so the data can be used to establish patterns and correlations (theoretical strength)
less time consuming than participant observation because the researcher doesn’t have to enter group under study (practical strength)
less intrusive than participant and smaller risk of observer bias (ethical strength)
give 3 weaknesses of non-participant observations
explanations of behaviour are limited because there’s no researcher involvement and they not fit into one category and instead overlap within several categories (theoretical weakness)
researcher presence (even if covert) means the researchers presence may affect behaviour of group being studied (ethical weakness)
data lacks validity because observation doesn’t tell us about meaning (theoretical weakness)
give the 5 steps of how to conduct a participant observation
1) getting in- some groups are easier to get into than others
2) making contact- need personal skills, have the right connections or by chances.
3) being accepted- need to make friends
4) staying in- need to be fully involved but also attached and going native
5) getting out- can be easy, problems in reentering the real world, problems of harming participants
covert observation
the researcher’s true identity is kept secret from those being studied and in some studies the researcher may put on a fake identity or pose as a member of the group during their observation,
give 2 reasons for choosing to use covert observation in research
for their own personal safety: especially in crime or gangs you may hide own identity to protect yourself when publishing research. Your participants may not want to be studied and respond violently to your request for research.
another reason is for interpretivists it will give more valid results. If your sample is unaware they’re being researched then their behaviour is more likely to be truthful. If they knew they were being observed the hawthorne effect may be experienced.
give 3 strengths of using covert observations
more valid data- reduced chance of hawthorne effect and can see natural human interactions in their natural environment so findings are more likely to explain real life (interactionalists desire this in research)
first hand research: get a more detailed picture as things aren’t lost in translation
experiencing a group as one of their own means you’re likely to experience verstehen
give 3 weaknesses of using covert observations
lack of validity and low in reliability: positvists dislike this method because of these and due to it not being scientific
time consuming: longitudinal and can’t write down findings so relies on memory for accurate findings (may take longer to accumulate findings)
ethical issues: danger of becoming too involved with group and going native (comprimises objectivity) and decieving participants (no way of gaining consent or research will be comprimised)
observation schedule
using a chart to systematically observe and record data.
used in structured observation- produces quantitative data from which patterns and correlations can be established