NJAMBI - DUALISMS AND FEMALE BODIES IN REPRESENTATIONS OF AFRICAN FEMALE CIRCUMCISION (2004) Flashcards
Many of those seeking the eradication of ‘FGM’ condemn them as…(3)
‘barbaric’
harmful to female bodies and sexuality
evidence of the universal oppression of women by men and male dominated social structures
‘Female circumcision’ tends not to be used as it…
fails to capture the horror of the mutilation involved
The centre maintained in anti-FGM discourse is subject to contradictory meanings, images and practices that carry legacies of colonial representations of ‘third world’ societies as…
‘savage’ and ‘barbaric’
whilst claiming to be pursuing their collective well-bein
KRATZ 1994 - The practices of female circumcision now enter a new discourse of not only ‘women’s health and well-being’ (articulated within the rhetoric of western feminism), but also that of the ‘universal’..(2)
‘oppression of women’
‘male domination of women’
Sensational stories told about the processes of African female circumcision, such as razor blades and the teeth of the midwife use, while not a single group is identified which employs such..
crude instruments
History of colonialism and neo-colonialism has afforded the more powerful west the right to…
intervene in the lives of its ‘third world’ Others
GOULD’S 1993 ‘hardline’ and ‘softline’
‘Hardliners’ are those who boldly state what they perceive as pure primitivity and barbarity of female circumcision, and are known for sensationalising stories designed to…
shock and horrify in order to push the audience into action
GOULD’S 1993 ‘hardline’ and ‘softline’
Example of a hardliner - Hosken (1993), who coined ‘FGM’ - “it is men who determine what becomes a custom and finally a tradition in each society. The objective, which is quite openly stated by African and Middle Eastern men, is to…
deprive women’s sexual pleasure and to keep women under male control…”
According to Hosken 1993 - “all the operations are performed without anaesthetic, often on struggling children held by force, frequently on the ground under highly septic conditions, using a…
variety of tools”
GOULD’S 1993 ‘hardline’ and ‘softline’
‘Softliners’ are identified through their often sympathetic position that attempts to contextualise these practices in their…
cultural settings
GOULD’S 1993 ‘hardline’ and ‘softline’
‘Softliners’ still presume that change requires an external catalyst from among the more culturally and economically developed, ‘modern’ society. While, they view that culture must be respected, intervention is needed to establish more…
‘appropriate/acceptable’ ways of living”
Walley 1997:421
According to Kasinga (well-known case) “most young women in Togo are happy to have the procedure done and think it is something…
very great”
Walley 1997 notes that the media was fixated on what it saw as an example of coercion and oppression in
African cultures and societies generally
One problem with anti-FGM discourse is its refusal to recognise differences - ignoring the diversity of..
female circumcision’s forms and histories
Njambi saw female circumcision as a ritual that marks the passage to womanhood, to demonstrate how ‘normality’ regarding bodies is…
culturally produced