Negotiable Instruments Flashcards
Note
Promise to pay-2 parties
Maker and payee
Draft
Order to Pay (check) - 3 parties You are commanding that a bank pay on your behalf Drawer - signs Drawee - bank Payee- person entitled to money
Requirements for Negotiability
She Won Unlimited Free Dunkin’ Donuts Or Bagels
(S)igned by maker or drawer; (W)riting; (U)nconditional promise or order to pay; (F)ixed amount of money; Payable on (D)emand or at a (D)efinite time; Payable to (O)rder or (B)earer.
and states no authorized undertaking or instruction by person promising or ordering payment
If it is conditional, then it is non-negotiable. What does conditional mean?
Expressly states a condition for payment
OR
is subject to or governed by another writing.
Its ok if it references another writing for terms (e.g. prepayment)
If there is a separate writing, does it affect a HDC
No, only applies to parties to the writing.
What does it mean that an amount of money is fixed?
To be negotiable, the principal due under the instrument must be fixed. Variable or indexed interest rates are acceptable.
Payable to Order
payable to an identified person
Magic words “Pay to the order of X”
If it just says Pay x, it is not negotiable unless it is a check
Payable to Bearer
Payable to cash or to possessor; does not name a payee.
Do acceleration clauses destroy negotiability?
No
Do extensions destroy negotiability?
No, s/l/a extension is for a definite time.
What happens if there is a conspicuous statement that the instrument is NON NEGOTIABLE
Negotiability is destroyed, except in the case of checks.
What is a holder?
A person in possession of an instrument with a right to enforce it.
How are bearer instruments negotiated?
Transferring possession
How are order instruments negotiated?
Payable to a specific payee - transfer of possession plus indorsement
-forging name breaks chain of title - indorsement must be authorized and valid.
Negotiation of order instrument with multiple payees
-If payable jointly (A and B), by indorsement of all parties
If payable severally - A or B, any one may indorse.
When a bank takes a check for collection, do you need payee’s indorsement?
No. Possession is enough to negotiate - but this is just with banks
Burden of proof on assignment of note vs. negotiation
Assignment - assignee needs to prove why he should be paid.
In negotiation, HDC brings the instrument to court and D has burden of proving why he doesn’t have to pay.
Factors That Do Not Affect Negotiability
Undated Checks. Treated as payable on demand.
Pre or Post-Dated Checks.
Handwritten Terms Outweigh Printed Terms.
Words Outweigh Numbers.
Writing NON-NEGOTIABLE on a Check does not destroy negotiability.
BUT BE CAREFUL! Writing Non-Negotiable on anything else DOES destroy negotiability.
What if the Instrument is Not Negotiable?
It can still be redeemed for cash.
It can still be sold, transferred, assigned, gives as security . . . it’s still “commercial paper.”
But, if an obligation is transferred to a third party (by assignment instead of negotiation), that third party is now subject to all sorts of contract claims and defenses that may make it harder for him to get paid.
Where can indorsement be written?
On back or on an allonge
Types of indorsements
- Special or blank
- Qualified
- Restrictive indorsements
- Anamolous Indorsements
Blank indorsement
- the indorser just signs.
- blank indorsement specifies no particular indorsee.
- If the payee is the indorser, the payee can now redeem the instrument and receive payment. That’s why you sign the back of your checks.
- You can put a blank indorsement on order paper or bearer paper.
NOTE: if you put a blank indorsement on order paper, it converts it to bearer paper.
Special Indorsement
-the indorser signs and names a third party as indorsee
-You can put a special indorsement on order paper or bearer paper.
NOTE: if you put a special indorsement on bearer paper, it converts it to order paper. Now, it can only be negotiated again by indorsement and delivery.
Qualified Indorsement
-similar to a special indorsement, but with limited liability to the indorser:
-Pay to Warren Buffett without recourse
Bill Gates
-This means that the indorser is not guaranteeing payment. The only thing that is happening is a transfer of ownership.
-By contrast, most blank and special indorsements transfer ownership and include a guarantee of payment.
-If the instrument is dishonored by the drawee (bank), a blank or special indorser may be liable to pay instead.
Typically, the words “without recourse” are used.
Restrictive Indorsement
-Any other language added to an indorsement creates a restrictive indorsement. It typically attempts to impose a condition or restriction on how the instrument will be further negotiated.
Example: “Pay to Buffett only”
Example: “Pay to Buffett, but only if he uses the property as a hotel”
Example: “No further negotiation or indorsement permitted”
-Generally, restrictions and conditions included in an indorsement do not affect negotiability. We would treat most of them as ordinary special indorsements.
-This is unlike conditions on the face of the instrument which do destroy negotiability.
Anomalous Indorsement:
-Typically, the holder indorses the instrument for the purpose of negotiating it to another party.
-Or, the payee indorses the instrument for the purpose of presenting it to the drawee/maker for payment.
If someone other than a holder or payee indorses the instrument, it is called an anomalous indorsement.
-The anomalous indorser becomes a surety (guarantor) for the instrument and is now liable for payment. Their liability is secondary.
-Look for an indorser who was never a holder or payee. That is an anomalous indorser, and he’s now on the hook as a “surety.”
Last Indorsement Rule
The last indorsement on an instrument determines whether this is order or bearer paper, regardless of how it started.
If the last indorsement is blank, the instrument is bearer.
If the last indorsement is special or qualified, it is order.
So, if you want to know whether an instrument is order or bearer paper, look at the last indorsement. If there are no indorsements, look at how it started.