MTIII Flashcards
Note the opening point about student misperception (Ch 12)
a. Most college students believe that peers are drinking much more alcohol on average than is actually the case
What was the original speculation about social norms marketing (SNM)?
a. A communication campaign that provides accurate information about student alcohol use would reduce misconceptions of campus drinking norms, diminish normative pressure to drink, and thereby reduce student alcohol consumption. This type of campaign = SNM. These campaigns should result in less drinking behavior after the true norm is publicized widely, providing that the true norm is believable and does not fall into their latitude of rejection.
What were the findings of the Social Norms Marketing Research Project?
a. SNM campaigns made a difference at institutions located in communities with low outlet density but failed to have an effect in communities with high density (an outlet is an on-premise alcohol outlet – bar, restaurant – within 3 miles of campus)
b. The small budget for the 2 studies’ SNM campaigns and limited message dissemination that resulted suggest a more basic explanation for their restricted impact: they failed to achieve the high volume of message repetition that is necessary to attain large audience exposure and promote learning, both crucial determinants of a health campaign’s effectiveness.
What did the case study at University of Virginia show?
a. That a large, well-funded, and highly visible social norms campaign can counteract an entrenched drinking culture and reduce alcohol-related problems.
The Michigan State study:
a. –How did student perceptions change during the SNM intervention?
i. Students misperceptions changed from thinking average drinks consumed was 6.1 (2000) to 5.3 (2010); where the actual consumption rate was 5.4 drinks (2000) t0 4.2 (2010). – New norms still had misconception
Michigan State Study - What was the scope of the campaign?
i. (Not sure if I am right…) Strategies at MSU and other SNM campaigns is to ratchet down levels of alcohol consumption and the attendant misperceptions by providing updated normative information at the beginning of each new campaign cycle
Michigan State Study - What were the milestones of the campaign?
i. In 2005, for the 1st time, majority of MSU students (57%) reported that they drank 0 to 4 drinks (rather than 0 to 5) the last time they partied
ii. The campaign was chosen as a Model Program by the U.S Department of Education (2007) – gained grant funds to improve campaign – like website.
iii. The “Duck Campaign” was born – duck=student ID with it, highly liked and trustworthy
Note the lessons learned from recent research (Chapter 12 -SNM)
a. Especially important for the campaign to have a high level of activity with frequent message repetition. Should be variety of supportive messages and media executions to keep campaigns fresh and avoid many message fatigue
b. Not all students are exposed to the same communication channels. As a result, reaching the broadest cross-section of students requires using multiple venues. Special consideration must be given to commuter students – less involved in campus activities.
c. Students grow up with the idea that college students drink heavily, therefore, expect it and build trust in campaign and data
d. Students will not be moved to change their behavior if they do not identify with the student body as a whole
Conclusion: What are college administrators now experimenting with?
a. With SNM campaigns directed at other student health issues, including sexual violence, tobacco, and other drugs, nutrition, and physical exercise.
What happened with “slow food” in 2008 in San Francisco, according to Schlosser?
a. Became a genuine social movement. Had an exhibition space at Fort Mason to showcase the future of sustainable agriculture.
Who was missing from the event described above, and why are they important? – The “slow food” in 2008 in SF
a. “A group of people who will ultimately determine whether this movement gains importance beyond the Bay Area: the workers, process and serve the food we eat.
What is the Slow Food trinity?
a. “According to the Slow Food trinity, food must be “good, clean, and fair.”
You should be familiar with the arguments of Holden, Shiva, and Pollan in this article . . . though you need not be able to match the names with the specific viewpoints.
a. Holden – warned that the coming shortage of fossil fuels would consign industrial agriculture to the dustbin of history.
i. Ten calories of fossil fuel energy are now required to produce each calorie of food.
b. Shiva – argued that free trade was actually “forced trade,” imposing the needs of multinational agribusiness upon Third World economies.
c. Pollan – explained how the latest US farm bill is really a “food bill,” providing subsidies to the manufacture of unhealthy, processed foods while maintaining high prices for health foods such as fruits and vegetables.
What is missing from the Slow Food Movement?
a. Not sure….but if I had to guess, probably the same answer as 2 – “A group of people who will ultimately determine whether this movement gains importance beyond the Bay Area: the workers, process and serve the food we eat.
i. “Jayaraman spoke about workers who could never hope to afford the meals they prepare and serve, who toil long hours of low wages, who rarely get sick pay or vacations.
Who is Wes Jackson?
a. Wes Jackson and his colleagues at “The Land Institute” are working on a 10,000 year-old problem - - agriculture.
What is the problem on which the Land Institute is focused?
a. Agriculture
What is the fundamental problem cited by Jackson (via Jensen)?
a. Fundamental problem is that no one has come up with a sustainable system for perpetuating agricultural productivity – production remains high while the health of the soil continues to decline dramatically
What is NSA and how would it help our agricultural problem?
a. “Natural Systems Agriculture” investigates ways that monoculture annual grains (such as corn and wheat) can be replaced by polyculture (grown in combinations) perennial grains. NSA attempts to mimic nature instead of subduing it.
b. A Natural ecosystem such as a prairie recycles materials, sponsors its own fertility, runs on contemporary sunlight, and increases biodiversity.
i. The question NSA poses is whether agriculture can be designed to increase ecological wealth in such fashion rather than degrade it
When did the modern environmental movement begin? What marked its beginnings?
a. The modern environmental movement really began in 1962 with Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring. Before that, environmentalism was mostly about wilderness advocacy, with some focus on soil erosion and water conservation.
What does Jackson say about social movements and depth?
a. Social movements and depth need to focus on preaching to the choir to get more depth in the solution.
Note the point about Jackson’s age and how much oil has been used?
Jackson is 67 this month, and in his lifetime people have burned 97.5% of all the oil that has ever been burned.
What does Jackson say about the importance of high-density energy?
a. “I’m saying there simply is no alternative to the density of high-energy carbon coming out of an oil well.”
b. “That’s where the discussion needs to deepen.”
What does he say about Democrats and Republicans?
a. Republicans are “fat cats who made out so well on the tax cuts and say, “OK boys, give us 10 percent.”
b. Democrats would be better in SOME ways, that fewer of our civil liberties would be violated. BUT the democrats are not trying to change our dependence on an extractive economy.
c. The democrats turn the dial a little to the right, and the Republicans turn it to the right, but they’re both on the wrong channel. I don’t see any fine-tuning that is going to make a difference
What does Jackson say about mass intellectual engagement on these issues?
a. It is possible and necessary
How does he compare the environmental movement to the anti-Vietnam war or civil rights movements?
a. “But I think that the environmental movement is, in many ways, more complicated than the anti-Vietnam war or civil rights movement. We have to deal with the aspect of human nature that wants stuff, wants comfort and security. For some time I think we were naïve and thought these problems could be solved easily.”
In what kind of agricultural economics is Jackson interested?
a. “Why should we constantly be looking for technological solutions? I don’t think we have spent enough time looking at the rules of nature’s economy, which are systems that have featured material recycling and run on contemporary sunlight. That’s the kind of alternate economics I’m interested in.”
What is a cocreational approach to PR?
a. It suggests that organizations work to create shared meaning with stakeholders, engage in dialogue, and counsel organizational leaders on how to make ethical, long-term decisions
How are Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) campaigns like health, political, and product ad campaigns?
a. CSR campaigns are similar in that organizations undertake certain socially desirable activities (an institutional perspective) and then communicate that perspective to the media and the world on the belied that the activity will build goodwill (promotional perspective).
CSR is based on what idea?
a. That an organization’s behaviors should contribute to society
The concept of CSR is grounded in what belief?
a. Organizations have an obligation to their employees, community, and consumers based on the concept of stakeholder obligations rather than stockholder obligations
What is the social capital point as discussed at the bottom of p. 262 and the bottom of p. 263?
a. Communication campaigns for CSR create a form of “social capital” that can strengthen a society, and, in the end, improve the environment (logical, economic, community) in which corporations operate.
b. “Social capital” = generally viewed as the norms, cultural values, and trust intrinsic to groups, organizations, or communities. It isn’t much different from monetary capital in that it is a “certain kind of capital that can create advantages for individuals or groups pursuing their own ends.”
Note the basics of the case studies involving Crate & Barrel, Western Union, and BP.
a. Crate & Barrel – partners with nonprofit to build customer loyalty (DonorsChoose)
b. Western Union – addresses criticisms through corporate social responsibility campaign engaging immigrant workers and employees
c. BP – learns how much (or how little) its past corporate social responsibility helps in a crisis
Pollan makes a connection between the new administration and which earlier presidency?
a. Nixon Administration
What does Pollan claim about:
a. -food costs?
i. The era of cheap and abundant food appears to be drawing to a close.
b. -national security?
i. The health of a nation’s food system is a critical issue of national security.
What can we no longer count on in our food system?
a. We can no longer count on cheap energy