Moral judgement, Prosocial Behaviour and Anti-social Behaviour Flashcards
What are the two stages of moral development?
1) Heteronomous morality
2) Autonomous morality
When do children have heteronomous morality?
Children in the preoperational stage (before 7 years old)
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
When children regard the “rules” as fixed, and not seen in the context of the situation
Heteronomous morality
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
When children focus on the action and the consequences, not the intent of the individual(s) involved
Heteronomous morality
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
When children’s morality is often governed by their parents’ expectations of behaviour
Heteronomous morality
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
Children develop the ability to take another person’s perspective, develop the Theory of Mind and demonstrate empathy
Autonomous morality
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
When children are no longer blindly accepting “the rules” as fixed/cannot be changed depending on the situation
Autonomous morality
What type of morality is this? (Heteronomous or Autonomous)?
When children can consider an individual’s intentions when they perform a particular behaviour
(and so judge theft of one cookie to be
more serious than accidentally breaking all of them)
Autonomous morality
What do studies of children across cultures suggest about children’s way of viewing morality?
Children increasingly take motives and intentions into account when judging the morality of actions (Berg & Mussen, 1975; Lickona,1976)
Children’s performances on tests of perspective-taking, Piagetian logical tasks, and IQ have all been associated with their level of moral judgment.
What does this suggest about morality and its correlations with other parts of development?
Moral development is multifactorial (has many factors that contribute to it) and includes a cognitive component
It is said that children who have not yet reached the concrete operational stage (below 7 years old) struggle to judge based on autonomous morality.
But studies have shown otherwise. How is this possible?
By making the individuals’ intentions (in the scenario given) more obvious
e.g. Showing a video of a child stealing a cookie and accidentally breaking the cookie jar instead of giving verbal instructions/scenarios
Preoperational children are more likely to correctly identify which is morally more dubious
At what age do children understand that a person could not cause a negative outcome “on purpose” if the person did not know that outcome was a possible consequence of their action (Pellizzoni, Siegal, & Surian, 2009)?
e.g. Someone knocking down the jar whilst running is most likely an accident rather than intentional
At around 4-5 years old
A 3-year-old who saw an adult intend (but fail) to hurt another adult was (……..) likely to help that perpetrator than they were if that person’s behaviour toward the other adult was neutral (Vaish, Carpenter, & Tomasello, 2010).
Less
Which researcher was influenced by Piaget’s work and used similar moral dilemmas as Piaget’s moral development theory?
Kohlberg
What are the 3 stages of moral development according to Kohlberg?
1) Pre-conventional moral reasoning
2) Conventional level
3) Post-conventional/principled level
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves self-centered reasoning for committing an act, with a focus on maximising rewards and
minimising punishment?
Pre-conventional moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves obedience to authority?
Pre-conventional moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves instrumental and exchange orientation?
Pre-conventional moral reasoning
What happens in stage 1 of Pre-conventional moral reasoning?
Obedience to authority
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on obedience to authority?
A child’s moral actions are motivated by avoidance of punishment
What happens in stage 2 of Pre-conventional moral reasoning?
Instrumental and Exchange Orientation
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on instrumental and exchange orientation?
Focuses on the child’s own best interest or involves an equal exchange between people
e.g. If someone hurts me, it is my right to hurt them back
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves Mutual Interpersonal Expectations, Relationships, and Interpersonal Conformity Orientation?
Conventional moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves the Social System and Conscience Orientation?
Conventional moral reasoning
What happens in stage 1 of conventional moral reasoning?
Mutual Interpersonal Expectations, Relationships, and Interpersonal Conformity Orientation
What happens in stage 2 of conventional moral reasoning?
Social System and Conscience Orientation
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on Mutual Interpersonal Expectations, Relationships, and Interpersonal Conformity Orientation?
What is socially acceptable?
Being “a good girl” or a “good boy” is
important and entails having good motives, showing concern about others
Simply = By being praised by others for being “good” after doing something, children learn to better judge what is right and wrong
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on the Social System and Conscience Orientation?
Fulfilling one’s duties, upholding laws, and contributing to society or one’s group
Simply = When children have moral judgements based on a group’s rules/morals. Children feel that fitting into a group is important and that in social groups, there are rules for a reason. Thus, children follow group rules to fit in.
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves Universal Ethical Principles?
Post-Conventional/Principled moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves Social Contract or Individual Rights Orientation?
Post-Conventional/Principled moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves focusing on moral principles?
Post-Conventional/Principled moral reasoning
Which stage of Kohlberg’s moral development involves centring moral judgement on social relationships?
Conventional moral reasoning
What happens in stage 1 of post-conventional moral reasoning?
Social Contract or Individual Rights Orientation
What happens in stage 2 of post-conventional moral reasoning?
Universal Ethical Principles
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on the Social Contract or Individual Rights Orientation?
Upholding rules that are in the best interest of the group (“the greater good”)
Simply = What is the best outcome for most people? Does this behaviour benefit the majority?
What happens when children’s moral judgements are based on Universal Ethical Principles?
Commitment to self-chosen ethical principles that reflect universal principles
e.g. basic human rights
Asserts that these principles must be upheld in any society, regardless of the majority opinion