Module 8 Flashcards
What 3 things should be true about the judicial system? (Think about the lady justice)
- Should be blind
- Equal
- Justice will be served
What are the 2 judicial systems and what do they mean?
- Adversarial. Judges job is passive
- Inquisitorial. Judge is active, looking for evidence.
What are summary offences? Who are they tried by?
- $2000 fine or 6 months in jail
- Judge alone
When can a defendant choose if the trial is tried by judge or jury?
Indictable offences with a potential sentence of 5 years or less.
What percent of trials is heard by judge and jury?
20
What happens during hybrid offences?
Crown chooses whether to proceed with indictable or summary charges.
What are the 2 legal functions of a jury?
- Decide the facts from evidence
- Decide on a verdict
What is not a function of Canadian juries?
Sentencing
What is step 1 of selecting jurors?
Prepare a jury list
Before bill C-75, how many peremptory challenges could be used?
- 20 for murder
- 12 for anything else
What was done for challenge of cause prior to bill C-75?
2 members of jury would decide whether the juror would be bias or not.
How does post bill C-75 compare?
- No more peremptory challenges
- Judge decides challenge for cause and jurors that served less than 2 years in prison, cannot be excluded
- Judge can continue if pool is below 10
What are the 3 requirements to be a juror?
- Canadian citizen
- Live in the province
- 18 years old
Who cannot serve on a jury?
- Attended law school
- Work in justice
- Member of house of commons
- Indictable offence 2 + years
- Armed forces member
What 2 things can happen of jurors are not impartial?
- Adjournment (delay trail)
- Change venue
Study by Ruva & McEvoy showed what about pretrial publicity?
- Positive publicity has no effect on guilty verdict
- Negative publicity does have an effect
Who convicts more, judge or jury?
Judge
What are 2 general features looked at in jury selection?
- Personality (e.g., Higher score on authoritarianism convict more)
- Attitudes (e.g., Rape myths and peoples beliefs)
What are the 4 ways we can study juries?
- Post trial interviews (Can’t talk about it in Canada)
- Archival studies
- Field studies (limited in Canada)
- Simulation studies
Can jurors disregard inadmissible evidence?
No!
What are the 6 variables studied in relation to a verdict?
- Demographic
- Personality traits
- Attitudes
- Defendant characteristics
- Victim characteristics
- Expert testimony
How does race relate to capital punishment given?
Higher percent of capital punishment given when the race of the defendant and victim are not the same.
How does sex play a role in the capital punishment given?
- If the defendant is female the jurors are less harsh
- Female jurors are also less harsh to defendant UNLESS it is a sexual assault case
How does beauty affect punishment?
- Attractive defendants typically rated less harshly
What is rape myth acceptance (RMA), what is true about it relating to jurors and who presents it much higher?
-Cognitive, affective and behavioural effects of beliefs that blame the victim and exonerate the perpetrator. Failure to resist attack, prior relationship, intoxication, calm demeanour
- In Mock trials, jurors were more likely to make negative judgements of the case aligned with rape myths
- Men present higher RMA
What 2 factors predicted verdict choice when looking at pre trial publicity and RMA?
- Negative messages about the victim = more not guilty verdicts
- People that believed the victim consented = more not guilty verdicts
What are 4 limitations to jury research?
- Deliberations. Group discussions vs individual decisions
- Complexity/length of an actual trial. Low generalizability to the real world.
- Samples not representative of real jury
- People are not always aware of why they make certain decisions