Mind, Body and Philosophy Flashcards
What is the mind-body problems?
Trying to understand the relationship between the mind and body or the relationship between physical and mental properties
What are physical properties?
Height, weight shape, colour, motion
They are observable, public and measurable
What are mental properties?
Consciousness, intentionality
More difficult to measure e.g. can observe if someone is happy but hard to measure happiness
What are the six big questions that arise from the mind-body problem?
What are mental and physical states? Is one subordinate to the other or do they co-exist as separate entities?
Do physical states affect mental states or do mental states affect physical?
What is consciousness and how does it relate to the mind and body?
What is intentionality and how does it relate to the mind and body?
What is the self? How does it relate to the mind/body?
What does embodiment mean? Is the mind housed in the body or does the body belong to a particular subject?
What is dualism?
Believe that something can be broken down into two categories
What does dualism contrast with?
Monism - something can be broke down into one principle/category
Pluralism - something can be broken down into multiple categories
What are the three types of dualism?
Substance, property and predicate
Who proposed substance dualism?
Descartes
What are the types of substance in substance dualism?
Material - don’t have experiences
Immaterial - mental experiences, don’t exist in space
Different properties and made of different things
What is the difficulty with substance dualism?
How do these two distinct substances interact in such a way that physical events can influence and affect mental events
What are the types of property in property dualism?
Physical and meta-physical
How does property dualism relate to the mind-body problem?
When matter is appropriately organised mental properties emerbe. Properties are not reducible to firing neurons or neurobiology instead matter is organised to produce emergent properties like consciousness
What two statements does predicate dualism make?
Mental predicates are necessary for a complete theory of the world
Mental predicates cannot be reduced to physical predicates
What does predicate dualism say about predicates?
Two different types in language - physical and psychological
Required to make sense of world
What is interactionism?
Mental states can cause physical states and vice versa
Problems with interactionism?
If material and immaterial are so different, how can they have enough commonality to interact with one another
Law of conservation - energy can only be converted, how does this occur between material and immaterial
What is epiphenomenalism?
Physical events cause mental events but not vice versa
Problems with epiphenomenalism
Does not help us understand how mental emerges from physical
If mental events do nothing then why would they have evolved
What is parallelism?
Mental and physical events are in continual harmony with each other but neither causes the other
What did Liebniz believe about parallelism?
Pre-existing harmony set up by God ithin universe that meant both physical and mental could run parallel without having to interact