Migration, Identity and Sovereignty Flashcards
8.1b - What is the migration policy in Singapore?
- Net migration rate of 4.26 migrants/1000 people
- Criteria of permanent residence: be 21+, good character and financially independent
- Policy since 1970s ensured that low skilled workers return to source country
- Easier for high skilled workers to gain citizenship
- Work permit system, dependency ceiling and foreign worker levy (management of low skilled)
8.1b - What is the migration policy like in Japan?
- Net migration rate 0.75 migrants/1000 people
- Categories include special permanent resident status, limited duration employment visa, academic research visas
- Main policies include the 1952 immigration and control act, policy tightened in 1990, 70s and 80s - migrants largely excluded from social privileges eg public housing
- 1990 act - permits work related visas and family related categories eg through marriage
- pay to go scheme: pay to leave as a result of the financial crash (2008)
- immigration policy moved to national gov to make re-entry/residency easier
8.1b - What is the migration policy in Australia?
- Net migration rate of 7.49 migrants/1000 people
- Immigration restriction act 1901 restricted non white migration
- Post WWII - Australian gov believed they had to ‘populate or perish’ and began to encourage migration
- assisted passage migration scheme targeting commonwealth citizens with no skills restrictions launched
- current policy: skilled occupation visas - working visa, most commonly granted to high skill workers, student visa, family visa and working holiday visas
8.1c - What impact has the environment had on migration?
- Increasing due to severity/frequency of natural hazards/risk of flooding
- Predicted to cause the largest refugee crisis eg tens of millions
- 2006-2011 - successive droughts, 1.5mil people migrated to Syria with no reliable access to food, water or jobs
- Likely to cause challenges in Europe as demand for food, water ad jobs increases
- Climate change has been referred to as a ‘trigger’
- J - in long term can be seen as an ‘existential threat to civilisation’ - short term can be seen as requiring a new response from humanity (Sir David King) - unpredictable with many uncertain factors so hard to measure impact, both HICs and LICs equally affected
8.1c - What impact has economic events had on migration?
- Financial crisis in 2008 led to an overall decrease in migration
- Immigrants to 24 OECD countries fell by 7% (2009)
- 36% drop in free migration in the EU
- Seasonal migration dropped by 13%
- Unemployment and economic decline affecting immigrants more significantly
- Growing economies eg India and China has led to increased economic migration - Chinese migrants were the number one migrants to OECD countries (9% of total pop)
- Disproportionate effect on migrants causing unemployment and tensions between insiders and outsiders
- However report undertaken in 2011 shows migration has continued to increase with unemployment decreasing as the economy slowly recovers suggesting that is had a relatively short term impact
8.1c - How has political events had an impact on migration?
- 2017 - number of Syrian refugees was over 5m according to the UN
- Concerns that migration fuel for far right politicians and groups during elections eg in France and Germany as policies to oppose refugees and asylum seekers which has occurred
- Political tensions caused increased rates of migration
- Tensions between borders - Turkey - more than 5mil refugees situated - creation of informal camps
- Lebanon - 1mil refugees according to UN but gov state that number higher
- J - rate of migration slow if war comes to an end and many Syrians likely to return to rebuild lives (Ukraine war caused a resurgence)
- tensions between bordering countries = cause anti-migration policy to be popularised
8.3a - What factors affect the rate of assimilation?
- Citizenship
- Education
- Type of employment
- Earnings/money
8.3a - What is Fractionalisation?
Fractionalisation - measures the compute the probability that two randomly drawn individuals are not from the same ethnic, linguistic or religious group.
- Cultural diversity varies considerably from country to country - African countries tend to be very ethnically fractionalised - Europe and Japan tend to be not very ethnically fractionalised - Middle East and South America contains partially ethically fractionalised
8.3a - What are the different attitudes towards intergration of migrants?
- Inclusionary - making it possible for immigrants to become citizens with full rights while maintaining their cultural identities - Australia, Canada, New Zealand and USA
- Multicultural - where for example, programmes have been designed to provide the immigrant pupils the option to complete school education in their mother tongue - Lithuania, UK and Latvia
Netherlands moving from multicultural to inclusionary
- Multicultural - where for example, programmes have been designed to provide the immigrant pupils the option to complete school education in their mother tongue - Lithuania, UK and Latvia
8.3a - Why might assimilation be considered successful in the UK?
- There is no evidence that Muslims are less likely to think of themselves as British than other groups.
- Among those who are born in Britain, over 90% of all groups of whatever religion or ethnicity think of themselves as British.
8.3a - What evidence is there that Turks have been unsuccessfully integrated in Germany? What factors might have played a part?
- Turks live a in a parallel world to the rest of society - formed their own communities separate to the rest of society
- 50% of Germans think there are too many migrants
- 2/3s of immigrant children still can’t read adequately at the end of their fourth year in school
- 30% of Turkish immigrants and their children don’t have a school leaving certificate
- Many who came decades ago didnt want to become part of German society - wanting to earn money and return home after a few years
- Not many speak German - for 30, 40 years the Turks weren’t offered enough in terms of education
Forced to pick between the nationalities
8.4a - What is a state?
A territory over which no other country holds sovereignty
8.4a - What is a nation?
- a population united by language, ethnicity, culture or a shared history
8.4a - What is a Nation State?
A country where a distinct cultural or ethic group (a ‘nation’ or ‘people’) inhabit a territory and have formed a state (often a sovereign state) that they predominantly govern
8.4a - What is the Peace of Westphalia, 1648?
Rule that you aren’t allowed to interfere in one another’s countires
- Westphalian sovereignty is a principle in international law that each state has exclusive sovereignty
8.4a - Why does Iceland have such little diversity?
- Isolated
- Sparsely populated
- Language unchanged 1000+ years
- 74% of the population is Lutheran
- Laws to protect heritage and cultural identity
- 94% of Iceland is either Norse or Celtic
8.4a - Why is Singapore so fractionalised?
- 76.8% Chinese
- Past demographic growth
- Physcial and political geography
- Economic contribution of migrants
- ‘aim is integration not assimilation’ - Singapore President
- Founded in 1819 - polyglot and multi-ethnic
- No one culture for migrants to assimilate into
8.4b - How can national borders occur/come into place?
- Physical geo
- Historical developments
- Colonialism - might not take account of different ethnic or religious groups
8.4b - Why is the border between India and Pakistan contested?
Map of the world is in flux/has been changing
- India-Pakistan border created in 1847 - partition by the British - colonial border
8.4b - What is the Canada-US border an example of?
Physcial border
- divided by Niagara river - tends to be more straight forward
J- Rio grand moves around - can cause disputes
8.4b - What was the Treaty of Berlin in 1880 an example of?
- Colonial/historical power
- Africa ‘divided’ among European powers
- States created without a Nation
- Caused many fights - Tutsis/Hutus - divided by the Belgium
- up to 1 mil deahts in a period of 100 days
8.4b - Why has Israel caused tensions in the Middle East and between ethnic groups?
- 29th Nov 1947 - General Assembly recommended the adoption and implementation of the Plan of Partition with EU - would be am Arab and Jewish state - Jerusalem left out
- 4th May 1948 Israel created - following day Arab Israeli war begins - 700,000 Palestinian are expelled or flee
- Jew around the world encourage to populated new Jewish state - 6mil in 2020
- About 70% of UN member countries recognise the State of Palestine (138/193 Un members)