Midterm 1: Lectures 1-8 Flashcards
Psychology AND the law (Haney’s taxonomy)
Uses psych to examine operation of the legal system, psych viewed as separate discipline used to ask questions about the law and research issues
Psychology IN the law (Haney’s taxonomy)
Use of psych knowledge in the legal system, expert testimony on legal issues
Psychology OF the law (Haney’s taxonomy)
Use of psych to study the law itself, by legal scholars
Why are confessions so influential?
May be fundamental attribution error, the tendency to attribute others behaviour to internal causes such as personality or character traits and to dismiss the impacts of situational pressures
9 Steps of the Reid Model of Interrogation
- Accuse suspect with real or fake evidence, look at response
- Offer possible excuses to justify the crime, get them to accept some responsibility
- Handling denials
- Overcoming objections/explanations
- Retaining the subject’s attention
- Exhibit sympathy and understanding
- Reframe crime as having a good vs bad reason
- Develop admission of guilt into full confession
- Converting an oral confession into a written one
Minimization techniques in interrogations
Soft sell tactics used by police interrogators that are designed to lull the suspect into a false sense of security (sympathizing)
Maximization techniques
Scare tactics used by police interrogators that are designed to intimidate a suspect believed to be guilty (telling them there were eyewitnesses when there weren’t)
Psychological processes in play at interrogation
- Loss of control
- Social isolation
- Certainty of guilt
- Face-saving scenarios
Criticisms in the Reid model
- Inaccuracy in deception detection, can detect at chance level at best, even trained people
- Investigator bias, police have a formed a belief about the suspect guilt prior to interrogation, leads to more coercive behaviours
Legal safeguards in interrogation/arrest
Canadian charter sets out that all suspects must be informed of their right to silence (s. 7) and the right to legal counsel (s.10b). Police tell suspects upon arrest.
R v Oickle (2000)
Standard for court to determine the voluntariness of a confession and its admissibility
When is police conduct improper?
Only deemed improper if it goes so far to “shock the community”
“Mr Big” sting
Police make fake criminal organization and use undercover officers posing as gangsters to trick suspects into giving a confession, generally for a murder
Coerced-compliant/instrumental false confession
A confession that results from a desire to escape a coercive interrogation environment or gain a benefit promised by the police
Coerced-internalized false confession
A confession that results from suggestive interrogation techniques, whereby the confessor actually comes to believe they committed the crime
Employment options for forensic psych
- law enforcement
- substance abuse counsellor
- Parole officer
- paralegal
- caseworker
- victim services
- security
what is forensic psych?
deals with human behaviour as it relates to the law
History of forensic psych
Began in the us and Europe. First experiments done at Colombia university. La suggestibilite by Alfred Binet looked at question techniques. Around 1900’s psychologists began appearing in court in Europe. Hugo Munsterberg advocated for forensic psych and was ridiculed at the time.
Who in Canada played an important role in Forensic psych developement and research?
Dr Stephen Wormith
Roles performed by forensic psychologists
-research that examines human behaviour
-professional practice of psychology in the legal system
-clinician forensic psychologists assess offenders and provide other testimonies
Expert witness
Witness who provides court with info that assists courts understanding of an issue of relevance to the case
Mohen criteria
Canadian standard for accepting expert testimony, will be admissible in court if its relevent, necessary and doesn’t violate any rules and is given by an expert
Internalization
The acceptance of guilt for an act, even if the person did not actually commit the act
Confabulation
The reporting of events that never actually occurred
Criminal profiling
An investigative technique
for identifying the major personality and behavioural characteristics of an individual based upon an analysis of the crimes they have committed. used most often in cases involving violent crimes, though it has also been used in cases of serial robbery, arson, and burglary.
Early attempts at criminal profiling
-Jack the Ripper (probably left handed, wearing a cloak)
-NYC Mad Bomber 1940s’
ViCLAS
The Violent Crime Linkage Analysis System, which
was developed by the RCMP to collect and analyze information on serious crimes from across Canada
Linkage blindness
An inability on the part of the police to link geographically dispersed serial crimes committed by the same offender because of a lack of information sharing among police agencies
Deductive criminal profiling
Profiling the background characteristics of an unknown offender based on evidence left at the crime scenes by that particular offender. Relies on logical reasoning, but this can be faulty.
Inductive criminal profiling
Profiling the background characteristics of an unknown offender based on what we know about other solved cases. Relies on probability and determining how likely it is that offender has same traits given prevalence of characteristics among known offenders who committed similar crimes. Basis of organized/disorganized model.
Investigative psychology
Evidence based method involving stat analysis to examine consistent patterns in crime scene behaviours and background characteristics across diff previous crimes, inductive. Focus on analyszing behaviours occuring during the comission of a crime. Ex: statistical cluster analysis