Medical Ethics Flashcards
What is abortion?
The medically induced termination of pregnancy and removal of a foetus before birth
List the arguments for abortion (9)
- In the instance of rape
- If the mother’s life is at risk
- If the child’s quality of life is compromised (eg. unplanned, unwanted, born into an economically/emotionally unstable household)
- If it is illegal, more fatal backstreet abortions will still occur
- It is a woman’s right to have control over her own body
- It could limit the parents direction in life - If contraception fails
- To prevent the spread of hereditary disease/disability
- At conception, the foetus is just a combination of cells
What are the arguments against abortion? (7)
- It is murder, a foetus is a person/viability begins at point of conception (infringement of the right to life)
- A denial of the sanctity of life
- Adoption is a possible alternative
- Contradiction of the Hippocratic oath
- Abortions can go wrong and threaten life further
- Handicapped persons can still live happily
- People should be responsible for their sexual activity
What is the Catholic Church’s view on abortion?
The Catholic Church opposes all forms of abortion since it holds the belief that “human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception”. Other than in the case of double effect, when the mother’s life is threatened.
What does the General Synod of the Church of England say about abortion?
“abortion is an evil…(but) in an imperfect world the ‘right’ choice is sometimes the acceptance of the lesser of two evils” - General Synod of the Church of England
What is the Society of Friend’s (Quakers) attitude to abortion?
The movement has difficulty finding a balance between the principle of non-violence, which could be used to argue against abortion, and the wish that women should be able to play a full part in society, which may justify abortion. In most circumstances the Quakers condone abortion because it is the most compassionate option.
How did the Westboro Baptist Church protest against abortion?
After a doctor who advocated late-term abortions was assassinated during a church service, 17 members of the WBC picketed outside his funeral service with signs that read “God sent the shooter”, “Abortion is bloody murder”, and “Baby Killer in Hell”.
Jeremiah 1:5?
“I chose you before I gave you life, and before you were born, I selected you”
Which two prominent figures in the Christian church have spoken against abortion?
Mother Teresa and Pope Paul VI
What proportion of women in England and Wales will have an abortion during their lifetime?
1 out of 3
What two controversial questions are raised by the topic of abortion?
When does life/personhood begin? Pro-choice or pro-life?
Until what point during pregnancy is abortion permitted? (viability begins)
24 weeks
What is Euthanasia?
The gentle/painless killing of a person induced to relieve suffering, usually at a person’s request.
Articulate the arguments for euthanasia being legalised (6)
- It prevents suffering and lessens pain. - Everyone has the right to a peaceful death - It would prevent prosecution for voluntary euthanasia - We should have the right to choose how we die - It is cheaper to let patients die than keep them alive on life-support machines. - The health you have in life is more important than the length.
What are the arguments against euthanasia being legalised? (5)
- Doctors take the Hippocratic oath, murder is a crime - It is unnecessary when there are painkilling drugs. - When individuals are mute (eg. in a vegetative state) others might try to end their life, despite a chance of recovery - It would cause religious conflict - Legalisation could be abused, relatives and doctors could force people into it
Define compulsory euthanasia
The theory of enforcing euthanasia on people when they reach a degree of terminal illness or a certain age. No country has ever enforced this, other than Nazi Germany.
What is active euthanasia?
When a doctor prescribes medicine that will reduce a patients symptoms/suffering and induce death (eg. an overdose of painkillers).
Define passive euthanasia
Passive euthanasia occurs when the patient dies because the medical professionals either don’t do something necessary to keep the patient alive, or when they stop doing something that is keeping the patient alive (eg. switching off life-support machines).
What is involuntary euthanasia?
If a person is unable to express a wish to live/die or they explicitly state they would like to live but others implement their euthanasia, this is involuntary.
What did Professor Stephen Hawking say regarding euthanasia?
“We don’t let animals suffer so why humans”
The term used to describe when someone wishes/asks for euthanasia, usually due to a poor quality of life?
Voluntary euthanasia
What is the Hippocratic Oath and when did it originate?
A vow taken by doctors and physicians stating they will never harm patients and their aim is to preserve life. First established in the fifth century.
Case study: What was Sue Rodriguez’s (a mother in her early thirties) experience of Euthanasia?
She lived for several years with the knowledge that the condition she had would eventually cause all her muscles tissue to waste away and she would choke to death, fully conscious. Sue begged the courts to allow a doctor to choose her moment of death but she was denied this right. Rodriguez lived in terror but was eventually helped by a doctor in 1994 who broke the law to help her die in peace.
Case study: The Sunday London Times reported on Joan Smith in December of 1998, what was her experience of Euthanasia?
An accident left Mrs Smith in a coma but aware of what was going on around her. Whilst in this paralysed state, she heard her husband telling the doctors to turn the respirator she was relying on off because he did not want her to live under those circumstances. It was only her daughter’s persistence that allowed her treatment continue and Joan to make a full recovery. (The Sunday London Times, 15/12/98)
Define cloning
The process of making multiple copies of an organisms DNA sequence
What are the two different types of cloning?
Therapeutic and Reproductive