Media Representation Of Crime Flashcards
What is meant by media?
How do you think the media can be restricted on what it reports about crime?
Censorship Filters Propaganda Sensitive information Brand names Print fact not opinion Invade privacy Information available [contempt of court]
Newspapers
How do newspapers represent crime and deviance?
Articles Photographs Headlines Front page is serious enough Don't shy away, they broadcast it Something exciting to read Glorifying Focus on serious crime Dramatic Over-exaggerating
Newspapers
Can they be accused of sensationalisation?
Main aim is to sell newspapers
Newspaper Richard Ericson (1991) and Williams & Dickinson (1993)
Richard Ericson (1991) study of Toronto found that 45-71% of the press and radio news was about deviance and it's control. Williams & Dickinson (1993) British newspapers devote up to 30% of their news space to crime. While the news media show an interest in crime, they give a distorted image of crime, criminals and policing.
Some key words - fallacy
Define age fallacy
The media representation gives the impression that all age groups are involved heavily with crime. When statistically 16-24 male are victims and offenders reported.
Some key words - fallacy
Define dramatic fallacy
The media focus on violent crimes therefore creating fear of crime by over focusing on crimes against these groups.
Some key words - fallacy
Define ingenuity fallacy
Media such as TV and movies give impression that criminals are clever, yet most crime is opportunistic l.
Some key words - fallacy
Class fallacy
Media Give impression that middle class are more likely to be victims of crime.
Some key words - fallacy
Police fallacy
Media give impression that the police are more efficient than they really are.
• on tv the police always get the person
• cold cases
• tv and movies show police are better at their job than they actually are
News valise and crime coverage
Social construction and Cohen & Young
The distorted picture of crime painted by the news media reflects the fact that news is a social construction- made by us, for us.
Cohen & Young- news is not discovered but manufactured (some stories selected, while others are rejected)
News values and crime coverage
What values do you think will influence whether a crime story is involved or not?
If the crime involves someone who is k own in the public eye. Common and not common. The seriousness of the crime. Victim vulnerability. Offender stereotype. Unusual. Impact of the crime.
Steve Chibnall (1977) 'law and order' 8 points List the 8 criteria which act as a guide to the construction of news stories
Immediacy Dramatisation Personalisation Simplification Titilation Conventionalism Structured access Novelty
Steve Chibnall (1977) 'law and order' 8 points Define (1) immediacy
Relates to the present.
More recent, the more interesting.
Steve Chibnall (1977) 'law and order' 8 points Define (2) dramatisation
If drama and action takes place.
Something exciting.
Steve Chibnall (1977) 'law and order' 8 points Define (3) personalisation
Telling details of victim/relatives