media rep of gender,sexuality,disability ethnicity,class,age Flashcards
how do media represent social class neo marxism
celebrate hierarchy n wealth
those who benefit - monarchy, upper class n rich get positive press as celebrities = deservin position
-hardly critical of them or draw serious attention to inequalities in wealth
-upper class think films n tv show their class as eccentric or nostalgic way
how do they represent monarchy
nairn
- monarchy converted much of modern mass media , rare criticism
- reinvented as royal family stood for national values
- national obsession with royal family= positive light
- queen as ultimate symbol of nation
- royal events as national events to be celebrated
how is wealth represented
wealth
focus on postively on lifestyles of wealth
- focus too much on consumer items that only rich can afford
- international news n trade reports impact on business world n investors - not on ordinary working people
- pluralist view rep of rich are justified:
1. media view uk as meritocracy n show wealthy as representative of idea - talented people rewarded
2. stories motivate people to work hard to be rewarded = benefits economy
3. focus on finance,stocks n shares reflect importance of sectors for economy
how is middle class represented?
—MC overrepresented on tv, dramas = predominant
concerned about manners, decency, respectability
—brit newspapers n magazines aimed at MC n consumption = tastes n interests in material goods who can afford it
—content of news suggest journalist believe MC anxious of decline of moral standards = threatened by alien influences
—most creative personnel are MC = dominant positions of authority, experts
how is workin class represented
Jones
curran n seaton
heider
- –few comedy,dama,films focusing on lives of WC
- —Jones = WC media coverage show MC assault on WC values, institutions n communities
- –MC journalists ‘liberal bigotry’ - assume all WC feckless, promiscious, foul racist who hate ethnic minority, multiculturalism, refuees
- –Curran n seaton = news aimed at WC assume they uninterested in serious analysis of political/social or of uk
- –political debate reduced to simple conflict
- –daily star assume they want to read of gossip, lifestyle, sport
- –show their crimes n industrial unrest = narrow
—marxists see media try to distract wc audience from inequalities of capitalism
-Heider = class visibility or invisibility; journalists either choose to cover or not to cover stories depending if a group will be interested . e.g poor victim of crime =story not given same attention if it be someone rich/influence
how is working class presented
—Ghettoisation - WC in media, restricted to narrow rangeof appearances or situations.
association with crime & industrial unrest. Middle-class
representations tend to be broader,
involving a wider range of representations
across professional employment, taking in
work, sport and cultural assoc
how is poverty n underclass represented
cohen
hayward n yar
lawler
- –coverage of media is marginal, causes n consequences of poverty rarely explored
- – Cohen; journalists, artist, bad at realistically reportin/ dramatizing poor problems
- –some intentionaly show poor as parasitic scrounger = reinforce poor as own depravity n weakness
- –Hayward n yar = label ‘chav’ used by news n web as familiar n abuse term for young poor people
- –Lawler = use discriminatory offensive lan to socially stigmatise what they show as peasant, underclass with stereotypical looks e.g tracksuit, idleness, anti social behaviour, criminality, drug
how is age represented
- –rep diff groups of people based on age n generalise n categorise people w stereotypes
- –encourage audiences to assume rep can be applied to all in age groups
–functionalist = rep part of socialisation equip young with values n norms = instilled shared culture,
engage in boundary mainenance = social control part of socialisation - social rules of behaviour
how certain behaviour is disapproved by others n punished
—media help control behaviour of young socially = safeguarding conformity n social stability
how is childhood represented
heintz- knowles
evans & chandler
content analysis of media products - 6 stereotypes
- cute ( in tv commercial for baby products)
- little devils (drama n comedy)
- brilliant (help save adult)
- brave little angels (suffer disease/disability)
- accessories (stories of celebrities’ children humanise them)
- modern (how children know more at their age than previous gens)
—Heintz-knowles = usa tv- children portrayed as motivated by peer relationships, sports n romance
& least y community/school/religious
& rarely shown w societal issues like racism/ abuse
—-positive rep n in pro-social actions like helping others
—-other rep children in anti social behaviour, bulling
- Evans & Chandler = child socialised to be active consumers for toys n games
- —pester power = child to pressurise parents into buying products to increase child status in eyes of peers
representation of youth
wayne
— media aimed to socially construct youth with lifestyle n identity e.g music, magazine, to shape tastes & social medias project identities globally
— seen as social problem, immoral n anti-authority = part of moral panic
concern of behaviour n deviant subcultures
- –Wayne = threat to society, news rarely feature youth’s view/opinion
- – only 1 dimensional picture n encourages fear/condemnation than understanding
- –focus on youth being suspect or victims of crime
- –distract real problems e.g homeless, unemployment, mental health
representation of old age
newman
—upper class n mc elderly people portrayed as occupying high status roles like judge, leadersm expert
- –gender; female tv star given inferior roles as they reach 40 ears while male actors continue play leading role
- —elderly women shown as passive, isolated, poor
- —old men seem to show authority to be on news broadcasting - often with young females but no old women newsreaders - exiled to radio
representation of ageing n elderly
- –devalued in media = more focus on youth n beauty
- –Age charity; media are ageist = negative stereotypes:
1. grumpy - complain modern world n young people
2. mentally challenged - forgetful n suffering, decline of mental functions
3. burden - economic burden on society n physical/social burden on younger people - -media realise they have grey pound = economic power to buy consumer goods
- –show them active, alert, successful, content= positive stereotype unrealistic = not reflect wide range of experiences people have (poverty,loss status, grief)
what does buckingham say about children n media
- –children aware of functions of advertising n sceptical about it (persuade to buy, make it look good)
- –children pestered parents - done with realization they would not get them - not seriously ask for things they wouldn’t get
- –at xmas they used adverts to help them know what they wanted for a list
- –saw other people influenced by adverts = children younger than them
- –children critical cynical about free gifts n quality of adverts = apply own interpretation
- –could read intentions of advertisers
- –before buy toy = saw on tv n tested those their friends bought
- –comparing prices of similar goods in diff shops
what is age - media effects
hebdige
—understand youth subcultures - take into account how media structure way society sees by youth
— Neo marxism = media role to absorb youth subcultures into mainstream society
—not allow youth to resist capitalist society- system try to neutralize them by incorporating them
—commodity form of incorporation = (dress/music) youth cultural signs converted into mass produced objects n sold on high street
= lose threatening n oppositional meanings
—leisuretime only style
how does media represent ethnic minority groups
dijk
- –journalists demonised black young people as threat to law abiding white society
- -stereotype that ethnic minority threat = moral panics
1. immigrants 0 lots of threat, impact housing/jobs
2. refugees n asylum seekers - abuse welfare state, use negative language - harass them
3. muslims - enemy, demonised n distorted by media as threat to security of uk
how does media represent ethnic minority groups
moore
muslims as violent cruel, misogynistic
—stories on terrorism,mslim community, forced marriages, hijab
—rare stories of muslim attacks and islamophobia
4 negative ideological messages of islam:
1. islam is dangerous, irrational
2. multiculturalism allow muslim extremist to spread messages in uk
3. clash between west - democratic, tolerant, equality and muslim world - oppressive, intoleran
4. threat to british way of life e.g muslims wanted to replace british law wihth sharia law = islamic legal system from religious
how is ethnic minority represented
mailk
—black people less seen in drama, big roles, films, news
—asians marked by absence on BBC only 1%
—-racialized regime of representation = black experience is diff n changes relating to audience
in contrast whiteness as norm in media
— white people have no race to rep n black people racialized
how is ethnic minority represented in media
cottle
- –representation appeal to myths, narratives in audience; ones that challenge racist stereotyping
- –rep of race n ethnicity on tv n news cant be counted = but understood as signs to be read in many ways
- –ethnic minorities seen a multiculturalist by superficial focus on festivals, success story n culture = reinforces views of ethnic minorities as ‘other’ n give ideas of disadvantage n inequality
how is ethnic minority represented
gillespie
- –tv n video used to recreate culture of south asians in uk n cause cultural change
- –youth used tv n video to redefine ethnicity = they compare contrast criticie cultures (parents) = dream of american lifestyle from ads
theoretical views of representation ethnic minority
pluralist
neo marxist
marxist
- pluralist = see media as window to world = reflect n report social world in objective way
- –media content shaped by market n control by public
- –black people as criminals n muslims threat show real fears of white readers
- —news act in interest of readers n demand powerful group to take action to control ethnic minority - marixt = media ideological apparatus to divide n rule, distract attention from inequality
- –minority ethnic subejct to moral panics to criminalise them n present as devils threaten stability = more official spending on social control - hegemonic marxist = most owners,editors,journalists white n have consensus view about how society should be = share with white audience
- —consensus way= not risk alienating white audience by focusing on minority cultures or interests = get more audience n profits
- –white experts n sources top of hierarchy of credibility =journalists go to policegov for info on crime/radicalisation/immigration
how does media represent femininity
tunstall
mulvey
kilbourne
symbolic annihilation == women achievement not often reported/ condemned n trivialised
- –when women shown its narrow n limited range of roles n less important achievements
- –biased = rep women as busy housewives,mothers n sex objects, ignore women go to work
—Mulvey: male gaze= women appearance importance n reduced them to sexual commodities to consume
—Kilbourne= media present women as mannequins, tall, thin, sie 0 - use to advertise cosmetics, health, o improve appearance for benefit of male gaze
how does media represent femininity
bates
salinas
martinson
—Bates; music guilty of sexually objectifying women in lyrics n videos
- –Salinas; journalists pass negative comment on way women dress,weight,looks n sexual,famil7 lives
e. g sturgeon - used to reading derogatory things, politics
—Martinson; few media stories of women’s abilities or expertise. Most experts men
femininity media
packer
orbach
—packer; olympics 5% news articles to womens sports = sexualise, devalue women sporting accomplishment
women in sports seen as ‘girls’
- Orbach; media think slimness = success, health, happiness n popular.
- –media encourage young girls n women to be unhappy with bodies = potential eating disorder
femininity media
gauntlett
plant
- –Gauntlett; magazines for young women emphasis women must do own thing n be themselves = women can be tough n independent while maintain makeup n shoes
- –men magazine reassert old fashioned masculine values against feminism
–plant = new media empower women. Internet is feminine technology to destabilise patriarchy = allow women to explore n subvert new identities
–but new media experience sexist rep e.g feminist campaigners get rape n murder threats from online