measuring delinquency Flashcards
the UCR
uniform crime reports- reported by state law enforcement
index crimes
- more serious offenses with higher reporting
- homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, larceny-theft, motor-vehicle theft, arson
strengths of UCR
- provides national estimates of crime in the US each year
- standardization and reliability
- allows for comparisons across regions and times
weaknesses of UCR
- does not account for the dark figure of crime (crimes that go unreported)
- crude , aggregate-level data
- reports are voluntary and often incomplete
what crime do juveniles generally commit
- property crimes such as burglary or motor vehicle theft
trends in juvenile crime over time
has decreased substantially since 1998
what does official data tell us about 4 correlates of crime (age, race, gender, social class)
- males are much more likely to engage in criminal behavior
- juveniles engage in a disproportionate amount of property crime
- we often observe a large racial differences in arrests ( however this does not actually give an accurate picture of what races commit most crimes because there of systemic/institutionalized racial prejudice)- difficult to disentangle differences in behavior versus differences in police practices
- evidence seems to suggest racial differences in offending actually reflecting class differences in offending
self report surveys
- designed to address three major weaknesses with official records
1) the dark figure of crime
2) differential police practices that might promote observed differences in offending
3) more minor forms of delinquency that of not often attract police attention - asks juveniles about their own behavior, even if they are not caught
strengths of self report surveys
- captures dark figure of crime
- captures victimless crime
- can gather information on offender characteristics, causes of crime, and situational info associated with offending
weakness of self-report
- can be time consuming, expensive, and not generalizable
- social desirability bias- answering questions in a manner you think is viewed favorably by others
- subjective interpretation of questions
- memory and telescoping issues
- non random “missing” cases
victimless crime
underage drinking/ drug use
What does self-report data tell us about the four correlates of crime? How does it compare to official data?
age- crime tends to increase from 12-17, then begins to decrease
gender- males engage in more delinquency for almost evert offense
race/ethnicity- race and ethnic disparities are much lower in self report surveys that official data
NCVS
-captures crimes against persons and crimes against households
-surveys victims of crime
strengths of victimization survey
- can capture dark figure of crime
- finds that about 65% of all crimes go unreported
- allows us to examine differential vulnerability to victimization
weakness of victimization surveys
- does not capture victimless crimes and most status offenses
- does not capture when a victim can’t report a crime
- also issues with memory and other reporting issues ay affect data