Market Abuse Flashcards
What are the 3 offences of insider dealings under s.52 CJA1993?
Who do they apply to?
- Dealing in price-affected securities on the basis of inside information
- Encouraging another person to deal in price-affected securities on the basis of inside information
(guilty whether or not that other person knows the securities are price-affected) - Disclosing inside information (other than in the proper performance or function)
Apply to natural persons only
Which securities does the offence of insider dealings relate to? When will securities be price affected? When does a person deal in securities?
Applies to securities listed in Schedule 2 (s. 54 CJA1993) = shares and debt securities
Price-affected = ONLY if the information would, if made public, likely have a significant effect on the securities price
S.55 CJA1993 = a person deals in securities if any of the following 3 are met:
i. They acquire the securities, whether as principal or agent
ii. They dispose of the securities, whether as principal or agent
iii. They procure, directly or indirectly, an acquisition or disposal of the securities by any other person
When will a person have information as an insider?
Section 57 provides that a person has information as an insider if and only if:
• it is, and they know that it is, inside information; and
• they have it, and know that they have it, from an inside source.
What are the 4 defenses for dealing in price-affected securities on the basis of inside information?
s. 53 CJA1993 = NOT GUILTY IF CAN SHOW:
i. They did not at the time expect the dealing to result in a profit attributable to the price-sensitive information;
ii. They reasonably believed the information was disclosed widely; or
iii. They would have done what they did even if they didn’t have the information
Schedule 1, para 1 CJA1993 = special defence = they acted in good faith as a market maker
What are the 4 defenses for encouraging another person to deal in price-affected securities on the basis of inside information?
53 CJA1993 = NOT GUILTY IF CAN SHOW:
• They did not at the time expect the dealing to result in a profit attributable to the price-sensitive information;
• They reasonably believed the information was disclosed widely; or
• They would have done what they did even if they didn’t have the information
• Schedule 1, para 1 CJA1993 = special defence = they acted in good faith as a market maker
What are the 2 defenses for disclosing inside information?
s. 53 CJA1993 = NOT GUILTY IF CAN SHOW:
i. They did not at the time expect any person to deal in securities; or
ii. They did not expect the dealing to result in a profit attributable to the price-sensitive information
What is the means rea for the offences of insider dealing?
The prosecution must prove the defendant had the ‘information as an insider’ = the mens rea
S.57(1) CJA1933 = only guilty if they knew the information was inside information and they knew that they obtained it from an inside source
What is inside information?
• s.56(1) CJA1933 = ‘inside information’ is information which:
- relates to particular securities or issuer(s) of securities;
- is specific or precise;
- has not been made public; and
- if it were made public would be likely to have a significant effect on the price of any securities
When does a person have information as an inside source? (3)
• S.57(1) CJA1933 = a person has information from an inside source ONLY if:
- They have it through being a director, employee or shareholder of an issuer of securities; or
- They have access to the information by virtue of their employment, office or profession; or
- The direct or indirect source of the information is a person within (1)
What are the penalties for insider dealings under CJA1993?
- Person is liable:
- On summary conviction, to a fine and/or imprisonment for up to six months; or
- On conviction on indictment, to a fine and/or imprisonment for up to seven years
Contracts entered into are valid and enforceable
What are the 3 offences relating to financial services under Financial Services Act 2012?
Are the offences mutually exclusive?
Who can commit them?
- Misleading Statements
• s.89 FSA2012 = where a person knowingly or recklessly makes a false statement with the intention to induce another to change their behaviour regarding a relevant investment - Misleading omissions
• S.90(1) FSA2012 = where a person knowingly or recklessly makes a false statement with the intention to create a misleading impression; With the intention to cause profit or loss to another
• Defence = if reasonably believed that their conduct would not create an impression that was false or misleading - Misleading statements etc. in relation to benchmarks
- s.91(1) FSA2012 = a person who gives a misleading/false statement to create a false bench mark is guilty of an offence.
- s.91(2) FSA2012 = a person who does any act or engages in any conduct which creates a false or misleading impression regarding the price or value of investments will commit an offence
Offences are not mutually exclusive
Both natural persons and companies can be convicted
What are the penalties for offences relating to financial services?
S.92 Financial Services Act 2012:
A person who is guilty is liable:
○ on summary conviction, to a fine and/or imprisonment for up to 12 months; or
○ on conviction on indictment, to a fine and/or imprisonment for a term up to seven years
The Secretary of State or the FCA may apply for a court order for the defendant to pay the FCA a sum based on the profits accrued or loss suffered
• FCA will then distribute the sums to those whom the profit should be attributable or who have suffered a loss
What is the UK’s competent authority responsible for ensuring compliance with Market Abuse Regulations 2014?
What are the 2 activities that constitute market abuse?
FCA
(i) insider dealing; and (ii) market manipulation.
What does Article 14 under MAR 2014 prohibit a person from doing in relation is insider dealing? (4)
• Article 14 MAR = a person shall not:
- engage or attempt to engage in insider dealing;
- recommend to someone to engage in insider dealing;
- induce another person to engage in insider dealing; or
- unlawfully disclose inside information.
Insider dealing under MAR 2014 applies to people who possess information as a result of what? (4)
Article 8(4) MAR = prohibition on insider dealing only applies to people who possess inside information as a result of:
- being a member of the issuer’s bodies;
- having a holding in the issuer’s capital
- having access to information through employment, profession or duties; or
- being involved in criminal activities