Lincoln Douglas Debate Flashcards
What year did the NFL add LD debate as a national event?
1979
What are the classifications of values?
Terminal, Instrumental, Main point
Terminal values
Core values (peace, freedom, salvation etc.)
Instrumental values
Help us attain terminal values (Courage, self control, ambition, responsibility etc.)
Main Point Values
Ultimate goal can’t be accomplished without values that make it possible
Which speaker has more time in their speeches?
Negative-Both team have same amount of time, but aff. has more, shorter speeches
What does LD debate stress?
Persuasion, Logical analysis, and Speaking skills
Which is faster, policy or LD debate?
Policy
According to Wiese and Lewis values are…
Universal
What are values, according to Wiese and lewis?
Preferences of how the world ought to be
Are values wrong or right?
Neither
What are the “big three” ways of applying values to the resolution to test validity?
Value comparison, value criteria, value application
Who is LD debate named after?
Abraham Lincoln and Stephen Douglas
What is a terminal value?
A core value such as freedom, peace etc.
What is hierarchy?
Ordering according to the degree of importance or the need for a group of values to exist to reach a terminal value
What is exigence and salience?
The most urgently needed or most threatened hierarchy, as publicly recognized, should win
Freedom/Liberty Maximization
The position that maximizes individual liberty should win
Constitutionality
The position most consistent with the constitutional law should win
Cost-Benefit Analysis
The relative cots and benefits of adopting a value position are weighed against not adopting it
Ends-means analysis
Claims that the ends, means, and intent of a given position need to be in compliance with a previously cited value
Normative Standard
The position that is the ultimate goal of a value or action can be shown to be moral if it universally applies to all people in all situations
Social Values
The position that best reflects the values of society should win
Utilitarianism
The position that achieves the most utility or provides for the welfare of the most people should win
Universality
The superior position in a round needs to be universally accepted by all rational people in similar situations
Value Maximization
The position that achieves the most of a specified value should win
Values are organized as (4)
Moral (Right v. Wrong)
Artistic (Beautiful v. Ugly)
Pragmatic (Practical/Efficient)
Political (Democracy/Justice/Rights)
What are the two forms of topics?
Philosophical (Core v. Core)
Asks for the resolution of judgmental declarations or statements of fact
What is the LD format?
Aff. Constr. 6min. C-X by neg. 3min. Neg Constr. 7min. C-X by Aff. 3min. Aff. Rebuttal 4min. Neg. Rebuttal 6min. Aff. Rebuttal 3min.
What is the Comprehensive value system, or complete thought process for evaluating a given subject?
Model-What frame of mind is needed to accept the topic as true or false?
Premise-Summarize case’s primary claim
Criteria- eg. Constitutionality, Cost Benefit analysis etc.