Lecture Two - Prejudice and Discrimination Flashcards
Prejudice
The systematic discrimination of a group by the people in power. Usually more hostile and based on stereotypes
Stereotyping
Making a categorisation of a group of people and changing behaviour based on that (either positively or negatively)
Discrimination
Not allowing/helping others to have equal opportunities because of something they can’t control. Acting on the prejudice
Schreer, Smith and Thomas (2009)
With everything else accounted for ethnic minorities are treated with more suspicion in public places
Mendelsohn, Shaw Taylor, Fiore, & Cheshire (2014); West (2018); West, Lowe, & Marsden (2017)
Ethnic minorities are less desirable by romantic partners
Bertrand & Mullainathan (2004); Booth, Leigh, & Varganova (2012); Pager (2003)
Ethnic minorities are less likely to receive employment offers
Sommers & Ellsworth (2000); West & Lloyd (2017)
Ethnic minorities are judged more harshly for the crimes they commit
Correll, Park, Judd and Wittenbrink (2007); Plant and Peruche (2005)
Ethnic minorities are more likely to be shot by police.
Green et al (2007)
Ethnic minorities are less likely to receive adequate care from physicians
Auspurg, Hinz and Sauer (2017)
Women are offered less pay for the same work
Milkman, Akinola and Chugh (2015)
Women are offered less support when joining organisations
Neumark, Bank, and Van Nort (1996)
Women are less likely to be offered high paying jobs and more likely to be offered low paying jobs
Bruckmüller, Ryan, Rink, and Haslam (2014); Ryan et al. (2016)
Women are offered fewer leadership positions, disproportionately offered risky or precarious leadership positions
West and Eaton (2019)
Men, compared to women, are less likely to notice or respond to sexism
Augoustinos & Every (2010); Bonam, Das, Coleman, & Salter (2018); McIntosh (1988); Nelson, Adams, & Salter (2013); Swim, Aikin, Hall, & Hunter (1995)
People in privileged groups deny the existence of bias
Andreouli, Greenland, & Howarth (2016)
Liberal young people tend to believe racism isn’t “that bad anymore”, and that it only occurs rarely and in extreme circumstances
Norton and Sommers (2011)
White people in white countries believe racism is a thing of the past and racism about white people is more serious.
Dunning-Kruger Effect studies (West and Eaton, 2019)
Racism and sexism studies support the Dunning-Kruger model. People overestimated their knowledge of these issues and strongest amongst prejudiced participants
Social Identity Approach
A large amount of research has demonstrated that SIT and SCT can explain prejudice… why?
We self-categorise and we have ingroups and we want our group to do better than other groups
We benefit by promoting our group (ingroup) compared to other groups (outgroup) because our group identity is part of our self-concept
If our group does well, then by some measure, we also do well…
The corollary of this is that if our ingroup is threatened then we feel threatened
Intergroup/Integrated Threat Theory (ITT)
The existence of an outgrip can be perceived as a threat. The threats can be real or symbolic
Stephan et al (1998)
ITT has been used to predict prejudice towards Moroccan immigrants in Spain and Russian and Ethiopian immigrants in Israel
Gonzales, Verkuyten, Weesie and Poppe (2008)
Symbolic threats (even not realistic ones) predicted stereotyping in Dutch adolescents towards Muslims
Tausch, Hewstone and Roy (2009)
Intergroup anxiety and realistic threat (not symbolic threat) predicted prejudicial responses from Hindus towards Muslims in India
Von Sikorski, Schmuck, Matthes and Binder (2017)
Hostility increased from non-Muslims to Muslims following terrorism-related media
Watts suburb of Los Angeles (1965)
- Perceived injustice of the arrest of 3 black family members
- $35 million property was damaged, 34 people were killed
- Military called in to restore order
- Notable high level of unemployment, deprivation in African-American communities (99% of population in suburb)
South Central Los Angeles
- Direct response to the jury acquittal of 4 white policemen for the beating of Rodney King
- Set against a background of rising unemployment and deep disadvantage in black communities
- 63 dead and 2383 injured, $1 billion in property damage
- Attacks symbolised by beating of white truck driver Reginald Denny
Stereotype Threat
The fear we will perform according to a stereotype (whether we believe that stereotype or not) - Steele (1997)
Steele and Aronson (1995)
Black participants took either a test of intelligence or a task to develop a new test. In reality they were both testing intelligence. Black participants did much worse than white participants when they knew it was an intelligence test
Stone et al (1999)
White and Black students took a golf test that was: A) a test of sports psychology; B) a test of natural athletic ability; C) a test of sports intelligence. All participants did well in the sports psychology condition. Black participants did much worse in the sports intelligence condition. White participants did worse in the natural athletic ability condition.
Aronson et al (1999)
White participants do worse if reminded of Asian maths proficiency.