Lecture 3 - Intelligence Flashcards
What experiments did Galton do?
Studied twins - to see how similar they were, especially in levels of intellect
- Looked at their behavioural similarities/ differences
He found: The closer the relative, the more similar you are
He argued that you can promote intelligence through selective breeding
What are the 3 Methods of investigating the heritability of intelligence?
- Family studies
- Twin Studies
- Adoption Studies
Outline family studies as a method of investigating the heritability of intelligence
- Looked at intelligence to see similarities in changing degree of relation
- How does intelligence vary as you get further related apart?
- OR compare similarities between biological family (genetics) and adopted family (environment)
X- However, families are usually in the same environment, so it is hard to distinguish nature and nurture
Outline Plomin et al (2004)
% - Mz concordances
- Meta- analsysi into % similarities of intelligence in familys
- He found that MZ raised together had a concordance of intelligence of: 86%
- And that MZ raised apart had a concordance of: 72%
- DZ together: 60%
- Siblings together: 47%
- Siblings apart: 24%
What did Plomins results show about intelligence
if intelligence was entirely the cause, Mz twins should have the same levels, but they dont
- this shows that the environment does have an influence on intelligence
However, Mz twins had better concordance than siblings
- so genetics clearly influences intelligence too
What are typical estimates of IQ heritability in the literature
Ranges from 50-80%
- of characteristics caused by genetics
What can explain the Variance in estimates of heritability?
AGE
- Age of sample may explain variation - IQ changes over age
- Heritability of IQ also changes with age
- As when your a child, everyones environment is the same, everyone goes to school, learns the same things etc
- But as you age, environmental variance differs
What did Haworth et al (2010) say?
Genetics gets more important for your IQ as you age
- across childhood, adolescence and young adulthood
What are the 3 general concerns with studies into the heritability of intelligence?
- X - Studies are not always typical or representative
- X - Haven’t pin pointed a single gene responsible, not sure we ever will
- X - Impact - assortative mating etc can have harmful consequences
Define assortative mating
A tendency to mate with those who are similar to ourselves
- rejects ‘opposite attracts’
- We match on weight, height, socio-economic status, education, ethnicity etc
- Age and geography are very influential factors
- When you mate based on intellect, the bell curve of intelligence stretches out, increasing genetic variance in a population
Outline Watson et al (2004) study into assortative mating
- Studied newlyweds
- Looked at the corrletions of traits
- Intellect: .4
- Body size: .1
- Personality .2
- Within intelligence, Verbal intelligence was most similar
- is it similarities or convergence of traits overtime?
Outline perinatal nutrition as a factor of IQ
- Oddy et al (2004)
- Perinatal Nutrition
- Breastfeeding seen as best for IQ
- Oddy et al (2004) - found those who had breast fed for longer than 6 months had differences in IQ than those who had breastfed for shorter than that
What were the 4 categories of environmental factors that influence IQ, outlined by Neisser et al (1996)
- Biological environment
- nutrition, pre-peri natal, maternal factors - Family
- School/ education
- Culture
Outline prenatal substances exposure as a factor of IQ
- Mortensen et al (2005) - smoking
Fetal alcohol syndrome
- baby is born addicted to alcohol
- cannot function without it - has poor cog functions without it
Mortensen et al (2005) - found links between maternal smoking and IQ scores in 18 YEAR OLDS MALES!
outline prematurity and birth weight as a factor in IQ
- Links between prematurity, low birth weight and IQ
- the more premature, and smaller weight, leads to risks surrounding IQ
What was Mayer & Saloveys (1990) concept of emotional intelligence
- dont worry too much about this one
- Understand own emotions and those of the people around
- Distinguish emotions
- Use that info to guide thinking/ actions
KEY POINT:
- Some can process emotional information better than others, but this doesnt mean you have a high IQ or vice versa
What is a limitation of emotional competency as a concept?
Rigid - suggests you are either competent or incompetent
Define Alexithymia
- Inability to label/ describe emotions, people who struggle with metnal health may struggle with this
What was Thorndikes (1920, 1937) early attempts at emotional intelligence
- Proposed the concept of socia intelligence
- “The ability to act wisely in human relations”
- Intelligence very often operates in a social domain
X - this was far too broad however
- and didnt specify emotional intelligence really, as E.I only includes emotional related information and emotional behaviours
Is emotional stuff an intelligence? or is it an ability?
- It is advantageous for survival so it is an ability
- knowing what a person feels is a behavioural tendency, not an intelligence