Lecture 10 - Neuropsychological Assessment (DN) Flashcards
What are the two fields of Neuropsychology?
- Experimental Neuropsychology
- Clinical Neuropsychology
What is the focus of Experimental Neuropsychology?
- the “normal” brain
Method: animal & human models (e.g., lesions)
What is the focus of Clinical Neuropsychology?
- “dysfunction” - particularly CNS dysfunction &
- its impact on behaviour & quality of life
What are the two main areas of clinical neuropsychology
- Assessment
- Rehabilitation
What is the (NAN, 2001) definition of a Clinical Neuropsychologist?
8:00
- professional within the field of psychology
- special expertise in applied science of the brain-behaviour relationships
9:50
- they use this knowledge to assess, diagnose, treat &/or rehabilitate patients with
- neurological, medical, neurodevelopmental & psychiatric conditions
- as well as other cognitive & learning disorders
What is the difference between treatment & rehabilitation in clinical neuropsychology?
10:50
- Treatment engages some technique applied to a client
- Rehabilitation applies a dynamic interaction between patient, clinician, family & community resources to achieve maximum possible recovery
(we know that most of CNS will not fully recover) but need to work to maximum possible recovery to improve client’s daily life
What are the 4 areas of definition required by the American Psych Assoc for a discipline to be recognised?
- Type of Problem
- Populations
- Settings
- Services
15:35
What type of problems would a Clinical Neuropsychologist attend to?
- characterisation of impairment
- differential diagnosis e.g., between dementia & other conditions
-
measurement of change
- preliminary baseline measurement e.g., Parkinsons disease to track change
- applicable to every dysfunction that can be detected early (huntingtons, MS)
-
prediction of functional outcomes
- e.g., can this person continue to work / drive safely etc)
- planning rehabilitation
- rehabilitation
16:05
What populations do Clinical Neuropsychologists work with?
- Neurological
- brain injury
- Psychiatric
- depression, OCD, schizophrenia
- General medical & surgical
- vascular conditions impacting brain
- Professional
- sports (brain trauma, post concussional syndrome), occupational (exposed to neurotoxic agents)
- Children (learning disabilities, developmental disorders)
22:45
- What settings do Clinical Neuropsychologists work in?
- Hospitals
- Clinics
- Forensic
- Private Practise
25:35
What services can a Clinical Neuropsychologist provide?
- Neuropsychological Assessment
- Cognitive remediation & intervention
- Neuropsychological rehabilitation
- Psychological therapies (for brain dysfunction)
- e.g., personality problems resulting from brain injury may require specific therapies
- Counselling to Public Agencies, Private Companies, Educational Centres
25:50
What proportion of a Clinical Neuropsychologist’s time is spent in assessment?
- 40%
How do current views of Neuropsychological Assessment differ from old views?
Old Views - relevance to current views
- locate the lesion -
- other techniques are better equipped for this (e.g., brain imaging)
- current priority is to characterise cognitive status
- determine organicity -
- do not distinguish between organic & non-organic (psychological)
- current view is that it is always organic & always psychological
- provide a reasoned account of cognitive strengths & weaknesses
- neurological or psychiatric diagnosis -
- this is for a neurologist or psychiatrist
- role is to work out how neuropsych system works and what is not working well
- determine functional (everyday) impact
- provide a neuropsychological diagnosis
27:25
What is the first question one should ask before performing a Neuropsychological Assessment?
- Why is this assessment necessary
What are the two approaches to Neuropsychological Assessment?
- Fixed Battery, Pattern Analysis
- Flexible Approach, Hypothesis Testing
- assess only particular parts of system that you think are causing the problem
How does the Fixed Battery differ from the Flexible Approach to Assessment?
Fixed Battery
- Quantitave
- gives you numbers - interpreted relative to norms
- Outcome Focussed
- scores/performance
- Matrix Vision
- Comprehensive
Flexible Approach
- Mixed Quantitative/Qualitative
- Process Focussed
- why did the client achieve this outcome, what compensatory processes, what could he have done differently
- Modular Vision
- assumes certain systems of brain are specific to certain functions
- isolated on other systems of the brain
- so only focus on module which is dysfunctional
- Hypothesis-driven
What are the advantages of the Fixed Battery approach to Neuropsychological Assessment?
- Systematic
- always done the same way
- Comprehensive
- addresses every possible cognitive determinant
- Objective Interpretation
- scores can be trasformed into deficits or strengths
- Easy to train
- Easy to replicate
37:15
What are the advantages of the flexible approach to Neuropsychological Assessment?
- Patient-tailored
- individuality of each case
- Focus on relevant domains
- not whole system
- Process (WHY) emphasis rather than outcome (WHAT)
- Time efficient
38:00
What are the disadvantages of the
- Fixed Battery
- Flexible Approach
Disadvantages of
Fixed Battery
-
time consuming
- could take 6-10 hours just for administration of instruments
- relies on availability of quality norms
- this is because reliance is on the outcomes
- provides reference framework for interpretation of scores
Flexible Approach
-
Susceptible to bias
- hypothesis may be wrong
- clinician may be misled by certain factors
- could mistakenly exclude vital points
- e.g., referall from lawyer - could bias you by adding relevance to some symptoms
- Relies on training/experience
38:35
How do you determine which assessment approach is better?
It depends on the referral question
42:05
What are some of the most frequent referral questions?
- diagnosis - 70%
- rehabilitation/treatment planning - 48.3%
- forensic - 31.8%
- educational planning - 29.6%
- capacity to work assessment - 27.9%
- establish baseline function for future testing - 24.3%
- assess capacity for independent living - 19.7%
- pre- and post-medical intervention - 9.6%
- localisation of lesion 2.7%
source Rabin et. al., (2005)
42:30
How did the flexible approach originally come about?
- in the diagnosis of certain language disorders
- it was established that using a relatively small number of tests language disorders
- e.g., aphasia could be accurately diagnosed
Which assessment approach is better in the following scenario: Fixed or Flexible?
- Intellectual disability determination
Fixed
- as don’t want to miss anything
- also has other implications
- need to measure against population norms
- findings also need to be replicable as other professionals will likely be assessing
Which assessment approach is better for this scenario: Fixed or Flexible?
Diagnosis of acquired language deficits
Flexible
- very specific referral question
- posterior parts of brain are more modular
- perceptual, language, motor is probably ok to do flexible
- wheras general cognitive ability or memory etc would need Fixed
Which assessment approach is better in the following scenario: Fixed or Flexible?
Forensic determination
Fixed
- Replicability
- Many professionals involved
- Court - challenged, needs to be backed up by systematic assessment
Which assessment approach is better in the following scenario: Fixed or Flexible?
Characterisation of a football players deficits post concussion
Fixed
- in sports concussion
- brain moves a lot - damage may be away from injury site
- best to go broad, so as not to miss anything
51:50
Which assessment approach is better in the following scenario: Fixed or Flexible?
Prognostic assessment of a recently diagnosed multiple sclerosis patient
Flexible
- already have a diagnosis
- know what typically occurs in MS
53:20
Which approach do professionals use?
Fixed, Purely Flexible, or Flexible (combination of both)
- Most people use a combination of approaches
54: 30
What are the four steps of a combination flexible battery?
- An intial “fixed” set of attempts to cover all relevant domains
- (i.e., cover most of cognitive system)
- to develop broad quantitative profile
- Develop hypothesis
- Select specific instruments to examine hypothesis
- Interpretation or Reiteration
54:45
What are the four phases of a Neuropsychological Assessment?
Phase 1 - Interview
Phase 2 - Selection of Instruments
Phase 3 - Administration of Instruments
Phase 4 - Interpretation of the whole assessment
56:25
What happens in Phase 1 of the Neurolopsychological Assessment?
Interview
- Clarify the Referral Question (this should be done before the interview)
- Medical History
- via patient, relatives
- Developmental Milestones
- School/Occupational History
- Psychosocial History
- Symptoms: evolution & coping
56:35
What happens in Phase 2 of the Neuropsychological Assessment?
Selection of Instruments
based on the:
- referral question
- selected approach
- information collected at the interview (phase 1)